3 ms·
To get to the top in forums that use voting (HN, reddit etc) articles have to get upvotes - and as each user only has one upvote to give, to get lots of upvotes
by michaelt 11y ago
To get to the top in forums that use voting (HN, reddit etc) articles have to get upvotes - and as each user only has one upvote to give, to get lots of upvotes an article needs to appeal to a lot of people and get upvotes from them.
That means articles need broad appeal. If you write a great article, but readers have to already know about <topic foo>, only a small fraction of readers will upvote it. If you go into fewer technical details but include more introductory content, and focus on topics that have broader appeal, you'll get more upvotes.
You also don't want the article to be too long - most forums rank, in some way, on votes-against-time and some readers don't have time to read a lengthy article. If the user doesn't get back to the forum they don't upvote, and if they decide to save the article and read it later, it's off the front page before they read it and upvote.
Forums like HN and Reddit rarely link to arXiv papers because it's just the nature of the system.