3 ms·
This really doesn't work for me as an experiment. 10% is too easy to hit. Do 3 or more students need the 6 rather than the 2? Why should I choose the 2 if it
by bsder 11y ago
This really doesn't work for me as an experiment.
10% is too easy to hit. Do 3 or more students need the 6 rather than the 2? Why should I choose the 2 if it won't do me any good?
In any class I teach, there are generally 10% on the line between grades that requires that I take into account a little more than just scores. Did they do all the homework? Did they improve on assignments or were they blowing them off? etc.
Given that 10% probably need the 6 and not the 2, this is likely to never work.
I had a tragedy of the commons that I hadn't intended. I had an extra credit programming assignment, but there was a catch--the students had to write the tests for the automated tester. If nobody wrote tests, nobody had the chance to get any extra credit. They were allowed to collaborate on the tests, but not the solution.
Everybody complained bitterly when nobody wrote tests.
My response was not terribly charitable: "This is extra credit, folks. Not charity. You all had two options.
First, write the tests yourself. Yes, writing tests is time consuming, but not horribly difficult. Some students started, realized the amount of work, and stopped. However, once somebody writes the tests, everybody get to benefit.
Second, encourage someone else to write the tests for you. Did any of you talk to the students most likely to write tests? Did any of you encourage these students to put in the work if you couldn't pull it off yourself? Did any of you offer to compensate them for their valuable time?
Many of you have been repeatedly asking for a group assignment since the beginning of the semester. THIS WAS A GROUP ASSIGNMENT AND YOU FAILED. It simply worked out that freeloaders weren't guaranteed to be carried by the best students. The best students realized the amount of work and simply opted out since they already had enough points.
Welcome to the real world. Figuring out how to get someone to do something that they don't really want to do is a fundamental problem of life."