8 ms·
I don't really like Uber's business practices but they do fill an essential niche in New York City. A couple years ago, the city allowed independent car servic
by jrockway 11y ago
I don't really like Uber's business practices but they do fill an essential niche in New York City.
A couple years ago, the city allowed independent car services to paint their cars green and take street hails. They previously did this, of course, but it wasn't legal. And of course, not every "black car" became a green cab, so this still happens. It's the standard way to get around the outer boroughs of New York.
I watched a very common event unfold the other day in Brooklyn Heights. A woman hailed a green cab. It pulled over and the driver opened the window, asking "where to?" The woman mentioned an address in Manhattan. The driver said, "sorry, green cabs can't go to Manhattan" and drove away.
That is 100% false. Like yellow cabs, green cabs have to take you anywhere in the five boros, but they're reluctant to take you to Manhattan because they aren't allowed to pick up fares there. They have to drive back to Brooklyn empty and not make any money, so they lie to customers to avoid that. The end result is that you still can't get a taxi in most of New York City, at least one that will pick you up near where you live and take you exactly where you want to go.
The "ridesharing services" rectify this problem; I've never had an Uber driver refuse to take me anywhere. If the licensed taxis want to be free from competition, they need to follow their own rules.
Anyway, this Forbes article about green cabs tells the exact same story: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johngiuffo/2013/09/30/nycs-new-green-taxis-what-you-should-know/2/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/johngiuffo/2013/09/30/nycs-new-g...
- zschallz 11y agoEven the yellow cabs within Manhattan would not take me places within Manhattan when hailed. They would stop and ask where to-- when I told them where (touristy areas) they'd just drive off.
- jrcii 11y agoAs a seasoned New Yorker I've learned that the best response to "where to?" is to silently get in the cab.
- arthurcolle 11y agoWhen do you drop the tidbit of information related to the whole reason you got in? /just moved to NYC
- jrockway 11y agoAfter you're inside and the door is closed. This is the only way you can get to the airport during the "shift change" that's right around PM rush hour. Nobody will take you there if you tell them you want to go there. That said the new Q70 bus from Jackson Heights (7/E/F/M/R) is quite efficient, and I don't bother with cabs anymore. Not worth paying someone $40 to bitch and moan about going to the airport when the MTA can get you there, from Brooklyn, in less than an hour for $2.50.
- greenyoda 11y ago"Jackson Heights (7/E/F/M/R)" Also ten minutes from Penn Station on the LIRR, whose Woodside station is next to the subway station (a bit more expensive than the subway, though).
- jrockway 11y agoYeah. The Q70 starts at Woodside, actually. I personally always take the LIRR to Jamaica when going to JFK. It's a bit nicer than taking the E (from Manhattan), and a bit faster than taking the A (from Brooklyn, get the LIRR at Atlantic Terminal) because the Jamaica AirTrain seems to run more frequently than the Howard Beach AirTrain. The LIRR also runs on an actual schedule, so you will end up at the airport when you expect, which always makes things less stressful.
- gfodor 11y agoI remember I once needed to catch a cab to the airport at this time, and I was lugging a big ass suitcase. Knowing full well that standing on the side of the road with that suitcase, a cabby would never stop, I hit it behind a tree. I hailed the cab, open the passenger door, then said "one sec", ran and grabbed the bag and dragged it into the back seat with me. Oh man, was he pissed.
- soyiuz 11y ago"It is against the law for a taxi driver on duty to refuse to pick you up because of race, disability, or destination within New York City." http://www1.nyc.gov/nyc-resources/service/2599/yellow-taxi-complaint http://www1.nyc.gov/nyc-resources/service/2599/yellow-taxi-c... Write down their licence plate if this ever happens and report. Otherwise, as has been said: get in first then address always.
- CaptainApathy 11y agoIn grad school I worked part time for the city's non-emergency 311 help-line and took several calls related to taxi complaints. The process may have changed since then (early 2000's), but it's not a very friendly process for the individual making the complaint. The person making the complaint is required to show up for a hearing, in person, at a date and time determined by the TLC, to present her complaint to a panel of "judges." The driver is also required to show up and to present their side of the story. My understanding is that they almost always find in favor of the complainee, even when there's no evidence and it's the driver's word vs. the complainee's. After the third judgment the driver loses their license. So on one hand making a complaint is far more difficult than poorly rating a driver on a phone, a process that takes almost no effort. But on the flip side the complaints that were processed were taken very seriously and had very real repercussions.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dilap 11y agoIt's less of a problem for uber though because (1) it only applies when there's no good uber driver match, not when the uber driver doesn't want to go where you're going (because then they'd get a bad review, or worse) (2) I'm not sure, but I believe there are penalties for drivers who cancel too much.
- Pyxl101 11y agoUber drivers can see where you are as part of evaluating your ride request. Consequently, though your ride request might be offered to several drivers before being accepted, you are not likely to be assigned a driver who cancels later because of your location. Furthermore, Uber drivers are not allowed to refuse more than a certain small percentage of rides, so drivers who do this more than rarely will be kicked out. It's more likely that a driver will be reluctant to go where you want to go. Though this can happen, Uber passengers will rate the driver poorly, and they'll be kicked out. Uber's star rating system and insistence on keeping drivers only with good ratings is part of why people enjoy using the service. Drivers can't pull shit like that and get away with it.
- jrockway 11y agoI have had a case of an Uber driver not really wanting to drive me to Marina del Ray from downtown LA. He gave me a low review (this was back when there was the bug that let you see your rating). The biggest problem I have with Uber is that some of the drivers are so pleasant and professional that I hate not being able to give them an extra tip. Maybe I should figure out how to do that.
- vacri 11y ago> Maybe I should figure out how to do that. Why wouldn't cash work?
- 11y ago
- sillygeese 11y ago> A couple years ago, the city allowed independent car services to paint their cars green and take street hails. Does anyone else see the absurdity in that? Compare to: "In 2014, the city allowed people to wear green socks" If you want to transport people for a fee, what rational, moral justification is there for anyone to intervene in that? -To decide what colour your car should be, or where you can pick up customers?
- mhaymo 11y agoThe road is a limited common resource, and it's difficult to directly charge drivers per their usage of it, so the local government uses other forms of regulation.
- sillygeese 11y agoRoads could be private too, and payments could be collected for (and only for) using them, even without setting up a state-maintained taxi monopoly/cartel. So I'm not sure what you think is currently handled well.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoIt's not difficult at all. Gas taxes pretty much pay for this. Congestion charges also work nicely in cities.
- arbitrage 11y agoGas taxes are less equitable now with more electric vehicles.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoAs electric cars become more common, we can lower gas taxes to the point that they only cover environmental externalities and switch to a weight x mileage tax for roads. (Mileage to be measured at vehicle inspection time and incorporated in registration fees.)
- 11y ago
- soyiuz 11y agoJust to clarify: green cabs are allowed to pick up street hails in Manhattan, North of West 110th street and north of East 96th street. http://www.nyc.gov/html/tlc/html/industry/shl.shtml http://www.nyc.gov/html/tlc/html/industry/shl.shtml The city now also promotes its own hailing app called Way2Ride, which has Uber-like features (pay by mobile and request hail to location). https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.verifone.way2ride&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.verifone.w...
- humanrebar 11y agoUber and other companies are itching to fill the role of taxi hailing app. Why does the city need to promote its own? This sort of arbitrary anti-competitiveness is exactly why Uber has a niche to fill in the first place.
- juliangregorian 11y agoHuh? Isn't having a competing taxi hailing app the definition of competitiveness?
- humanrebar 11y agoIt's a portal provided by the government (through a contract). It's may be competitive for taxis (that's an empirical question, I think), but it's not competitive in terms of algorithms, ratings systems, predictive taxi distribution, etc.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> it's not competitive in terms of algorithms, ratings systems, predictive taxi distribution, etc. Isn't that for the market to decide? :)
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> The "ridesharing services" rectify this problem; I've never had an Uber driver refuse to take me anywhere. If the licensed taxis want to be free from competition, they need to follow their own rules. This is because all hails on Uber are tracked, and enough refusals would be noticed, and the driver would be fired. It's shitty that green (or yellow) cabs do this; there should be a way to hold them accountable, but for now there is a stop-gap solution: lie. Get in before telling them your destination. If they don't let you, lie and say you're going to somewhere in Brooklyn, then change your mind. As soon as you hear them begin to complain, snap a photo of their cab number, and start dialing 311.
- cheald 11y agoIt's a lot less hassle, effort, and stress to just use a service that actually wants my business, though.
- somebodyother 11y agoAlso, sometimes you're trying to get somewhere very reasonable in Manhattan, but you can't hail a cab because of your, say, skin color. Uber solved that.