6 ms·
Charges Against Netzpolitik.org Are an Attack on the Free Press
- themeek 11y agoGermany's Secret Service just charged their leading Civil Rights group on treason for publishing information about the German government's plans to further expand domestic mass surveillance. This is not different than what has happened in the United States - though the US uses National Security Letters, gag orders, financial and criminal leverage and defamation - its only when these don't work that the US will reach toward the Espionage Act. We look back in history and question why citizens in history asked their governments to send civil rights activists to prison and to silence certain stories in the press. Today we get modern answers to these questions at least every few months. I have polled friends, family and acquaintances: the overwhelming response is that we don't feel safe. I have also sampled the official stance from press releases and speeches: the overwhelming justification is that we are not safe. As all things are, the truth is much more complicated.
- nickbauman 11y agoEspionage is not treason.
- dragonwriter 11y agoThe Espionage Act in the US serves a similar role to the broader treason laws in many other countries, which often include the kind of offenses included within the Espionage Act. So, while "espionage" and "treason" are, indeed, different words, being prosecuted for what German law calls treason may well be more analogous to being prosecuted in the US under the Espionage Act than it is to any other US offense.
- rayiner 11y ago> This is not different than what has happened in the United States - though the US uses National Security Letters, gag orders, financial and criminal leverage and defamation - its only when these don't work that the US will reach toward the Espionage Act. The hell it isn't. When did the U.S.G. hit the ACLU with treason charges?
- themeek 11y agoNot the ACLU. James Risen. Journalist.
- dragonwriter 11y agoOk, when was James Risen charged with treason by the US? AFAICT, the most significant legal battle he's had with the US Justice Department was over the latter's attempt to force him to testify in the trial of Jeffery Sterling, a former CIA officer charged with leaking. Risen himself hasn't been charged with anything.
- themeek 11y agoHe was charged with the Espionage Act. Please refer to the original comment to see that I did not claim the US charges individuals with treason. Risen got it better than others though in some ways. Binney and his family were held at gunpoint. Nacchio was blackmailed.
- rayiner 11y agoSource that Risen was charged with the Espionage Act? The Wikipedia page just mentions Sterling. Binney was never indicted for anything. As for Nacchio: http://www.marketwatch.com/story/qwests-joseph-nacchio-tries-to-rewrite-history-2014-04-03 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/qwests-joseph-nacchio-tries... ("Nacchio, after all, had deep pockets and millions of dollars in legal indemnification from Qwest. He fully exhausted the federal-appeals process and still lost his case, Eid said.")
- themeek 11y agoYou are right about Risen and Sterling. I think you get the point though. The leverage placed on Risen to reveal his sources and the placement of Sterling under the Espionage Act - the use of backroom deals to keep Risen's publication of mass surveillance out of the Times when it was first published - the use of NSLs - the hacking of the Associated Press to spoil their sources during the Benghazi Affair. The US uses these things to curdle journalistic coverage and their sources. Binney wasn't indicted for anything. He and his family was held at gunpoint and threatened. The link you gave just had people calling Nacchio pathetic. Was there a specific fact you were trying to highlight? (I mentioned character defamation in the top post.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nickbauman 11y agoWhat does German law consider "Treason"? In the US, treason has a very specific meaning regarding the Mens rea of the accused. You have to prove that the accused meant to do harm to the republic by the action. (For example even worst case scenario, Snowden could never be accused of treason because there was no intent to harm; quite the contrary.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mens_rea
- cremno 11y agoThe second link in the article is: http://www.iuscomp.org/gla/statutes/StGB.htm#BII http://www.iuscomp.org/gla/statutes/StGB.htm#BII It's an English translation from 1998 but § 94 StGB hasn't changed since 1975: https://dejure.org/gesetze/StGB/94.html https://dejure.org/gesetze/StGB/94.html
- baertram 11y agoIt has more or less the same legal meaning. I have seen no evidence for any "treason" charges (according to §94 StGB), the charges are most likely "disclosure of secrets" (§353b StGB). The cause for the confusion of the terms is most likely the relation of the words. "Verrat" -> "the act of treason" "Verräter" -> "traitor" versus: "jemanden etwas verraten" -> "to disclose something to someone" "Geheimnisverrat" -> "disclosure of secrets"
- itistoday2 11y agoTry not to get confused: writing about mass-surveillance plans is treason, the secret non-consensual mass-surveillance itself is not.
- itistoday2 11y agoTo the downvoters: are you really that frightened to consider the possibility that the government is abusing its relationship with you? What if your spouse treated you this way? Would you not feel betrayed if one day you found out that they were monitoring all of your communications "for your safety" without informing you or asking for your permission?
- rbehrends 11y agoThe reporting on this issue can at best be described as muddled, including the original articles by netzpolitik.org. They are not actually investigating netzpolitik.org, but their (unknown) sources (clarified in a later article [1]), presumably for leaking the information. "Treason" is a misleading translation; the closest equivalent to "Landesverrat" would probably be "espionage". The leaked documents were (1) parts of the budget of the domestic intelligence service, the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, and (2) plans by the same institution to create a new unit to conduct internet surveillance. Because these are purely domestic issues, it is unlikely that the leak qualifies as "Landesverrat", which requires creating a grave danger for the external security of the Federal Republic of Germany (creating a danger for Germany's internal security is insufficient, and neither is embarrassing the government, including in international affairs). Leaking the documents is still likely a crime under §353b of the criminal code [2], but the German Federal Prosecutor is not competent to prosecute violations of §353b (this is the prerogative of the state prosecutors). [1] https://netzpolitik.org/2015/generalbundesanwalt-bestaetigt-strafanzeige-des-verfassungsschutzes-gegen-unsere-quellen/ https://netzpolitik.org/2015/generalbundesanwalt-bestaetigt-... [2] http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stgb/englisch_stgb.html#p3016 http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stgb/englisch_stg...
- itistoday2 11y agoThanks for pointing that out! I hope the EFF updates their article. Question: how can they push charges on the sources if they do not know who the sources are? (Or do they?)
- baertram 11y agoIf they don't know, they can still file charges against "Unknown" ("Anzeige gegen Unbekannt")
- Tomte 11y agoI hope the EFF updates their article. Don't hold your breath. People don't like to acknowledge it, but the EFF is a lobbying organisation with an agenda, not some kind of disinterested "super court for Internet issues". And the last months have shown that they have a habit of "misunderstanding" things and writing over-sensationalist press releases. I mean, virtually everytime some press release of the EFF is discussed on HN, commenters have quickly pointed out factual errors or non-sequiturs.