5 ms·
The thing about Uber I don’t understand is how they are going to defend their monopoly once they acquire it. Assuming they eventually win all the legal battles
by danieltillett 11y ago
The thing about Uber I don’t understand is how they are going to defend their monopoly once they acquire it. Assuming they eventually win all the legal battles and drive all other taxi and taxi-like services out of business then how are they going to stop anyone else from entering their market?
Each transport market is effectively isolated (you don’t hail a driver from SF to get around NYC). This means any new entrant can achieve critical mass in a market at a relatively low cost (especially if they start with small towns/cities). If Uber do manage to get to the point where they can start extracting monopoly profits they have no means of defending these markets other than competing on unit price. Consumers are going to win big time out of Uber, but I can’t see how their investors will (at least their long term investors). Someone far smarter than me must have answered this?
- dotBen 11y agoAssuming they eventually win all the legal battles and drive all other taxi and taxi-like services out of business That's very unlikely to happen and I don't think anyone here at Uber sees the world as a zero-sum game as you portray it. Even in SF, the most mature Uber market, there are still plenty of cabs operating. Cabs offer a different service (street hails, fixed pricing etc) - which is why you can even hail a cab from the Uber app if you want. Differentiation is key, and that's how Uber does and will compete with both taxis and direct TNC competitors.
- danieltillett 11y agoI also don’t think it is very likely either, I was just assuming the best case scenario for Uber and I can’t see how they can make money in the long term even if they achieve this. Competition is great for consumers, but not so good for investors. Edit. Thanks for the updates to your post Ben. Given Uber’s cost of capital and current valuation how do you see Uber earning enough of a return with a differentiation business model? Or is the current business model irrelevant to Uber’s future and you foresee a massive pivot?
- dotBen 11y agoI think you under-estimate the power of network effects and also the cost of entry to set up an on-demand transportation company. If it really was as easy and low cost as you assert I would suggest you would have seen many other players enter the market already by now.
- danieltillett 11y agoMaybe, but if each market is isolated then the network effect is small. To dominate a market you just need enough drivers available to meet the market expectations. If you have two businesses in a market supplying an equal quality service, but where one is 20% cheaper, then the cheaper service will capture the majority of the market. An alternative hypothesis might be that nobody can think of a way to make money by investing in such a market and so they don’t.
- pbreit 11y agoIf you have enough liquidity you can implement pools and cut prices in half. It is not easy to compete against.
- danieltillett 11y agoMy god I hope this is not Uber’s plan. While this would actually work it is very, very illegal [1]. I can’t see the USA government turning a blind eye to such blatant antitrust activities, but after what they have let the banks get away with maybe it would work. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law
- pbreit 11y ago"Pools" are multiple riders.
- danieltillett 11y ago
- gberger 11y ago> which is why you can even hail a cab from the Uber app if you want How? Is this specific to SF? I've been there a couple times and never saw this option.
- kalleboo 11y agoThere are very differing options between cities and countries. This article shows a bunch of them: https://medium.com/@ImJasonLi/around-the-world-with-uber-1246b0bb796d https://medium.com/@ImJasonLi/around-the-world-with-uber-124...
- noir_lord 11y agoI think (not an economist) but this is what happens when a market is disrupted, new players enter with a lower cost than incumbents, clean up, this encourages other new players to enter at slightly below, first player then drops to match and eventually you reach a new stable equilibrium, in lots of markets that is by one company winning and buying out the others (commodities like Sugar and Salt seem to go this way, it's hard to differentiate on Salt) while others divide up amongst big players (laptop market). Uber will be interesting since the initial capital costs aren't that high (compared to a multibillion dollar fab plant or hundreds of 40,000sqft shops) so it could be a blood bath, alternatively one way of differentiating is on brand and Uber has (despite some negative press) got brand recognition. There maybe a first mover advantage in play here as well, lots of sites clone successful sites (for example) but rarely make a tiny fraction of what the original one did. Something else occurs, Uber took a lot of VC funding, new players entering the market who didn't do that could offer a better deal on both sides of the market and not have the millstone around their necks either, it would be amusing if a smaller nimbler non-VC company ate their lunch.
- danieltillett 11y agoIndustries like sugar and salt are commodity industries where prices are driven by costs. There are economies of scale that allow one player to dominate a market and prevent new entrants. Uber does not have this advantage since each market is effectively small and isolated (there are thousands of taxi markets in the USA alone) and most of the costs are unit costs, not fixed costs over which they can scale. Any competitor with lower costs - say a business that used only one fuel-efficient car type that offered lower unit costs should be able to outcompete Uber. The contractor model where each contractor purchases and services the needed physical equipment (i.e. cars) is far from the most efficient way to run a capital intensive business.
- noir_lord 11y agoThat was pretty much what I was saying yes :).
- braythwayt 11y ago
- onewaystreet 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_leader https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_leader They use their revenues and funding to subsidize lower prices in key cities than their competition can afford. They already do this in a few cities.
- danieltillett 11y agoSure, but their investors are going to want them to start extracting profits at some point in the future. You can’t run an business indefinitely selling below your costs. The question I have is how are they going to be able to start doing this without opening themselves up to competition?
- dylanjermiah 11y agoIt is rare to see, of not impossible, a real monopoly in a free market. Uber has to compete to win customers, if they artificially raise their prices to where people will not pay, people will choose a different form of transportation.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes this is the problem. Unless investors don’t care about returns how will Uber extract the profits required to justify their current valuation?
- dylanjermiah 11y agoFirstly, I have no inside knowledge of their complete model, just assuming. Travis has said that the early markets are 'profitable', the early markets are also their most competitive. So the 20-30% model they have now should allow profitability in all the 300+ cities they're in. I'm assuming the margins are very tight, and that they have to do a lot of volume to be hugely profitable, which they're fast approaching.
- pbreit 11y agoI think Ubers monopoly will be at least as strong as Ebay's in online auctions. There's a humongous liquidity advantage.
- dylanjermiah 11y agoThe common definition of 'monopoly' is the sole provider of a good or service. I doubt very much that Uber can ever achieve that. I much prefer 'market share', I think it's the most accurate term. Aside from that, I do see some parallels with eBay.
- lallysingh 11y agoYou can start in a niche and grow out. Like Brooklyn.
- eru 11y ago
- pbreit 11y agoIt's pretty much a natural monopoly and very difficult to compete against once in place.
- danieltillett 11y agoHow is it a natural monopoly? A natural monopoly is something like the electrical poles and wires. I can't see how Uber could even become a normal monopoly even if everything went their way.
- pbreit 11y agoIn most of their cities they are already a monopoly or near monopoly. Liquidity is a hugely massive advantage for both drivers and riders.
- eru 11y agoBoth riders and drivers can use multiple apps without too much hassle.
- danieltillett 11y agoExactly. If you know a competitor can provide the equivalent service quality, but at significantly lower price, then users will switch. In a small market it is not too hard to let potential users know you exist and install your app.
- MarkMc 11y agoBoth buyers and sellers of second-hand goods can use multiple auction websites without much hassle, yet eBay still has a natural monopoly due to network effects. I doubt the network effect for uber is as strong as ebay, but I wouldnt completely dismiss it either.
- roymurdock 11y agoWhat do you consider "monopoly profits?" As of the 2013 leak, Uber was grossing $1bn in revenue [1]. Uber takes a 20% cut from each transaction, and has an extremely lean cost structure - drivers pay for gas, insurance, amortize vehicles, don't get any benefits, etc. Even if we assume costs to be 10% of revenue (which they aren't), Uber still would have earned a gross profit of $100m in 2013. Judging by Uber's current $50bn valuation, their revenues have grown anywhere from 3x-5x over the past 2 years. [2] So by my rough estimations they're making $300-$500m in yearly profit (hardly loss-leadership), and they still haven't driven Lyft or conventional cabs out of service. This is also without taking geographical expansion into consideration. Uber is sitting on a goldmine of a market that it has barely begun to tap. So what if Uber does manage to establish itself as a monopoly? Then we look to the price elasticity of demand for Uber's service, which measures change in demand over change in price, aka how bad people actually need the service. Cabs are essential to a large group of people (businessmen, tourists, blind, etc.) and in high demand for almost anyone else that lives in a large city such as NY or SF, where it is uncommon to own a car and often inconvenient to take the metro. Therefore they will have a large bandwidth in which to raise their prices in large cities before users start to disengage with the service, opting instead to walk or take the metro. Smaller towns, where people don't use cabs as much, do not present a large market for Uber, but it costs them next to nothing to get users and drivers to download the app, therefore there are no prohibitive costs of investment stopping them from expanding operations other than a natural lack of demand. If they jack prices up too high for an extended period of time in the cities, another company will enter the market and pick up the churned customers, much as Uber did in the broken, monopolistic taxi market. So ultimately they will be able to make a very healthy profit, and will not need to worry too much - unless the government decides to intervene with some serious anti-trust legislation, but it probably won't as long as Uber is paying a cut to the cities that it operates out of. You are right that there are low barriers to entry in this market - it's why most drivers do both Uber and Lyft. The underlying technology is the same, and the capital (drivers) is not proprietary and can be shared between different companies. However, if Uber were to stipulate that drivers sign an employment contract, and then enforce that they were not working for the competition, this would raise the barriers to entry for competitors. Likewise, there isn't much differentiation in the taxi market. It's nice if a driver comes with water and a nice-smelling car, but ultimately it's not a deal breaker. Ultimately, the network effect is key. Get the most users on your service, get the most drivers driving for you, beat the competition, then erect barriers to entry around your castle. Just don't piss the peasants off too much, or they might try and revolt :) [1] http://techcrunch.com/2013/12/04/leaked-uber-numbers-which-weve-confirmed-point-to-over-1b-gross-revenue-213m-revenue/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/12/04/leaked-uber-numbers-which-w... [2] http://www.forbes.com/sites/chrismyers/2015/05/13/decoding-ubers-50-billion-valuation-and-what-it-means-for-you/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/chrismyers/2015/05/13/decoding-u...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- danieltillett 11y agoAny new business can establish an equivalent to uberpool once they have critical mass. Since many markets are small the relatively cost of establishing this mass is not excessive.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- danieltillett 11y agoYes network effects are real - the question is there much of a network effect with the taxi industry. History suggests there isn’t, but the current valuation of Uber suggests that a lot of smart money thinks there is such an effect.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- danieltillett 11y ago>There is no history for something like UberPool Actually there is a lot of history for this - go to any third world country and this is how most of the taxis for locals run. It is actually one of the outcomes of a lack of enforced regulation since competition drives unregulated drivers down this path.
- morgante 11y agoI think you're significantly downplaying the network effects inherent in Uber's model. Yes, those network effects might be localized (each city is its own network), but they're still incredibly strong. Drivers want to be where the riders are and riders want to be where the drivers and other riders are. (As a rider, I want there to be a healthy rider pool so I can do sharing.) Additionally, Uber doesn't have to jack up prices (with "monopoly pricing") to earn a healthy profit. In its mature markets, it's already quite profitable. Given that, where do you think there is an opening? If it's so easy to compete with Uber on a local level, why isn't Lyft beating it in any single market (despite $1b raised)?
- danieltillett 11y ago>Given that, where do you think there is an opening? If it's so easy to compete with Uber on a micro level, why isn't Lyft beating it in any single market (despite $1b raised)? The market is going through a lot of innovation right now and what the end result will be is not known. I just can’t see how even if Uber wins that they have a way of preventing competition eroding their margins. All the regulation in the taxi industry was driven by the players wanting to control the cut-throat competition that existed before regulation. Competition is great for consumers, but not so good for the owners of taxis.
- morgante 11y ago> All the regulation in the taxi industry was driven by the players wanting to control the cut-throat competition that existed before regulation. The difference is that traditional taxis had no monopoly power. They were (and are) undifferentiated commodities—I don't even have any idea who owns a cab I'm in. Uber's network is a substantial moat which protects it from undifferentiated price competition. Again, how do you propose that a competitor would build a viably competitive network in an Uber city?
- danieltillett 11y ago>Again, how do you propose that a competitor would build a viably competitive network in an Uber city? I would pick mid-size markets and optimise for unit costs. I would settle on a single fuel efficient car model (or two) and then work on making my capital and servicing costs as low as possible. I would use trained and experienced employees and implement tracking technology to ensure that the drivers are polite, prompt, efficiently located, and don’t drive the vehicles like taxi drivers do (helping keep wear costs down). I would then bombard the local media market to achieve name recognition and app take up and then run a price war to gain market domination. Since I had optimised for unit cost I should be able to defend this domination against new entrants as long as I kept my pricing at just above my costs. I would make little profit, but my market would be defendable. Rinse and repeat in each new markets. I don’t think such a business is worth the effort, but all it take is one person who does.