4 ms·
This also bears repeating: >Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver. >Stallman had a printer which
by epistasis 11y ago
This also bears repeating:
>Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver.
>Stallman had a printer which had proprietary drivers, and he wanted to fix an issue with the driver.
In the fixing mode, Stallman was not operating as a user, he was operating as a developer. This is a "freedom 1" activity, which is a freedom that is only useful for developers.
The user and the developer can not be fully separated when it comes to freedom here. Modification of software, and redistribution of that modification is fundamentally a developer activity. Non-developer users can hire developers to do what they want, but ultimately there's a developer involved in this, otherwise what's the point of source code?
- richardjs 11y agoAny user can become a developer if he or she chooses. The user may decide it requires too much work to learn to code in order to implement a given change, but the option is there nonetheless.
- tome 11y agoThe user can also pay a developer for modifications to open source software. They typically can't do that if the software is proprietary.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoSure, that's freedom 1. But there's also the freedom to redistribute unfettered with no restrictions (sharing with your neighbor), no usage restrictions (freedom 0) and then even non-developer users can know how to make custom builds of a program. Besides, every developer is also a user. Reciprocal guarantees like copyleft ensure user freedom is preserved because all changes are shared across the community, meaning that technical and non-technical users alike benefit from using modified and enhanced copies.
- mikegerwitz 11y agoThis was a story today: http://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-highway/ Let's say I'm a user of that vehicle. I read this article. I want my Jeep audited and fixed, and I want the code modified to indicate any time the vehicle is accepting remote commands. You cannot separate developers and users, because users can hire developers to perform actions on their behalf. I can't fix my own car, but I have problems with it, and I want to be able to hire someone of my choosing to fix it.
- bunderbunder 11y agoConsider an alternative scenario: malware. In that situation, as a consumer, I'm actually pretty jazzed about living inside Apple's walled garden on my iPhone. The phone refusing to run unsigned code gives me a little bit more security. It also largely defeats the scenario where I can hire someone to modify my phone's software. But I'm OK with that tradeoff, because I think it puts me on the side of greatest benefit to myself. I suspect most non-programmer users would fall in the same camp.
- mikegerwitz 11y agoBugs are by definition unintentional. Surely Jeep did not intentionally introduce those flaws. Code signing does not help there.
- llllllllllllll 11y agoYou should think what malware is. Maybe apple software is malware as well. Anyways if you could review the source code of the "malware" you (or people who can read it)could know what it does in advance and avoid it. And code could be signed and verified and still be free software. Linux distros verify software signatures and have almost no malware problems and at the same time use a lot of free software. So free software makes users more secure if anything.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoIf you think about it, package repositories are just like app stores. They're curated, centralized places to obtain software where you can have high confidence it's free of malware. ...And it's free software with no arbitrary usage restrictions. Meaning you can actually audit it if you so desire, and in fact you'll be doing a great service to users and developers in the process.
- llllllllllllll 11y agoExactly linux distributions have had app stores for ages which have a lot of freedom. And then there are things like the arch user repository which is even less controlled and also great.
- betenoire 11y agoHe was a user of the printer first, and his needs arose as a user of the printer. You can't discount that just because he was also the developer.
- kazinator 11y ago> In the fixing mode, Stallman was not operating as a user, he was operating as a developer. This is a "freedom 1" activity, which is a freedom that is only useful for developers. If a "pure user" has an issue, and that issue is with free software, that user can go to the open market and hire a developer to solve the issue. You don't have to be a programmer to benefit from the freedom; that is a fallacy. All users benefit, programmers or not.
- epistasis 11y agoAs I indicate in the very next paragraph.
- bluedino 11y ago>> In the fixing mode, Stallman was not operating as a user, he was operating as a developer. At one time they were very often the same thing
- hasenj 11y agoThey are not anymore. Insisting on old ideas because they used to make sense in the past is .. well .. kind of dogmatic.
- marrs 11y agoNo, but that's not relevant because what quickly happened is that communities of programmers grew around free software projects on which they collaborated, and they made their work widely and easily available at cost of distribution only, which quickly became zero. This means that users of free software don't have to be programmers to benefit from it, and indeed most of them aren't.
- Nursie 11y agoThat seems a rather odd distinction to make. Developers are also users, and users can more easily cross the line into tinkerers and developers if they have source access. In fact I think it's a false distinction.
- asanagi 11y agoYou're striking at the core of the issue here. In RMS's ideal version of the world, there is no distinction: every "user" is also a "developer". The freedom guaranteed by the GPL enables society to reach a state in which every individual is not merely a consumer of solutions, but a producer. In this vision, we all cooperate to solve problems together because solving problems in the world makes the world better for everyone. In reality, problem-solving ability (the intersection of the cognitive ability, skill set, drive, and opportunity to solve problems) is a limited resource. There are problem solvers and there are sheep, a configuration that results in a natural kind of economy. "Corporate" with all its lawyers and sales hucksters, i.e. persons not directly engaged in the work of solving problems, are a necessary demon. They connect problem solvers with users that have problems to solve. Users, for their part, exist to give us their money as a reward for the work of solving their problems. Whether to support the GPL is really a moral decision about which world you believe in. Do you solve problems to make the world a better place, or to make more money for yourself? I personally wish RMS' vision would come true even though I don't believe it's possible. There are natural limitations to problem-solving ability other than the psychological effects of the capitalist environment on those who grow up in it. Still. When you really dig to the bottom of opposition to the GPL, you always find one thing, and one thing only. Money. "ME".