3 ms·
A bit is no different than a letter/grapheme of a text, which was what copyright originally was designed to protect. They are both digital (discrete) encodings
by icebraining 11y ago
A bit is no different than a letter/grapheme of a text, which was what copyright originally was designed to protect. They are both digital (discrete) encodings of information - a computer file is just a text in a language that only has two letters. The law doesn't concern itself with the specifics of the components of the work, it concerns itself with higher-level concepts like "copy" and "derivative", which still make perfect sense for information encoded as bits.
As for the failure, I disagree. This case merely represents ambiguity, which is inherent to law (it's why we have courts and judges and juries).