2 ms·
I think they were involved in it, but doesn't a murder conviction usually require proof that person X actually did the killing? That depends on your jurisdicti
by patio11 17y ago
I think they were involved in it, but doesn't a murder conviction usually require proof that person X actually did the killing?
That depends on your jurisdiction. I'm not familiar with Italy, but most U.S. states and the federal government do not require actually personally causing death as an element of the crime of murder. If you're a) engaged in the commission of a felony (sometimes, an enumerated list of "really bad felonies") and b) someone dies with cause proximate to the felony you're committing, you just earned yourself a murder charge, regardless of who pulled the trigger. This is called "felony murder". The most common use case is suspects A, B, and C attempt armed robbery on D, D dies in the attempt, and A, B, and C each admit to the robbery but not to the killing. Absent the felony murder theory, you might have to sift through confusing physical evidence and unreliable testimony of self-interested shady characters. With felony murder, your options are simpler: charge 'em all.
- davidw 17y agoAh ok, that's what I was looking for...
- DenisM 17y agoI think there is another reason for this practice: Imagine that one criminal has good leadership skills and is able to manipulate another, weaker criminal. He could then convince the weaker criminal to pull the trigger and escape consequences himself, and then do it again and again with different weak criminals. By sharing the blame the system compels the leader, whoever he is, to restrain the underlings rather than push them to the extreme.