Um, I think there's a challenge with this analysis of the Chinese Room argument. The argument presupposes a perfect lookup table of (sentance -> sentance). So

Um, I think there's a challenge with this analysis of the Chinese Room argument. The argument presupposes a perfect lookup table of (sentance -> sentance). So the point of the argument is that given the correct responses, there's no way to tell if there is a contextual understanding. Now you can say that such a table cannot possibly exist, but you would have to say why.