3 ms·
The coastline paradox is a matter of accuracy (significant digits). As you "zoom in" on the coast this is what happens to the length: 100km > 120km > 128km > 1
by zamalek 11y ago
The coastline paradox is a matter of accuracy (significant digits). As you "zoom in" on the coast this is what happens to the length:
100km > 120km > 128km > 129.5km > 129.52km > 129.528km > 129.6281km > ...
If you have to "zoom in" to see a length feature it means that the length feature is small and therefore the contribution to the overall length that these features provide diminishes. Something like a sigmoid[1], it would approach a limit (except in the case of some fractals, but not coastlines) - it can increase infinitely but at tinier and tinier increments. Eventually you reach the size of atoms and you are now talking about fractals and not real-life coastlines.
While it would technically apply to rivers as well, the website seems to be using a single significant digit. The above example becomes:
100km > 120km > 128km > 129.5km > 129.5km > 129.5km > 129.6km > ...
So we can accurately measure a coast/river length up to a specific significant digit.
[1]: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/55/Sigmoid_curve_for_an_autocatalytical_reaction.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/55/Sigmoid_...
- Osmium 11y ago> As you "zoom in" on the coast this is what happens to the length: 100km > 120km > 128km > 129.5km > 129.52km > 129.528km > 129.6281km > ... I don't think that's true. In real life this series does not converge unless you specify a minimum feature size, which you hinted at. This isn't just a mathematical curiosity; real life coastlines are fractal and have no well-defined length, as the parent poster's link explains. [Edited wording.]
- zamalek 11y ago> To measure a coastline you have to specify a minimum feature size. Not coastlines: only fractals. The name of the paradox is really unfortunate because it doesn't apply the coastlines "all the way down." You can't keep subdividing a coastline because eventually you start working with curves meaning that you can use calculus and meaning that you can work out limits. The actual issue with real-life coastline (and river) length is that it's continuously changing. [Edit to your edit]: yep. However the important result is that we can actually arrive at a length for a river, regardless of the mathematical thought experiment.
- Osmium 11y agoAgreed that the fact it's continuously changing is an additional issue, but I don't see the "eventually you start working with curves" argument. Where are these curves on a typical coastline? If you're measuring the coastline on a map, that argument holds, but the map is only one representation of the reality, and they've already made decisions regarding minimum feature size implicit in the construction of the map. But yes, also agreed that measuring rivers should be fine, because you can represent it as a one-dimensional line along the 'centre of mass' of each segment of the river, which should give well-defined values regardless of what the 'edges' of the river look like.
- zamalek 11y ago> Where are these curves on a typical coastline? Between atom nuclei.
- Osmium 11y agoHow so? Do you fit the positions of your nuclei to a spline to get your curve? How about quantum uncertainty in its position? How do you assign whether a given nuclei belongs to the 'coast' or to the 'sea', etc. I don't think it holds.
- zamalek 11y ago> How about quantum uncertainty in its position? Aw crap, really good point. You're right.