5 ms·
JavaScript: The World's Most Misunderstood Programming Language (2001)
- ryanelkins 17y agoNot a bad little article, although the fact that it is 8 years old should make anyone who would find it useful question how much of this is still completely accurate. On an somewhat related note, I really hate it when programming articles don't have a date on them. You start reading just to find out it was written so long ago that the version of code it was written for no longer exists and everything is deprecated.
- city41 17y agoI hate it when any page on the web doesn't have a date. I wish having created on and modified on dates was a standard somehow.
- jacquesm 17y agoIt is a standard, somehow. After all, most if not all webservers will include that information in the headers. Browsers could easily display it if their designers wanted to implement that. It would be a fairly simple addition to put that in to the statusbar on the right. I'm not sure if greasemonkey scripts have access to header information but if they do that might be one way to solve this for you.
- city41 17y agoYeah but that might not be good enough. Like if the user switches web servers, they restore from a back up, the data is dynamically served, etc, the dates might not be accurate. What I've always dreamed of is truly accurate dates on when the article was written, and when it was consciously updated.
- jacquesm 17y agoI'm fairly sure that that is exactly how those dates are meant to be used. If people misbehave then that is not really the fault of the standard. Just for a little check I just looked at a page by a well-known news service, today it is the 13th, here is the last-modified header from one of their articles: Last-Modified: Fri, 11 Dec 2009 11:14:26 GMT So it looks like those headers are actually being used the way they are intended. Restoring from a backup should definitely preserve the file dates, dynamic serving could still serve up the right last modified date (such as in the example above). Dates not being accurate is more likely to happen when people can enter them manually! The only thing remaining then would be a header that registers when the document was first created, but for that we have the META name='date' tag.
- city41 17y agoI totally agree with everything you are saying. It's just that in practice it often doesn't work out. I can create a website that pulls its content out of a database and the web server has no clue what the dates should be for the headers. I think the only real solution is for web developers to be more conscious of this and ensure their frameworks play nice. The up side to that being the more conscious websites are more likely to be the sites with quality information anyway.
- prodigal_erik 17y agoIf the database has no timestamp for the content, the web site shouldn't be using Last-Modified without a meaningful value. When your code doesn't know what's going on but still wants caching, that's what ETag is for.
- mcav 17y agoLast-Modified isn't intended to preserve the date of the content. It represents the modification time of the HTML document, which is used for caching. It may or may not -- probably not -- represent the date the article was modified. To try to do so would conflate the purpose of the Last-Modified header.
- gasull 17y agoI'm not sure if greasemonkey scripts have access to header information but if they do that might be one way to solve this for you. http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/34231 http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/34231
- jonny_noog 17y agoThis is actually one of my (few) pet peeves with the 37Signals crowd. I remember reading somewhere (possibly in their Getting Real book) the reasoning behind such design decisions as not including the year on the dates displayed in their web applications. The general reasoning as I remember it was "It doesn't matter." It doesn't matter until it's 3-4 years later and I'm reading a post on Rails that may or may not actually still be relevant and trying to figure out what Rails version it pertains to. Sure the date doesn't matter so much when the content is new, but particularly when it comes to technical documentation, the date starts to matter more and more as the content ages.
- warfangle 17y agoIt's still fairly accurate. A cursory read through it (I read it once several years ago) and I don't see anything that needs updating, except maybe the books section. Of course, I haven't read much dead tree documentation for JavaScript, so I can't really comment on that aspect. Since the article was written, a few things were added that are handy, but not expounded upon in the article: we've gone from 1.4 to 1.8.1, and added some helpful things like array helpers, iterators, and so forth. Not much else has changed, though - for instance, you can and probably always will be able to accidentally save a variable to the global stack if you assign a value to it without declaring it.
- TNO 17y agoES5 strict mode won't allow you to define an undeclared variable.
- ThinkWriteMute 17y agoI think the Modula series is the most misunderstood programming language. Perhaps not misunderstood, but the most potential with least use. (Note: This opinion is probably naive or uneducated)
- jacquesm 17y agoThere are lots of candidates for that list: - occam - smalltalk - lisp - oberon And that's just the tip of the iceberg of languages that seem to somehow have missed the adoption that they definitely deserved. And, conversely there are plenty of languages that did not 'deserve' the recognition they got. It's almost like fashion, some stuff makes perfect sense but will never make it, other stuff is pointless and a smash hit.
- BerislavLopac 17y ago"Undervalued" is quite different from "misunderstood". Most of the languages you both listed are not quite known even emong programmers; on the other hand, anyone who's evenr dabbled with Web production (and many that just browse) have at least heard of Javascript. Douglas' point is that many people think that they know what Javascript is all about, but they're wrong.
- michaelcampbell 17y agoI'll freely admit to being one who didn't "get it" with Javascript back then (and more recently than I'd like to admit). Not sure I even get it now, but I'm at least aware enough to admit my lack of awareness about some (ok, most) things.
- mark_l_watson 17y agoThanks to whoever added the 2001 date to my submission - I'll remember to do that next time. The history of Javascript is a history of accidents :-) Javascript is one language that I wish I new better. I can code in Javascript, but I need references handy to help me remember how to do things. I tend to just remember the basics required to write CouchDB view functions and simple web related tasks. However, nice tools like Rails AJAX helpers, couch-potato (generates CouchDB views from Ruby) and other tools pretty much make it possible to not spend too much time dealing with Javascript. Regardess of technical merit, Javascript is used on a wide scale and its use will I think keep increasing.
- telemachos 17y agoThis may be out of place, and I have no doubt that Douglas Crockford is a genius and an all-around excellent human being. Also, I am pretty firmly in the substance over style camp of web design. Having said that, I find it pretty hard to accept webpages (in 2009!) that have this for design: <body bgcolor=linen> <h1 align=center><font size="+4">JavaScript:</font><br> Thank god for Readability... Updates: Yes, by Readability I mean http://lab.arc90.com/experiments/readability/ http://lab.arc90.com/experiments/readability/ It's an outstanding little mini-app. If you don't know it, try it. Second, I want to clarify that what I quoted is literall the entire style for the whole page. I find that mind-boggling. (And, yes, I thought of PG's site.) Finally, the page was written in 2001, so my crack about 2009 isn't quite fair. Still, many people do update their sites.
- hyperbovine 17y agoCopyright 2001 Douglas Crockford.
- telemachos 17y agoThis is a fair point, but people do update their websites. Some people, some of the time. Still, I'll update my post to note that.
- raju 17y agoHa! I hit the Readability bookmarklet right after clicking on the link on HN and seeing Crockford's site. And I come back to find your comment. Another example of a genius having a similar site is Peter Norvig - http://norvig.com/ http://norvig.com/ Great content on both sites, and yes, thank god for Readability
- pogos 17y agoYou should also take a look at sources of paulgraham.com, norvig.com and tlb.org. They all use horrible markup and tables for layout. The fact that they don't care what their html code looks like should tell us something.
- 17y ago
- afed 17y ago"JavaScript is a very nice dynamic object-oriented general-purpose programming language. " No it isn't. Javascript is a toy language for making animated menus on web pages. No one should use it for anything real.
- tyrmored 17y agoI really disliked working with JavaScript until Douglas Crockford told me it was Scheme with C syntax, and then, suddenly, everything made sense and I actually began to enjoy it.