5 ms·
Interestingly enough, fractional reserve banking is not significantly different from the way any other business works. If I loan money to a business, that busi
by anamax 17y ago
Interestingly enough, fractional reserve banking is not significantly different from the way any other business works.
If I loan money to a business, that business almost always does something with the money, like buy stuff or pay expenses. It doesn't keep the money sitting around to pay me back. If things go wrong, the biz won't have money to pay me back.
Let's compare that with the Wikipedia description of fractional reserve banking. "The fact that banks are required to keep on hand only a fraction of the funds deposited with them is a function of the banking business. Banks borrow funds from their depositors (those with savings) and in turn lend those funds to the banks’ borrowers (those in need of funds)."
Yes, there's the quibble about "demand deposits" vs other kinds of loans, but that doesn't really have anything to do with the expansion in the actual money supply.
Yes, I know that the article defines "money supply" as "cash plus demand deposits". However, as a loan matures, it becomes closer to a "demand deposit" and eventually becomes one. The original money, meanwhile, has already left the biz. Maybe some came back, maybe it didn't. Either way, the only thing that's there for sure is the obligation to pay.
Note that a bank has loans as assets. A biz has whatever it got in return for the borrowed money that it spent. Either one can go bad.
- DougWebb 17y agoThe big difference is that when a bank loans money to a business, the business can bring in revenue from other parts of the economy to enable it to pay that loan back. When the Fed loans money into the US economy, there is no place to pull money from to pay the loan interest; only the principle can be repaid. The loans can only be repaid with hard assets (gold, real estate, etc) or by inflating the currency sufficiently to devalue the principle that was borrowed to below the repayment cost.
- anamax 17y ago> The big difference is that when a bank loans money to a business, the business can bring in revenue from other parts of the economy to enable it to pay that loan back. That's not a difference. When a biz spends borrowed money, it does so with the expectation that money will come back, just as the bank expects that its loan (of deposit money) will be repaid. In both cases, the bank/biz sent borrowed money out the door and only has an expectation that sufficient money will come back. (Yes, deposits are borrowed money.) The Fed is different because it gets to print money. We're talking about ordinary banks here. Yes, banks can get into trouble if its lenders call at an inconvenient time, but so can biz.