8 ms·
What size company is he talking about -- 5 employees? 15? 50? 500? 5,000? Public companies are certainly run with ownership being different from management. Bu
by crazygringo 11y ago
What size company is he talking about -- 5 employees? 15? 50? 500? 5,000? Public companies are certainly run with ownership being different from management.
But if we're talking about a 15-person company, the author says:
"This means that before long there will be a general feeling of resentment, after all if you (and possibly your co-founders, also lying on the beach) are going to receive all or at least a very large chunk of the profits then why do all the hard work?"
That big chunk of profits comes from the fact that you took the initial risk, you worked the endless hours at the beginning, you created the whole thing in the first place. Why on earth should they resent you continuing to take your fair share of the fruits of your previous labor? If they have a problem with that, the problem isn't with you, it's with capitalism in general.
You do need to make sure everyone continues to be appropriately invested in the company, including the new CEO. But the idea that you should either run a company or not own it at all is ludicrous -- taken to its logical conclusion, this means investors shouldn't exist!
- jacquesm 11y agoSomewhere below the 30 employee mark or so. How many investors do you know that put all of their savings into a single company run by someone else without wanting to take control of that company?
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoHumans don't behave rationally. It is better to take this into account when planning your own actions as otherwise you open yourself up to risk when humans act like humans. Even in the really small case of taking only 75% of the salary to work only 75% of the hours due to not needing the money and valuing your time more. It can cause problems in the team because they see the result of you working only 75% of the time but they rarely encounter the effects of being paid only 75% of the amount. So when you are getting paid far more and working far less because of all the initial investment and taking on the initial risks (something employees are likely not able to see and fully appreciate), then there is going to be resentment. >taken to its logical conclusion, this means investors shouldn't exist! And there are groups of people (political and not) who have a negative view of investors compared to employees.
- sbov 11y agoLeaving a smallish company where the original owner is sitting on their ass is behaving rationally. Once key players start slacking it's time to start looking for a new job before competition puts you out of yours. At a small company, the owner is usually a key player. And I don't mean slacking as in "not working 7 days a week". I mean not working, roughly, a normal work week.
- Frondo 11y agoYou raised a good point in bringing up that phrase "fair share." What is the fair share for someone who doesn't do anything? What should someone get for mere possession? I'm asking not in the present-day legal sense (where the answer is, whatever's fair is whatever you've clawed out for yourself), but in the moral sense of how much should ownership of anything actually be worth if you're not continuing to put any effort into a venture, but are totally passive--a name on paper. Where does "setting up and creating a thing and then profiting as an absent owner" cross over into rent-seeking?
- pc86 11y ago> for someone who doesn't do anything Presumably that person who "doesn't do anything" now spent many years working 12+ hours a day, 7 days a week, for zero pay building the business. It would not exist in any form without them.
- Frondo 11y agoSo, someone spends 12+ hours a day, 7 days a week, for zero pay, for some period of time (say, a year), and for the rest of their life, they receive free money. Tweak the numbers but that's what you're saying in a nutshell... and that's certainly the way the world works now. Should it? Do we like the idea of "receive free money" because there is entrepreneurship involved? What if it someone who was born into owning a business? Do we still like the idea as much?
- Turing_Machine 11y agoOthers work the same amount and lose everything. Most startups fail. What you're calling "free money" is compensation for the risk. Without it, most people would not start businesses.
- Frondo 11y agoI don't see how failure or success changes that question of "is a lifetime of free money for some small value of work acceptable?" -- nor am I even saying "no free money ever". I'm getting at, where does the passive ownership cross the line into rent-seeking?
- s73v3r 11y ago"That big chunk of profits comes from the fact that you took the initial risk" And why do any of the current employees care about that? All they see right now is you sitting on your ass while they're the ones doing the actual work. "you worked the endless hours at the beginning" And now you're not, and they're the ones working the endless hours. Or perhaps a number of them were also there at the beginning, working the endless hours. "you created the whole thing in the first place." This is not always true. "Why on earth should they resent you continuing to take your fair share of the fruits of your previous labor?" Because they don't see it as being a fair share. "If they have a problem with that, the problem isn't with you, it's with capitalism in general." Not necessarily. Capitalism doesn't say that one should be able to rest on one's laurels forever. And quite frankly, if you want your employees to work hard for you, then you need to lead by example. If you're going to sit on your ass, then why shouldn't they?
- dhimes 11y agoThis is exactly what can happen. I'll pile on: >>"That big chunk of profits comes from the fact that you took the initial risk" >And why do any of the current employees care about that? All they see right now is you sitting on your ass while they're the ones doing the actual work. Furthermore, they may see themselves as the reason you did not fail. In their minds, it was their brilliant insight about X that saved you from failing. >>"If they have a problem with that, the problem isn't with you, it's with capitalism in general." >Not necessarily. Capitalism doesn't say that one should be able to rest on one's laurels forever. It doesn't matter whom the problem is with. It is now your problem.