3 ms·
> which now contains anything we ever have written or ever will write It's actually possible to demonstrate that this can't be true. You can calculate an uppe
by lisper 11y ago
> which now contains anything we ever have written or ever will write
It's actually possible to demonstrate that this can't be true. You can calculate an upper bound on the number of different states enumerable in this universe. Basically you assume that each elementary particle is a computer operating at a clock rate of the Planck frequency and multiply by the time between the big bang and the heat death of the universe. The number turns out to be surprisingly small, about 2^500 or so. Longer than this (i.e. any longer than a tweet), and this universe is no longer capable of enumerating all the possibilities.
- edgarvaldes 11y agoSorry, but can you explain this in layman terms?
- ttctciyf 11y agoRoughly: the state-space of the universe isn't large enough to contain a distinct physical realisation of every book in Borges' library, though it is about large enough to contain every possible tweet (I think.)
- lisper 11y agoYep, that's it exactly. The calculation goes like this: There are about 10^80 elementary particles in the known universe. No physical process can happen faster than the Planck frequency (the frequency of light at which a single photon would have enough energy to form a black hole), about 10^43 Hz. The universe is about 10^16 seconds old. Multiply all those numbers together and you get 10^140 = 2^465. Even if you allow 10^100 seconds (a conservative estimate of the time until the heat death of the universe) you still only get about 2^700 possible enumerable states. Of course, if you want all the enumerates states to exist simultaneously then you can only encode one state per particle, and the number drops to 10^80 = 2^265, about 53 5-bit characters, not even a third of a tweet.
- jonotrain2 11y agoThis would only be true if the library stored all of its books on disk. It doesn't need to because of the algorithm it uses to generate the books, which is described here: https://libraryofbabel.info/theory4.html https://libraryofbabel.info/theory4.html (davegauer linked to this description as well) You shouldn't think that this means the books do not exist. The concepts of presence and absence which underlie our understanding of existence were long ago inflected by the existence of virtual archives. Any digital archive, like JSTOR for example, exists as a mass of zeroes and ones, and only enters a form intelligible to the human eye once an article is loaded from its reserve. But I doubt anyone would say that these articles don't exist before they are loaded, come into being from nothing when someone opens them, and cease to exist again when they are closed. Already when Borges envisioned it, the library was more capacious than the universe.
- lisper 11y ago> This would only be true if the library stored all of its books on disk. Disk? Who said anything about disk? The calculation assumes that a single sub-atomic particle can store an entire work. Not only that, but that a sub-atomic particle can generate a different work every Planck time, and store them all. That's really the point: our imaginations are much bigger than the universe we live in. > the algorithm it uses to generate the books, which is described here: Sorry, I don't see the description? All I see is: "I found a successful formula combining modular arithmetic and bit-shifting operations, and the result is the library you see today." It doesn't actually say what the formula is. > Any digital archive, like JSTOR for example, exists as a mass of zeroes and ones, and only enters a form intelligible to the human eye once an article is loaded from its reserve. How is my model any different? > the library was more capacious than the universe. Borges was writing fiction so he was free to ignore the laws of physics. But libraryofbabel.info actually exists, so it is not.
- jonotrain2 11y ago1) You are assuming that the works need to be stored at all. They do not. As long as the same block of text can be located based on the same input, it is just as available as it would be if it were stored on disk or on any other type of storage device you imagine. 2) The PRNG is irrelevant to this point. The article I linked to offers a detailed description of how to generate text without storing it on disk. 3)Your model is identical to JSTOR's, as is libraryofbabel.info's. That's my point - all of these are ways of creating a digital archive (or in your case some sort of quantum archive). The point is that libraryofbabel.info is able to archive more text than your model - more pages of text than there are atoms in the universe. 4)The concepts you should think about more thoroughly are: fiction/reality, existence/nonexistence, actuality/possibility/virtuality. The texts the website contains have a potential existence - each of them can be summoned up at any time. But they do not have the sort of actual existence which would require one or more atoms to be available for the storage of each text. The script capable of generating them all takes up less than a MB.