3 ms·
> but I really can't stop thinking about my wife and kids What about all those wives and kids that would have been endangered if the flaw had continued to go u
by the8472 11y ago
> but I really can't stop thinking about my wife and kids
What about all those wives and kids that would have been endangered if the flaw had continued to go unfixed and exploited in a more malicious manner?
Can we please not make "BUT THINK OF THE CHILDREN" arguments? Appealing to emotion makes arguments, well, emotional.
- hoopism 11y agoBy saying this you are basically saying there was no reasonable alternative method of exposing this. I am unwilling to say that. This argument that somehow the ends justify the means when there was a clearly more safe means has to stop. It's just ignorant.
- ripter 11y ago> By saying this you are basically saying there was no reasonable alternative method of exposing this. No, he's saying you need a better argument.
- kbenson 11y agoThe two options here are not "test on highway with other drivers" and "let flaw exist with no testing and no exposure". There are many ways to responsibly test this while not endangering others on a public road. For example, using a private road, a large empty parking lot, an abandoned airforce base, the salt flats, etc. The Mythbusters test stuff like this all the time. What do they do? Use an abandoned airforce base or the Utah salt flats. Rule number one, don't endanger the public.
- yellowapple 11y ago> For example, using a private road, a large empty parking lot, an abandoned airforce base, the salt flats, etc. The researchers did many of these things, according to the article. They were ignored by auto makers.
- kbenson 11y agoIf you increase the danger of a situation to increase it's exposure, you can't be surprised when that causes repercussions. I doubt they will go to jail, but I do think alerting the authorities was the right call. In fact, they may have been counting on that. If they really want to increase the exposure of a story, start a public debate. The easiest way to do that? Get some public outrage going. They called this all out, they'll need to deal with the consequences.
- yellowapple 11y agoI don't disagree with you on that. The researchers (and WiReD) should certainly be aware of the risks here, and be prepared to accept the repercussions thereof. On the other hand, while two wrongs don't make a right, I'm glad that the researchers made that choice, so long as said choice results in manufacturers actually taking car security seriously for once.
- krackers 11y agoDid they publicize it on Wired like they did with this post? I'm reasonably sure that if they had tested in a private track and made a public article it would have the same effect as what they did in their post. In essence, the publicity factor is the most important, not where they tested it.
- waterlesscloud 11y agoDifferent hackers, over a year ago, in a semi-controlled environment, on Vice. Didn't have much of an effect. http://www.vice.com/video/how-to-hack-a-car http://www.vice.com/video/how-to-hack-a-car
- krackers 11y agoI didn't watch the full video, but at 6:45 it states "Unlike most previously recorded car hacks, this demonstration was performed wirelessly over cellular networks. The vehicle shown is modified with third-party hardware for demo purposes. In stock form it is not vulnerable to these attacks" which is quite different from the level of vulnerability showcased in the Wired article.
- devindotcom 11y ago>What about all those wives and kids that would have been endangered >Can we please not make "BUT THINK OF THE CHILDREN" arguments
- dopamean 11y agoThis comment is shockingly naive. Can you really not think of any other way to demonstrate the vulnerability they found without taking the whole thing onto open public roadways? Safety researchers who work for auto manufacturers don't go out on the highway to do crash test exams and we trust their outcomes.
- the8472 11y agoObviously they don't. But chrysler was informed and created a patch. But what they didn't do is ensuring that it gets rolled out to everyone vulnerable.
- efuquen 11y ago> What about all those wives and kids that would have been endangered if the flaw had continued to go unfixed and exploited in a more malicious manner? Because, he said anything like that right? What a gratuitous use of a strawman. It's not appealing to emotions, it's pretty rational to think this experiment could have easily caused an accident and hurt people. We all rationally know that driving is one of the most dangerous forms of travel. Seriously, a car is a dangerous, fast, multi-ton piece of metal, it's not a toy to experiment on when other people's safety is at stake. Respect the vehicle and the damage it could cause. The exploits can and will be published and reported on quite easily without these reckless theatrics.