3 ms·
> GPL advocates wanted to limit user freedom in that case. That's disingenuous. GPL advocates don't want to limit users' freedom. GPL's Freedom 0 is allowing u
by pornel 11y ago
> GPL advocates wanted to limit user freedom in that case.
That's disingenuous. GPL advocates don't want to limit users' freedom. GPL's Freedom 0 is allowing users to run code for any purpose.
The problem is that users don't decide what they can run on iPhones. Apple does, and Apple chose to forbid GPL code in the App Store.
---
I've licensed my code under GPL (and sent takedown requests to App Store multiple times) specifically to avoid supporting Apple's user-hostile policies with my gratis work.
App Store users have to give up their software freedom for privilege of using Apple's locked-down system. When my code helps increase number of App Store users, it helps increasing number of users who don't have software freedom.
If I license my app under a DRM-friendly license, then it gives competitive advantage to those who don't want to give users' freedom. Instead I license my apps under a DRM-incompatible license, so they give competitive advantage to those who respect users' freedom.
- stephenr 11y agoThe right to choose a "locked down" platform like iOS is inherently a user right. If you don't want your software to be used on that platform that's your choice, but pretending its about "user rights" is ridiculous.