3 ms·
... and here's a takedown of your takedown: http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2009/12/11/fernholz-vs-taibbi/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2009/12/
by barrkel 17y ago
... and here's a takedown of your takedown:
http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2009/12/11/fernholz-vs-taibbi/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2009/12/11/fernholz-vs...
Key quotes:
> often Taibbi simply doesn’t say what Fernholz implies that he says
> the schadenfreude over Fernholz’s attack on Taibbi is particularly weird since they seem to actually agree with each other
> This is quite astonishing. Fernholz is basically saying that Taibbi is right
If you're going to link to a takedown, make sure it's actually a takedown.
- tptacek 17y agoFrom the "takedown of the takedown": In any case, I feel that Fernholz is a bit like Heidi Moore: he’s missed the point of Taibbi’s polemical style. Taibbi is not interested in an writing an even-handed examination of Obama’s economic policies: he’s interested in writing an enjoyable screed which jumps off the page and which describes Alan Greenspan as “a staggeringly incompetent economic forecaster who was worshipped by four decades of politicians because he once dated Barbara Walters”. This stuff isn’t meant to be taken nearly as literally as Fernholz is taking it — but in any case, Fernholz’s game of gotcha comes up with precious little of real substance. Later: Yes, Taibbi is polemical and one-sided, and he exaggerates his thesis, and he’s entertaining; I daresay he’s learned a lot from watching Fox News. And no, I would never want to live in a world where everybody wrote like that. But Taibbi is one of a kind, and we can enjoy him and learn from him as such.