4 ms·
It is affected by that case though because of the policy and guidelines it spawned. > “Because copyright law is limited to ‘original intellectual conceptions o
by rtkwe 11y ago
It is affected by that case though because of the policy and guidelines it spawned.
> “Because copyright law is limited to ‘original intellectual conceptions of the author,’ the Office will refuse to register a claim if it determines that a human being did not create the work,” said the US Copyright Office in its latest compendium of practices published Tuesday. “The Office will not register works produced by nature, animals, or plants.”
and
> In new guidance the USCO has ruled that only works created by a human can be copyrighted under US law, which excludes photographs and artwork created by animals or by machines without human intervention.
Source [0]
This feels like it falls into the 'by machines without human intervention.' There's no meaningful contributions from a human.
All that said this will eventually be an issue (hopefully) when machine intelligence actually takes off or human uploads become a viable operation. Though maybe by then we'll be less obsessed with every idea having to have an owner, but that's neither here nor there.
[0] http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/aug/22/monkey-business-macaque-selfie-cant-be-copyrighted-say-us-and-uk http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/aug/22/monkey-bus...
- spiritplumber 11y agoMonetary concerns aside, I like seeing "by spiritplumber" on my work, even when I'm giving it out.
- rtkwe 11y agoTrue and I'm a big proponent of attribution. I just think that in a lot of cases the person who's assigned ownership of things like a lyric, melody, etc. is really just the lucky one who got to have their name put on a long string of remixes. This is especially bad in music and specifically hip hop where building on earlier music is one of the core tenants. It's easier when the thing in question is still whole and unchanged but ownership of bits and pieces of a copyright work is troublesome to me.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>There's no meaningful contributions from a human. Humans provided the training data. Humans wrote the source. Humans compiled and ran the program.
- bitJericho 11y agoHumans provided the input photograph
- olefoo 11y agohumans caused the photograph to be created... authority is becoming confused. The notion of Intellectual Property is becoming obviously self-contradictory. Who owns the copyright to your soul? Is it Facebook? Is it Google? Did you accidentally assign all of your Intellectual Property to WR Hambrecht? Can you be required to perform on command like a dancing bear? Are the excrescences of your soul merely the feedstock of an industrial process that requires human fleshbrains for supervised learning processes the output of which will be the property of the state since they are formed without human agency? Bullshit. Intellectual Property is Ideal Theft. There are no original ideas. Nothing is true, everything is permitted. There is nothing to be afraid of; resume shopping and avoid panic buying.
- icebraining 11y agoOverstuffed wording aside, copyright is just a set of laws that can be interpreted with more or less ambiguity; it's not some sort of ineffable concept. And laws aren't mathematical theorems; they don't become invalid just because they're self-contradictory. Also, "original" in the law doesn't mean the same as in regular conversation; it merely means it's not an outright copy. That's why a work can be deemed to be derived from other(s), yet still have copyright protection for its own contribution.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>And laws aren't mathematical theorems; they don't become invalid just because they're self-contradictory. No, they just become meaningless (and potentially dangerous). The problem is that people are trying to apply the law to actual mathematical concepts (like bits). Since the law does not model mathematical reality, the law necessarily fails. Many appear to be stuck in the fallacious belief that the law reflects reality, or at least that reality should reflect laws. Of course, this belief is incorrect, doomed to failure, and we see that failure play out all the time, including in this case.