3 ms·
I run a web site that produces original content at significant cost. We charge a small monthly fee for access. We don't carry ads, and have no plans to. That b
by Silhouette 11y ago
I run a web site that produces original content at significant cost. We charge a small monthly fee for access. We don't carry ads, and have no plans to.
That being the case, how exactly is someone who values our content and pays us for it going to get more ads as a result, no matter how much any third party might want to advertise to that person through our site?
- leephillips 11y agoGood question. Care to share where I can find your site? There are sites like LWN that have a long record of quality content that people are willing to pay a subscription for, that either have no advertising or very limited, unobtrusive advertising that they have not increased for a long time.
- Silhouette 11y agoSorry, I tend to post pseudonymously in these discussions. I see too much risk of the everything-should-be-free crowd causing trouble in the real world if I link to my actual businesses. Suffice it to say that like LWN, the site in question is in a niche area, appealing to people who enjoy a specific activity and think about it a certain way, with little relevance to anyone else. The target audience is large enough to be viable, and we make enough money on it to cover our costs, but it's a small world kind of situation so we have little interest in interfering with the site or risking reputation damage or unwanted associations by carrying advertising. I suppose I'd never say never in business unless there were significant legal and/or ethical principles involved, but right now I can't imagine any realistic offer that would change our minds.
- droopyEyelids 11y agoDoes your website have a business development team that discusses the best way to drive revenue for the enterprise? If not, you may be comparing apples to oranges.
- ethanbond 11y agoThe best way to drive revenue? Go rob a couple of banks and throw them in the corporate coffers. Of course, there's a tradeoff. Just because your form of "driving revenue" includes annoying the living hell out of users while cleanly documenting all of their behavior for surveillance purposes (government or otherwise) doesn't mean someone else's does.
- Silhouette 11y agoNo, it's not really that kind of site. But then many of the sites I value myself and the content I read also aren't that kind of site. There are plenty of people in the world willing to produce good content without trying to maximise every last drop of potential revenue, and who for whatever reason prefer not to carry ads next to that content. Some of them just blog for fun. Some, like the site I mentioned, charge to cover the costs and maybe make some modest profit, but in a niche market you're never going to become the next Google or Facebook anyway. Sometimes the whole site is run for reasons other than direct profit anyway, for example if the site itself is a promotional exercise for some brand or store or charity awareness campaign or freelancer, or if it's some sort of community or government site with its costs covered by other means. None of these sites need to carry the kind of ads I think we're talking about here. Of course there are also sites that are very commercial in nature and do want to do everything they can to maximise revenues. If that means carrying ads, they'll do it. But as long as those sites aren't the only places you can find good content, the original premise will be flawed.
- fixermark 11y agoThe hypothesis in the original article is that advertisers will be willing to pay an unlimited price for the eyeballs of your readers, as their demonstration of the desire to pay for content implies they have money to pay for other things. For this hypothesis to succeed, there must be a price at which your readers' attention can be bought from you. This is a simple theory that falls apart on the details. Of course advertisers won't pay unlimited funds. And if the entire business model of your content product is "View it without ads," there is in fact no price at which advertisers can buy your readers' attention (short of "The cost to buy your entire publishing entity," which is up to you).