4 ms·
Considering that all DMCA notices must include various dire assertions under penalty of perjury, has anyone ever tried to sue/prosecute over a negligently false
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Considering that all DMCA notices must include various dire assertions under penalty of perjury, has anyone ever tried to sue/prosecute over a negligently false DMCA notice?
- pasbesoin 11y agoBorrowing from others' arguments, one can argue that such selective and/or one-sided enforcement actually weakens a law or regulation. (Meaning here, no penalties for abusing the DMCA.) Akin to speed limits. Make them unreasonable, and selectively enforce them -- perhaps for purposes, e.g. revenue generation, other than their ostensible purpose -- and people lose all respect for them. You may attempt to enforcement through force, but you no longer have the public's buy in and willing participation -- something upon which democracy is founded. P.S. I didn't mean for my comment to ride this high on the thread, by virtue of being a response. Nonetheless, my point: We continue to fight e.g. artificial scarcity and strengthening threats, rather than working with efforts to actually improve the public's experience and gain willing participation.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago[Meta comment on HN comment structure, not related to the topic.] > P.S. I didn't mean for my comment to ride this high on the thread, by virtue of being a response. As long as you're actually responding to the comment you're replying to (which you were), rather than just responding to a top comment with an unrelated comment to make yours more prominent, then I don't see how that could be taken as a bad thing. By necessity, comments are tree-structured; it'd be too confusing otherwise.
- M2Ys4U 11y agoIt's simply not true that DMCA claims are covered by penalty of perjury, at least not in the way that nearly everybody thinks. The only part that is covered by penalty of perjury is that the person making the claim is, or is authorised by, the copyright holder. This means that you commit perjury if you issue an otherwise legitimate DMCA claim for a work that is not yours, but you don't if you submit a completely false claim for a work that is. That part of the DMCA is just smoke a mirrors, designed to make the censorship regime look like it's fair and balanced.
- ikeboy 11y agoYou still need to pay damages for lying about other parts, though.