16 ms·
Uber has defeated Bill de Blasio’s plan to rein them in
- josh2600 11y agoCan't stop, won't stop. Uber continues to amaze me with their incredibly skillful political maneuvering. They seem to have roadblocks thrown in their way at every turn and they manage to just keep trucking. Heads down, eyes on the prize; it's really quite impressive to watch. I have to believe it starts at the top with a tunnel vision approach to revenue growth. It's like that old Al Davis quote "Just win baby!". Whether you agree with what they're doing or not, it is incredible to watch their execution.
- pbreit 11y agoIn this case it looks like its lobbying lost but its PR won. Despite that it reluctantly turned over its data, every news outlet portrayed it as a victory.
- rquantz 11y agoYes, a company with an illegal business model stayed under the radar until they got big enough that they could combat the legal challenges to their illegal business model. Always a pleasure to watch.
- marssaxman 11y agoWhen their business model is only illegal due to a corrupt, inefficient, entrenched monopoly which is just as hostile to its customers as its employees, yes, it is indeed a pleasure to watch someone take on the machine and win.
- beatpanda 11y agoWhere "winning" is the normalization of precarious labor where the employee assumes all risk and somehow makes even less money than they did in "the machine". Oh, but you got to the club a little faster. Baller, bro.
- bitJericho 11y agoWhat, a fair wage? Clearly that's un-American.
- marssaxman 11y agoI make a point of asking Uber and Lyft drivers how they like it. Lyft drivers universally love it. Uber drivers are less enthusiastic on the whole, but they have generally said it's better than working as a cab driver. I've since stopped using Uber since it's hard to feel comfortable about their business practices, but they're still better than the taxi monopolies and I'm happy to see them pursuing the fight and clearing the way for kindler, gentler services along the same lines. I am generally inclined to think that people should be free to make their own decisions about their lives. Whatever you may think about the risk/benefit tradeoff, it seems clear to me that drivers in Seattle who have the choice choose to drive for Uber, Lyft, or a private for-hire service rather than put up with the traditional cab dispatcher. I can make guesses at why that might be, overall, but I am certainly not going to tell them that they are making the wrong choice.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoTo be honest, consider that it may take just one negative review to get fired ("independent contractors", hehe) from Uber (don't know how strict Lyft ratings are). I doubt the drivers that are not satisfied will risk answering you honestly, as you're a person in power to kick them out of their job by a single tap on your smartphone.
- marssaxman 11y agoThat's a reasonable point, and I certainly don't imagine that my informal survey results have any scientific validity. I do have what seems to be a higher-than-average sensitivity to body language, however, and I have never seen the signs of stress or guarding that I would expect if drivers were trying to give me the answers they thought I wanted. Perhaps Lyft's hiring process selects in some way for people who have the kind of social awareness and self-presentation skill necessary to fool me, but it seems simpler to believe that Lyft drivers are, by and large, genuinely happy about their jobs.
- deegles 11y agoYes, once Uber takes the crown they will behave ethically, operate within the confines of the law and re-classify their drivers as employees with full benefits. They also won't even consider dropping them as soon as self-driving car technology matures. /s
- marssaxman 11y agoIt depends on the state, but in many places taxi drivers are not employees either; they are independent sole proprietorships who rent the taxi medallion from its owner. Uber is not perfect but is an improvement over the status quo for both drivers and riders. Once it "takes the crown", we can work on the next step in improving transit.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> re-classify their drivers as employees with full benefits In what way is this an ethical concern? Many other businesses work with contractors. Considering that drivers compete with each other, work hours of their choice, and supply their own equipment, what exactly makes them employees?
- bitJericho 11y agoSeems like a somebody thinks so: http://uberlawsuit.com/OrderDenying.pdf http://uberlawsuit.com/OrderDenying.pdf
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ethanbond 11y agoThis seems like a non-sequitur. The business model was made illegal by people who were voted into office to make business models like these illegal. Uber isn't wrong to push the letter of the law, but no one should be surprised that it will take a little bit of time for the law to adapt to this. Uber's vicious and cavalier attitude towards law in general is really disgraceful. This seems like a classic "ends justify the means" type of scenario, and I'm generally skeptical of these.
- danhak 11y ago> The business model was made illegal by people who were voted into office to make business models like these illegal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- dnautics 11y agoAlthough I am a big proponent of spreading the word about Regulatory capture, it's not quite that simple. A lot of the regulations that exist for taxis really do make sense, given a few contexts: 1) you don't know who is coming to pick you up 2) the ability to contact your former driver in the event of a bad experience is almost nil 3) you have to trust the taximeter 4) taxis have to jockey for a visual hail 5) there is no guarantee that a dispatched taxi will actually arrive. while there are concerns (e.g. safety, insurance) that do warrant a strong rational basis for regulation that are in common between taxis and lyft/uber, etc - a lot of the regulations that are in place do not carry over and those shouldn't apply to the lyft/uber. To its credit, the state of california seems to be making an (if slow) rapprochement between the existing regulation set and a reasonable set... Don't know about other places.
- antihero 11y agoBut people didn't vote people in because of their stance on taxis, apart from small vested interest groups. For most people this wasn't even an agenda they thought about, but because Uber exists, and they see an alternative to the rubbish taxi companies, it's coming to the spotlight.
- threeseed 11y agoThe US is not the only country in the world. Not all countries have a corrupt, entrenched monopoly nor do all countries have the same antagonism towards taxi services. And yes it's great to see someone siphon billions of dollars away from government/taxpayers and into the hands of a select few. It's also great to see them do this by ignoring any and all laws they see fit to. What a shining example of corporate responsibility and ethics.
- SilasX 11y agoYishan Wong explained it well in a Quora answer about the law being "lazily evaluated" and how the political realities can change by the time the law comes after a business in earnest: https://www.quora.com/Why-has-Airbnb-not-been-sued-or-regulated-out-of-existence/answer/Yishan-Wong?share=1 https://www.quora.com/Why-has-Airbnb-not-been-sued-or-regula...
- princeb 11y agosometimes I wish a brave soul will do the same with the financial industry (w.r.t. institutional regulation) but alas the law there is nowhere close to lazy eval.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoJust as it's much easier to get traction behind an idea with a proof of concept, it's much easier to change the law when you've demonstrated an obviously better solution. A company should never act unethically. That does not make all laws worthy of respect. Just have a very detailed understanding of the consequences.
- rquantz 11y agoFascinating to see HN's best brightest and their view of the rule of law. How is it good for democracy if a well-funded corporation can flout the law by its very existence? People make the excuse that taxi regulations are unjust. But it is still the law, and for Uber it didn't matter whether the law was unjust, only that it was in their way. These guys are not crusaders for justice, they are profit-seekers who decided the law didn't apply to them and went about their business until they amassed enough power that they could not be stopped.
- jvm 11y agoThe Travis Kalanick biopic: "A bro stands athwart history, yelling cant stop wont stop." https://twitter.com/Broethius/status/595971600358449152 https://twitter.com/Broethius/status/595971600358449152
- s73v3r 11y agoWhy are we still calling this "ridesharing"? Isn't it pretty clear to everyone that there is no ride sharing going on?
- niklasni1 11y agoThis is where people go wrong! You're not paying to be driven anywhere. You're paying the driver to want to go to the same place where you are, and then he might as well give you a ride there. So it's completely different, and the driver doesn't deserve any of the perks and protections people with real jobs get. Being an Uber driver obviously isn't a job, it's just doing something for money. And there's an app involved, so it's clearly different. It sounds like you're just conversative. Disruption, dude. Have you heard of it?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ghayes 11y agoUber is ride-sharing if and only if taxis are ride-sharing.
- spacehome 11y agoYea, but it's 1000 times easier to organize a ride share with Uber when the app will automatically pair you with someone with similar source and destination locations.
- danhak 11y agoNot totally true. I pretty much only use Uber pool these days unless I'm with more than one companion.
- mgraczyk 11y agoI use UberPOOL more often than UberX these days. I think it's fair to call that "ridesharing".
- pbreit 11y agoMore accurate headline: De Blasio legislative threat successful in persuading Uber to turn over data at 11th hour. California wasn't able to get that result with its $7m fine.
- jessaustin 11y agoWow that is a different story.
- onewaystreet 11y agoNot really, defeating the cap was much more important to Uber than the data access.
- ethanbond 11y agoOkay? And the data access was clearly more important to NYC than the cap. If you really think NYC can't step up at a moment's notice and drop the hammer, you're awfully optimistic. I mean, it's in the press release that the cap is not off the table. Unfortunately, this world cannot have win-wins, so I've got to find someone to hate in this situation!
- greenyoda 11y agoThey haven't defeated the cap yet. According to the article, there will be no cap while a four-month study proceeds, and a cap may still be imposed, depending on the conclusions of the study: The city will conduct a four-month study on the effect of Uber and other for-hire vehicle operators on the city’s traffic and environment. While the study is being conducted, de Blasio won't seek to cap the number of new vehicles Uber or other car services can put on the road. But de Blasio administration officials say a cap is still a possibility in the future.
- fx85ms 11y agoThe title would be better if it were "Uber has defeated Bill de Blasio's plan to block them from doing business". I think we really need to fight the notion that Uber promotes "ride sharing", whatever that even means now. Uber has shown that its service is anything but sharing - it is plain old taxi with a spiffy app and no labour protection, and where their "employees" are merely treated as another replaceable contractor. The media also needs to stop quoting meaningless buzzwords like "sharing", but I guess this goes to show the successful PR of Uber.
- snitko 11y agoAnd yet people choose to use them and pay them money. But no, we must protect those willing customers from the dangers of doing business freely and having an actuall choice, instead of paying extra to a violent monopoly of taxi drivers who'd rather crash other's cars than compete honestly.
- pd1 11y agoPeople would pay for taxis too if they were priced competitively and as reliable/convenient as Uber. I don't think treatment of drivers/employees is high on anyone's priority list.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoJust because some people are willing to pay for something, doesn't mean it's right. People in general are very happy to pay for things that have huge externalities not directly affecting them.
- HappyTypist 11y agoWhat externalities for uber are you referring to?
- Tomte 11y agoUninsured Uber driver causes traffic accident. Pedestrian is severely injured. Uber driver cannot pay for the medical expenses and there is no insurance company involved who could. Either the pedestrian is ruined for life, or society has to pick up the bill. That's one of the clearest examples of externality you will ever see. Our free choice evangelists try to frame the whole issue as "one Uber driver, one satified customer who only exercised a choice, and no one else exist in the world". It's dishonest, but that's Internet discussions.
- JohnTHaller 11y agoDoes this mean Uber's daily spam robocalls from "Molly" to New York City residents that offer no option to be removed from the list or speak to a live person will stop?
- twright0 11y agoIf this is what they were actually doing, and not hyperbole, I suspect you would have a reasonable case to fill out an FCC complaint - see their "Rules and Resources for Dealing with Unwanted Calls and Texts" at https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us/articles/202873880-Rules-and-Resources-for-Dealing-with-Unwanted-Calls-and-Texts https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us/articles/2028738...
- JohnTHaller 11y agoI've gotten several. I still have one recorded in voicemail. It likely wouldn't matter since Uber would call it a "political" call, thus utilizing one of the loopholes so they can spam the heck out of your phone number. All they accomplished by calling me over and over and over is ensuring that I'll never use their service. Vonage's auto-translate results for the curious: "Hi it's Molly with Huber and we need your help. We ended the days when you couldn't get a ride home because cab didn't wanna leave Manhattan now married to blog Theo is trying to bring the bad old days back because his millionaire taxi donors are telling him to why on earth would your council member. Ever consider voting for something like that. They should stand up for you. Not orders from the mayor your council member is sponsoring this bill and we need your voice. Please call your council number and tell them to take their name off of mayor-to-bother-as(?) an title bird(?) because you and all New Yorkers deserve a reliable transportation. Paid for by Huber 212-257-1745." "
- dang 11y agoAll: Whether Uber needs reining in or not, HN threads about Uber do. They have reliably been turning into flamewars. It's time this stopped. Kindly control yourselves, whatever your views. This is a place for thoughtful discussion, not venting.
- littletimmy 11y agoPity. This modern day exploitation should end. Uber's huge profits are because they exploit people for labor. Ban it already.
- masterleep 11y agoYay taxi cartel!
- kansface 11y agoWhy don't you let the drivers make the decision for themselves.
- balls187 11y agoI think that's fair, so long as they're presented with all the facts. If there is any truth to the comments that claim many drivers quit after determining they make at or near minimum wage, it seems like they got into Uber believing that drivers can make $90,000 a year
- fwn 11y agoWell.. It's also fair in situations without perfect information. Assuming that as a requirement would render any ethical judgement on real life scenarios unusable.
- seizethecheese 11y agoAs far as I know every Uber driver chooses to be one. Also, to be an Uber driver you have to own a relatively new car... I couldn't even drive for Uber because my car is too cheap. These people are not helpless.
- sampo 11y agoSome people might take a loan to buy a car to drive Uber?
- 11y ago
- JumpCrisscross 11y agoThere was un-coördinated public outreach, too. It may be unmerited graciousness, but a council member and a senior City administrator each told me, on separate occasions, that I swung their position on the bill. New Yorkers have shit to do and places to go. I'm fine with paying for a congestion charge. But it needs to be fairly applied across traffic. Engaging regulators and - in a balanced and sensible way - poking them in their flabby spots, when warranted, is a well-tread feature of democracy. If you care about something, reach out to your local representatives. Disclaimer: I don't work, nor ever have worked, for Uber. Neither do I hold a position in their stock, et cetera. I am a frequent rider. I've had many severely upsetting experiences with yellow cabs.
- bko 11y agoWhatever you think about Uber, you have to realize that de Blasio's actions are not about congestion or the public's interest. Let's not forget his original plan to have the city pre-approve upgrades to ride-hailing apps: > The mayor’s plan to require Uber Technologies Inc., Lyft Inc. and other ride-hailing services to get city approval for upgrades to the user interface on smartphone apps -- and to pony up $1,000 each time they do -- has rankled a broad swath of companies, with 27 signing a letter protesting his plan. http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2015-05-28/tech-champion-de-blasio-under-fire-on-plan-to-regulate-uber-apps http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2015-05-28/tech-c...
- eru 11y agoCouldn't that be easily circumvented by making the actual app a glorified browser that always stays the same?
- HappyTypist 11y agoThis is very similar to BitLicense which is also born in new York. It's unfortunate that they are heavily against permissionless innovation which had created $4 and $40 billion markets.
- nolepointer 11y ago"Everything you heard about me is true ... I am not a free-marketeer ... I believe in the heavy hand of government."
- jrockway 11y agoI don't really like Uber's business practices but they do fill an essential niche in New York City. A couple years ago, the city allowed independent car services to paint their cars green and take street hails. They previously did this, of course, but it wasn't legal. And of course, not every "black car" became a green cab, so this still happens. It's the standard way to get around the outer boroughs of New York. I watched a very common event unfold the other day in Brooklyn Heights. A woman hailed a green cab. It pulled over and the driver opened the window, asking "where to?" The woman mentioned an address in Manhattan. The driver said, "sorry, green cabs can't go to Manhattan" and drove away. That is 100% false. Like yellow cabs, green cabs have to take you anywhere in the five boros, but they're reluctant to take you to Manhattan because they aren't allowed to pick up fares there. They have to drive back to Brooklyn empty and not make any money, so they lie to customers to avoid that. The end result is that you still can't get a taxi in most of New York City, at least one that will pick you up near where you live and take you exactly where you want to go. The "ridesharing services" rectify this problem; I've never had an Uber driver refuse to take me anywhere. If the licensed taxis want to be free from competition, they need to follow their own rules. Anyway, this Forbes article about green cabs tells the exact same story: http://www.forbes.com/sites/johngiuffo/2013/09/30/nycs-new-green-taxis-what-you-should-know/2/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/johngiuffo/2013/09/30/nycs-new-g...
- zschallz 11y agoEven the yellow cabs within Manhattan would not take me places within Manhattan when hailed. They would stop and ask where to-- when I told them where (touristy areas) they'd just drive off.
- jrcii 11y agoAs a seasoned New Yorker I've learned that the best response to "where to?" is to silently get in the cab.
- arthurcolle 11y agoWhen do you drop the tidbit of information related to the whole reason you got in? /just moved to NYC
- backtoyoujim 11y agoDoes anyone on HN "work" for either of Uber or Lyft? There seems to be a lot "uber workers this" and "lyft workers that" without much substance.
- Karunamon 11y agoI drive for Uber in my spare time as of a few weeks ago - they just started serving Cheyenne for Frontier Days (and I'm hoping they keep the service on after that, though I'm not sure the demand is gonna be there) (That is, for the precisely one ride I've gotten.. Something in the backend appears broken and nobody can request rides even though I'm online, and support hasn't been helpful on this >_<) Can answer any questions you have, but I doubt there's going to be a lot to answer. Signing up as a driver and doing what you gotta do is a pretty straightforward process.
- kazinator 11y agoSpare time, what? Aren't you guys ruled to be employees in some jurisdiction, which makes it employment? :)
- justuk 11y agoI have heard several interviews with drivers. It reminds me of every other VC funded technology company that creates a platform. Those drivers do well as early adopters, but I suspect its downhill (for them) in the long term.
- driverdan 11y agoI spend every Lyft ride I take talking to the driver about what it's like driving for them. The majority also drive for Uber. They always say positive things although that may be due to self censorship.
- dbcooper 11y agoCaught a taxi tonight in Paris. 5 euro but jacked up to a minimum of 7, driver claimed he couldn't give me change. He spent 5 minutes pretending to have no change, then gave me 2 euros in coins plus a 10 in exchange for a 20. Great. Taxi services have practically begged for Uber etc to destroy them.
- DarthMader 11y agoWhen you have French taxi drivers willing to injure, threaten, assault just for working for a competitor, it's no surprise that some of them resort to shenanigans like this.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- moistgorilla 11y agoAre you seriously making fun of him because he didn't want to get scammed?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> driver claimed he couldn't give me change. Are taxis in Paris not supposed to be able to accept credit cards? In New York, if a cab's card reader is broken (hey, it happens) they're supposed to inform you of this before beginning the ride. If they don't, you get a free ride.
- danieltillett 11y agoThe thing about Uber I don’t understand is how they are going to defend their monopoly once they acquire it. Assuming they eventually win all the legal battles and drive all other taxi and taxi-like services out of business then how are they going to stop anyone else from entering their market? Each transport market is effectively isolated (you don’t hail a driver from SF to get around NYC). This means any new entrant can achieve critical mass in a market at a relatively low cost (especially if they start with small towns/cities). If Uber do manage to get to the point where they can start extracting monopoly profits they have no means of defending these markets other than competing on unit price. Consumers are going to win big time out of Uber, but I can’t see how their investors will (at least their long term investors). Someone far smarter than me must have answered this?
- dotBen 11y agoAssuming they eventually win all the legal battles and drive all other taxi and taxi-like services out of business That's very unlikely to happen and I don't think anyone here at Uber sees the world as a zero-sum game as you portray it. Even in SF, the most mature Uber market, there are still plenty of cabs operating. Cabs offer a different service (street hails, fixed pricing etc) - which is why you can even hail a cab from the Uber app if you want. Differentiation is key, and that's how Uber does and will compete with both taxis and direct TNC competitors.
- danieltillett 11y agoI also don’t think it is very likely either, I was just assuming the best case scenario for Uber and I can’t see how they can make money in the long term even if they achieve this. Competition is great for consumers, but not so good for investors. Edit. Thanks for the updates to your post Ben. Given Uber’s cost of capital and current valuation how do you see Uber earning enough of a return with a differentiation business model? Or is the current business model irrelevant to Uber’s future and you foresee a massive pivot?
- dotBen 11y ago
- joemaller1 11y agoIn the last few years NYC has closed stretches of Broadway (a significant north-south corridor) to traffic, squeezed vehicle lane widths to add bike lanes and introduced several measures to slow or impede traffic so the city is safer for pedestrians. These are all very good things, but they come with a cost. Reducing the surface area of roads does not magically remove cars from the roads, it just creates congestion and traffic. If anything, Uber's model would seem to reduce traffic since their cars are more deliberate vs. taxis' aimlessly wandering. NYC should try to figure out how to partner with Uber. Taxi's are already expensive enough to be something of a luxury (though filthy), Uber is a far better experience.
- mason55 11y ago> Reducing the surface area of roads does not magically remove cars from the roads, it just creates congestion and traffic. Most traffic theory maintains that this actually does magically reduce traffic. People who would have driven now decide that there's too much traffic and find another way. Similarly, expanding highways doesn't reduce congestion, the number of cars just increases to the previous levels of congestion.
- _delirium 11y agoIt's sensitive to model parameters, but one estimate is that Uber makes congestion in the core of Manhattan worse by ~8%: http://www.streetsblog.org/2015/07/22/ubers-own-data-reveals-it-slows-manhattan-traffic-9-percent/ http://www.streetsblog.org/2015/07/22/ubers-own-data-reveals... The main issue seems to be that Uber isn't replacing taxis but augmenting them: before there were about 2000 taxis in the core of Manhattan during peak hours, and there are now 2000 taxis and about 1900 Ubers. The trips per taxi seem to be slightly reduced, but overall there's still an increase in the total number of taxi-like vehicles circulating, and the total number of trips made by automobile vs. other modalities (subway, walking, etc.). Thereby making it easier to get a taxi, but making traffic congestion worse.
- akgerber 11y agoReducing the complexity of a large number of intersections (AKA closing & narrowing Broadway) can move traffic through them more quickly: http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/pedestrians/broadway.shtml http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/pedestrians/broadway.shtml 'Travel speeds for northbound trips throughout West Midtown improved 17% from fall 2008-2009, compared with 8% in East Midtown.'
- dmead 11y agono mention of ashton kutcher's day job as a tech investor.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoThere is a restaurant in Chicago called El Ideas http://www.eater.com/2015/4/27/8486425/phillip-foss-el-ideas-chicago http://www.eater.com/2015/4/27/8486425/phillip-foss-el-ideas... It's in a neighborhood that has no cabs and driving there not pleasant or convenient. Last night the chef told me if it wasn't for Uber, they probably wouldn't have survived
- tzs 11y agoWhy did they put their restaurant in a location that depends on a single, possibly illegal, transportation service to get their customers to them? Was that location easier to get to when they opened?
- eru 11y agoIn theory, they should pay lower rent for a bad location. Uber, in driving up their profits, should in the longer term also drive up their rent. The landlord will eat all the advantage eventually.
- vasilipupkin 11y agoit won't drive up their rent, because it's a really not a great neighborhood and doesn't show any sign of improving
- eru 11y agoNeighbourhood with Uber is commercially better than neighbourhood without Uber. Thus, rent should go up.
- vasilipupkin 11y agomaybe, but it will stay ridiculously low for reasons unrelated to Uber
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- michaelochurch 11y agoI'm no fan of Uber and I can't stand its founder or his ridiculous smirk but... they played this well. Uber's got game when it comes to politics. If either political party ever learned demagoguery from Travis, I'd be scared. It helps them that their opponent isn't sympathetic at all. Non-zero medallion values, by definition, mean that there are too few cabs on the road (and in New York, there are). The Medallion Mafia pisses me off; just a bunch of rent-seekers stealing money from drivers. I'm actually glad to see the Medallion assholes get "disrupted". I just wish that it were a different company taking the lead in doing it.
- tsax 11y agoMy hunch is that if the company was different, it would lose. Like it or not, this is what's required to defeat our noble overlords a.k.a. the holy regulators and the munificent politicians.
- p_monk 11y agoUber's "we need to meet demand" argument is true, but disingenuous. Uber needs to keep adding more drivers because they have such a high turnover rate. Many drivers work for a few months, realize that after costs they're making minimum wage, if that, and then quit. Naturally, Uber needs constant access to fresh blood in order to keep the scheme going.
- dotBen 11y agoIf there was such an issue with churn, which isn't, the cap wouldn't be an issue because it was (as proposed) for total drivers not licenses issued.
- mikeash 11y agoMost of my exposure to Uber has been negative articles about them. I've used them a handful of times, but not for a couple of years, until just this week. I used them to get to and from the airport for a trip this week, and it was pretty interesting to compare with what I've been reading. First, of course, the experience as a user was great. This is no surprise, but it sure does cement my desire to use them over any other service. I wanted to avoid taxis at all costs. I was ready to drive to the airport twice each way to handle all 8 people who were going, and pay for parking, rather than deal with that. I've done it before and wow, it just sucks. You call and get a surly dispatcher, you have no idea where your car is until it arrives, it might just not show up, credit cards are a joke, you have to figure out what to tip, etc. Uber was great. Hail in the app, see within seconds exactly where your car is and who's driving it, track them all the way, get in, ride, then get out on the other end and go, without even needing to explicitly pay. It just works! Even getting two different cars at 5AM in the suburbs was no problem. No cars were available at first, but within a few minutes they appeared. I'll note that it's not just taxis who are problematic. I also checked into Super Shuttle, because heck, there's so many of us that we should be able to get a whole van at a good price. Checking on their web site, I thought that's how it would be. They wanted $28 plus $10/person, which worked out to quite a bit cheaper than four Uber rides (two each way). And we'd all go together, cool! Of course, it turns out that this is the price for each way, so the actual price would be double. They are pretty careful not to make this clear until very late in their reservation process. To be fair, all the info is there if you pay very close attention, but they make it extremely easy to assume that the quoted price is the whole thing. Compare with Uber, which is happy to give me a pretty precise quote, and matched it (near the low end!) all four times. OK, we know all this. It's a great service (unless you get a bad driver who attacks you or something) but it's built on the backs of the poor oppressed drivers. Except both drivers I talked to were ecstatic about Uber and loved doing what they do. One was relatively new on the job, having been an assistant manager at a pizza place until a few months ago. He started out doing Uber part time, then graduated to full time once it became apparent that it was the better choice. The other one has been doing it for about two years. He bought a brand new Toyota just to drive for UberX, and he's put over 60,000 miles on it since then. He loves the flexibility (apparently he's somewhat "on call" to help family members out doing various things, and when he needs to help them he just signs out of Uber, goes off and does whatever tasks this involves, and signs back in) and the money is pretty good. He usually hangs around downtown DC on weekends and makes good money accumulating lots of short trips, but hangs out doing occasional airport runs on other days to earn a bit more. So they're good with customers, they seem to be great with drivers, and all I have left is a vague sense of unease at how they approach regulations, by basically barging in and ignoring them. Except they're totally on the up-and-up in Virginia now, having reached an accommodation with the relevant authorities to be completely above-board. After all the stuff I've read about them over the years, I felt a little guilty using Uber for this trip, but practicality won out. The guilty feeling didn't last. Edit: I forgot to mention, the second guy, with the new Toyota, previously drove a cab. It was awful, and says he tries to convince his cabbie friends to switch to Uber at every opportunity. They charged him $150/day to drive for them no matter what. No fares? Fuck you, pay me. He's extremely happy that Uber came along to give him a much better way to make money.
- ajays 11y agoServices like Uber definitely need some regulation. I drove from downtown SF to the Castro this evening, and witnessed 4 separate incidents of Uber drivers being reckless and/or discourteous. Things like: driver stopped in the leftmost lane, at a green light, because he suddenly decided that he wants to turn right instead of left; driver stopped in the right lane to pick up passenger, when he could have just stood in a parking spot a few yards down; driver stopped to pick up a passenger at a corner, blocking the crosswalk. I'm all for "disrupting" the taxi industry, but please don't disrupt traffic because you're too lazy and/or clueless. Is there a way to report asshole Uber drivers?
- usaphp 11y agoWhat does it have to do with Uber? A lot of drivers are doing that, and don't even get me started on taxi drivers in New York City, they just do whatever they want on a road.
- balls187 11y agoIt's more pronounced because Uber drivers are waiting for their passengers. In Seattle, the behavior of uber drivers has started to mirror Taxi cab drivers: surly attitudes and aggressive.
- onion2k 11y agoDriving for Uber (or a rival) hugely increases the likelihood that you'll want to change your destination suddenly eg when you get a job. That makes it more likely you'll do something dangerous to get somewhere more quickly - your review depends on it, and consequently so do your potential future earnings. I'm not sure that's a reason to regulate Uber but it is a problem, just as it's a problem with taxis.
- discardorama 11y agoI have noticed the same in SF. > What does it have to do with Uber? If these are Uber drivers picking up/dropping off passengers, then it's Uber's problem, isn't it? Setting aside the contractor/employee dispute, these drivers are engaged in activity for which they'll get money from Uber, so it definitely is Uber's problem. > A lot of drivers are doing that Not in SF. I've lived here 10 years, and never saw this level of ineptitude. These days whenever I see a driver being an asshole, I immediately check to see if it's an uber driver; and 9/10 it is. I sometimes work in a cafe which is on a corner; and I've lost count of the number of times I've seen Uber drivers doing a U-turn at the stop sign, confusing other traffic. > don't even get me started on taxi drivers in New York City Irrelevant, since we're talking about SF.
- xacaxulu 11y agoNo matter what Uber does, they always please me with stuff like this. It makes the anarch-libertarian blood run warm to see government cronies routinely bested and consumers offered superior services in a market that was ripe for innovation. Now we need this type of disruption in health care and education.
- mdpopescu 11y agoIt started in education with Khan Academy and the like, but there's still a lot of work to be done. As for health care... it is one of my fondest wishes for a large company like Google to come up with a medical expert system that can solve even half of the "take two pills and come back in two days" consultation that currently cost me $50.
- umeshunni 11y agoAs with Uber and AirBnB, this is something that only a new entrant to the market with no political capital or PR to lose can change.
- dragonwriter 11y agoWhile Uber and AirBnB were able to get VC backing for business models that deliberately disregarded key regulations in their field, neither short-term occupancy laws nor taxi regulations are enforced with the same kind of, well, robust methods by authorities as laws governing the practice of medicine and, particularly, the dispensing of controlled substances. Disrupting that is likely to take political capital, and application of that political capital at an earlier stage of the process than what AirBnB and Uber have done in their fields, or its going to involve a lot of risk for participants and investors, and not just the kind of limited-downside financial risks that investing in a corporation, startup or otherwise, usually involves.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> it is one of my fondest wishes for a large company like Google to come up with a medical expert system that can solve even half of the "take two pills and come back in two days" consultation that currently cost me $50. AFAIK, this is not a technical problem; such solutions have existed for quite a while. Drug control laws, laws governing scope of practice of various classes of health care providers, and insurance rules all require that, even if your diagnosis and recommended treatment come out of such a system, its done under the authority of a provider with a particular kind of license with a particular degree of contact.
- tlogan 11y agoI have one question for somebody knowledgeable about this market. Why companies like YellowCab do not offer something similar to Uber? They developed the app but the app is jut front end to dispatcher: so there is no guarantee that cab will actually come (I tried it). For example, ability to pre-pay taxi via iPhone so that there is guarantee that cab will actually pick me up. Or maybe hailing taxi via iPhone? Or something like Lyft Line? Is management of cab companies to blame? Or is it taxi drivers?
- nolepointer 11y agoPoor Comrade De Blasio didn't get his way.