3 ms·
That's correct for highway speeds.... What happens when I'm stuck in a ditch or sand or in a rut and need delicate manoeuvering? Maybe I'm out in a field in t
by mc32 11y ago
That's correct for highway speeds....
What happens when I'm stuck in a ditch or sand or in a rut and need delicate manoeuvering? Maybe I'm out in a field in the middle of nowhere. No roads, just open field with seasonal hazards.
I still want a way to guide the vehicle manually without having to call someone with a winch.
- outworlder 11y agoI'd suspect we are further away from self-driving, offroad cars. At least for roads the cars have a set path to follow, with choices at intersections.
- mc32 11y agoOk how about navigating into my garage? Maybe I want extra space on the left this time?
- jessaustin 11y agoMost self-driving cars won't be stored in our garages, because we won't own them. That's one of their big advantages.
- mc32 11y agoI might want to back it up just tight at the Ikea dock to pick something up. Don't let "garage" get in the way of thinking of why you might need to take over manual steering. As amply exemplified above, single lane situation with two way traffic.
- jack-r-abbit 11y agoThat could be solved easily (and probably more accurately) by just having a few nudge buttons or some other UI. Use them for those "Move left a few more inches" or "Back up just a little more" situations. These cars should be able to do fine maneuvering/adjustments much better than a lot of people can.
- jessaustin 11y agoIkea already delivers. It's difficult to imagine that they'll deliver less when they won't have to hire drivers to do so. The robo-delivery-van won't only lack a steering wheel, it will lack a seat. I envision doors on the front, and sliding dividers that push the next delivery forward when the van backs out of the driveway of the preceding delivery. These will not be cars as we have known them. Most people today don't like cars as we have known them, nor the cruft that has built around that. A vocal minority here on HN really likes cars, exactly as they are, and they don't want to hear about these changes. That's OK, people who want to waste money on old-timey cars will be able to do so, for at least a few decades. If not have a steering wheel blows your mind, hold on: which direction do you think the front seats will face, in the typical robocar? [EDIT] I'm dreaming of a time when few people buy cars, so we'll no longer be plagued with car commercials.
- mc32 11y agoOne positive thing of emasculating ourselves from cars will be the dear of the car chase trope in French, Chinese, American, Australian, Indian and Nigerian cinema.
- jessaustin 11y agoHaha I love the verb choice! I'd expect chase scenes to endure, and they'll probably include robocars, but also hacks to get around/take advantage of their inherent chase limitations. E.g.: someone on a bicycle could intentionally ride through a crowd of pedestrians knowing that robocars won't just blast through to follow. Or the police could shut down a robocar remotely, but the fugitive could figure out how to escape the locked car. Etc.
- slantyyz 11y agoI would buy one if I could. There's something to be said about having instant access to a car vs. having to wait for one to arrive.
- eCa 11y agoI would be surprised if there is no low-speed manual maneuverability with a joystick or somesuch.
- monk_e_boy 11y agoThere are a lot of roads where I live that are one lane, with passing places. Or most of the time both drivers have to aim for a wide-ish part of the road and both bump up the hedge a bit. God knows how Google car will do that, half the tourists have problems figuring it out. It's common to meet a car, both pause while the drivers try to figure out who has a better chance of reversing 500 wiggly metres to a passing place. If you meet an old lady, man, just stick it in reverse and drive as far as you need, waiting for her to even find reverse is pointless.
- arethuza 11y agoQuite a lot of those here in Scotland - and there is a fair amount of etiquette around how to drive properly on them without other people (locals) getting very annoyed with you. I can't see any reason why self driving cars couldn't manage single track with passing places better than people - especially if they knew where the passing places are and could communicate with other cars.
- fixermark 11y agoThe scenario described is so rare, that "calling someone with a winch" is likely to become the de-facto scenario. Why the unnecessary redundancy of having every car able to be controlled manually when in the very, very common case it's not needed? People already keep AAA memberships in their wallets instead of a spare tire, tire wrench, jack, jumper cables, and starter one-shot battery in their trunk.
- gambiting 11y agoRare? Where? Where I live we get a very heavy snowfall in Winter, and even a regular trip to shops ends in me trying to get moving again by rocking the car back and forth to get out of snow. Unless automatic vehicles will drive only on clean, dry roads in pristine condition?
- jessaustin 11y ago[EDIT] OK you have snow tires. Then what's the deal? I've lived in snowbound places, without snow tires, and rarely had difficulty getting moving again after parking half an hour to shop. Sure, if you leave your car in a bad spot during a snowstorm you'll have problems in the morning, but most robocars will never have that problem, because they will only park in safe secure areas and only during the 2AM-5AM "quiet" period when people don't want to go places.
- gambiting 11y agoI have a set of snow tyres, and chains are illegal on regular roads, even in snow.
- slantyyz 11y ago>> I've lived in snowbound places, without snow tires, and rarely had difficulty getting moving again That is a YMMV statement. I live in Canada, and after a major snowfall, I've seen plenty people get stuck --while-- driving on residential streets that hadn't been plowed yet. Starting from a stop and going up hills are often a problem in that situation too.