4 ms·
Contrast ""And yet Morris sat on his data for years. If there were flaws in his theory, he was determined to find them before anyone else could. 'We set about d
by anamax 17y ago
Contrast ""And yet Morris sat on his data for years. If there were flaws in his theory, he was determined to find them before anyone else could. 'We set about destroying this observation,' he says. 'We brought in outside people with no blood in their veins, no interest, to destroy it.' But they couldn’t."
With "hide the decline" and "trick".
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoA Google Scholar search for science articles with "trick" in the title: http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=trick&num=10&as_subj=phy&as_subj=eng&as_sdts=5&hl=en&as_vis=1&as_occt=title http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?as_q=trick&num=10... This intentional misreading is as misguided as assuming that we are all "hackers".
- anamax 17y agoYes "trick" can have benign meanings. Do you really want to argue that the "trick" in this case is benign? Where's the skepticism among the AGW folks? They were rewarded for finding "confirmation"....
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoYes, in this case the word is clearly used as a synonym for "technique". Here's the original text: http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=154&filename=942777075.txt http://www.eastangliaemails.com/emails.php?eid=154&filen... Even if "hide the decline" was considered to be referring to something dubious, the use of "trick" would still clearly mean "technique". It would be like if a student was breaking into a school computer (i.e. "hacking") and used a tool in an ingenious manner (i.e. a "hack"). Someone could say "That's a cool hack" and it would be clear from the context that they're not complimenting the lawbreaking, but on the creative use of a tool. Maybe if you were later prosecuting that student in court then you'd take that "cool hack" phrase and try your best to sell it to the jury as referring to breaking the law to bolster your case, and maybe they'd buy it, but it would still be obvious to someone who understood the context and culture that it didn't mean what it was being purported to say.
- anamax 17y ago> Even if "hide the decline" was considered to be referring to something dubious, the use of "trick" would still clearly mean "technique". Yes, read the link. The "technique" was concatenating two dissimilar datasets in a way that suggested a trend that simply wasn't there. They had tree data for a certain period of time and then both tree and temp data. They used a model to generate temp data from the tree data. They then concatenated the temp from tree data for the time when they didn't have temp data with the temp data that they did have. They didn't show that applying the same procedure to the tree data when they had temp data did not produce the actual temp data.... Do you really want to argue that the model was good only when they didn't have a way to check it? Yes, it's "creative". The problem is that it's deceptive, or if you like, intended to trick. And the fact that it's deceptive has nothing to do with them calling it a "trick". They could have called it a banana.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoMy point was entirely about the very intentional misreading of the word "trick". If you feel you have a good argument with the tree ring stuff then concentrate on that then and don't ruin it by throwing in the irrelevant fact that they used the word "trick" in an entirely different sense from what you imply. Just like the lawyer intentionally misrepresenting "hack", it might help make a case to people without strong English skills, but it also makes your case seem weaker for anyone who knows how to use the word properly.
- anamax 17y ago> My point was entirely about the very intentional misreading of the word "trick". Except, as I've shown, it wasn't a misreading of the word trick. They accurately characterized their technique. > by throwing in the irrelevant fact that they used the word "trick" in an entirely different sense from what you imply. Huh? I "implied" that they intended to deceive and they did.