3 ms·
What's the point of fail2ban (for ssh)? It definitely won't stop you from getting hacked, nor will it provide any useful data. Especially since any sane brutef
by ryanlol 11y ago
What's the point of fail2ban (for ssh)? It definitely won't stop you from getting hacked, nor will it provide any useful data.
Especially since any sane bruteforcers iterate over IP addresses instead of passwords to avoid just this.
- thraxil 11y agoIt's useful as part of a layered strategy. Your passwords still need to be secure enough that they can't be guessed easily. If they're easily brute-forced, fail2ban might slow things down, but it won't stop it. Once you have that though, fail2ban does do a nice job of making the perpetual brute force attacks significantly less obnoxious. I've seen machines effectively DDoSed by brute-force ssh attempts, either with the network overloaded or filling up disk with ssh's logs of the failed attempts. Not as bad as getting hacked, but still annoying. A serious botnet attack will be able to spread it over thousands of IP addresses, but IME, those are relatively rare. Most attacks are still coming from a handful of hosts at a time and fail2ban basically stops them dead in their tracks. The other useful thing to do with fail2ban is to use it along with a whitelisted range of networks. Even if you aren't on a private network, not every server needs ssh open to the entire world. You can often get away with whitelisting the local network and maybe a few ISPs' ranges where admins are likely to access it from. I run fail2ban even on machines on private networks. If one of the other machines gets hacked, one of the first things they'll usually do is start trying to brute-force other machines on the network. Since it will probably only be a couple compromised machines, fail2ban is useful here. I find that it does also give me useful data as well. Eg, I have simple graphite metrics based on the number of bans/minute. If it gets unusually high, I can get an alert and perhaps notice that other hosts have been compromised, or do a quick firewall rule or two to drop packets from an entire network for a while.