3 ms·
While I in no way agreeing with this decision why are these people responsible for the terrible decision of the USPTO? They just get to apply for a patent, not
by danieltillett 11y ago
While I in no way agreeing with this decision why are these people responsible for the terrible decision of the USPTO? They just get to apply for a patent, not issue one. The employee(s) at the USPTO that approved this patent are the ones that should be ashamed.
- jarcane 11y agoBecause flooding the USPTO with an unending flow of bogus patents are partly why those same patents get approved. They're taking part of a system that takes advantage of an underfunded and understaffed agency in order to profit from it in the long term, knowing that they will get away with it for years and be able to milk millions through the courts long before anyone big enough shuts them down. Patent trolling effectively begets more patent trolling, and everyone partaking of it should indeed be ashamed of themselves.
- danieltillett 11y agoThe USPTO is a profit center for the US government. Every extra patent submitted reduces the amount of tax everyone else has to pay. If the USPTO is approving bogus patents then should not the effort be on solving this rather than stopping people applying?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vonmoltke 11y agoNo, it isn't. Look at their budget[1]; very little money enters or leaves the office. The billions collected in the patent and trademark process are all spent on the patent and trademark process. [1] http://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/fy16pbr.pdf http://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/fy16pbr.p...
- danieltillett 11y agoThe most interesting thing about the USPTO report is the decline in patent applications and hence revenue. They have gone from making profits year to year to making a loss last year. It seems people have realised the lack of value of most patents. If people stop putting in bogus patents applications the US tax payer is going to have to start paying to support the USPTO. Lets hope with less applications coming in that the staff at the USPTO have more time to stop these dubious patents being issued.
- notahacker 11y agoNot everybody that patents a [generic description of] a system they're developing has any intention of doing anything other than protecting themselves from others' claims. Aside: I had an interesting conversation a couple of months back with a guy who had a very broad patent on methods of operating a digital auction dating back to the early 2000s which as worded clashed with everything from Betfair to Priceline. He's still far more interested in building a consumer business once he can find people to run it and fund it rather than flogging it to a troll.
- vonmoltke 11y agoWhy did he file a patent in the first place?
- notahacker 11y agoGarden shed inventor type thinks idea is goldmine; doesn't want anyone else to get there first.