2 ms·
That isn't a question. At least in a vehicle, the Supreme Court has ruled that the police have the authority to order you to exit the vehicle and to use force
by FireBeyond 11y ago
That isn't a question.
At least in a vehicle, the Supreme Court has ruled that the police have the authority to order you to exit the vehicle and to use force to compel your compliance.
- IanDrake 11y agoA common trick used by police is to phrase questions as commands. "I'm going to search your vehicle, ok" If you say "ok", then you just volunteered to have your car searched.
- FireBeyond 11y agoThis is true, but tangential to my comment. The Supreme Court has determined that the police have the authority to -demand- your exit from a vehicle, orthogonal to the issue of "Am I free to go?" and other detainment questions, and to compel your exit from the vehicle using force if necessary (at which point you reach the awkward catch-22 of "is this classified as 'resisting arrest'?"
- dragonwriter 11y ago> That isn't a question. "Please" implies a non-obligatory request; it can also be used as a layer of politeness over a command, but confirming the intent is not unreasonable. That police have the power to order you to exit the vehicle does not imply that any request to do so is an order.