7 ms·
You called the cops on two security researchers and a journalist, because you disagreed with their methods and weren't sure what their plans were and what autho
by geofft 11y ago
You called the cops on two security researchers and a journalist, because you disagreed with their methods and weren't sure what their plans were and what authorities they'd talked to? (And not just any cops, the cops in St. Louis, for bonus points.)
Are we still on Hacker News, or is the transformation to Enablers of Traditional American Power Structure News complete?
- epochwolf 11y agoThere's plenty of safe ways to accomplish this kind of demonstration. The fact they choose to do so in a way that endangered the public is in fact criminal. Being a security researcher or journalist doesn't give you a license to put the public in physical danger.
- astrodust 11y agoI'm sure the police are even more ill-equipped to understand the ramifications of this demonstration and will over-react and start jailing anyone with a laptop and suspicious intent. I can't wait for the pathetic outrage when "racial profiling" now means harassing white kids with laptops that fit the profile of hacker. This is a matter for a company like Google to take on politically, not some beat cop in St. Louis of all places.
- mattdotc 11y agoThis has nothing to do with the type of test they ran and everything to do with where and how they ran it.
- astrodust 11y agoI totally agree that there's a problem here, but I strongly disagree with the method of action. Why not engage the FBI? This is not an issue specific to St. Louis. Throwing some researchers in jail solves nothing. This is a way bigger deal than some local offense. You need an agency with the ability to see the bigger picture.
- taejo 11y agoHow is deliberately disabling a vehicle on a highway the FBI's jurisdiction?
- astrodust 11y agoHow is it not given they could have disabled any vehicle with that vulnerability? This basically suggests thousands of cars could be driven off the road and deliberately crashed right now. I'd say that's a threat that they need to deal with at the national level on an immediate basis. Would you rather wait for a malicious actor like North Korea to get involved before the FBI makes a move? What I'm trying to say is I'd rather the FBI gets involved and works with these researchers to develop an expedient fix for this problem than some beat cop in St. Louis to bust them and throw them in jail where they help nobody and the threat remains extremely grave.
- shoeboxam 11y agoIn addition, being a security researcher doesn't give you a license to put the public in any form of danger! That's why we have private disclosures.
- geofft 11y agoThe researchers did disclose it privately. As always, the believable pressure of public disclosure makes the process work. https://twitter.com/0xcharlie/status/623492229714313216 https://twitter.com/0xcharlie/status/623492229714313216
- shoeboxam 11y agoIn addition, being a security researcher doesn't give you a license to put the public in any form of danger! That's why we have private disclosures.
- talmand 11y agoAre you not supposed to report dangerous, and possibly criminal, situations to the authorities? A witness to such events cannot know if it has already been reported or is known about, are they supposed to just go on with their day? Yep, just drive by that car accident with possible injuries without calling it in because I'm sure someone else has already taken care of it. What's the worse that could happen? The authorities tell you they are already aware of the situation, thank you? Are we now people who should no longer care what's going on around us or are we careless souls more worried about ourselves to not care over fellow human beings?
- calgoo 11y agoSorry, but the cops lost that trust from me when the started sending swat teams and abusing power way to much. Since then, to me calling the cops has become a last resort. I dont trust ANY of them because of the few aholes that are abusing their power. Mainly caused because of their policies of shutting up and protecting each others. Until they fix this, i will not trust ANY cop again.
- jamespo 11y agoUntil you're a victim of a crime I presume
- spacehome 11y agoI'm not sure how this would make calgoo change his mind. * Cops are under no obligation to go into harms way to protect the public. * Cops primarily exist to collect evidence for prosecution after the fact. * Just because criminals and crimes exist doesn't take away from cops' bad behavior. * If calgoo becomes the victim of a crime, cops are unlikely to be able to make him whole again - for bodily injury, prosecution of the perpretrator can't restore his body or life - for property damage or theft, police usually can't be bothered with the small stuff.
- mc32 11y agoThere are problems with power and corruption.... But Have you seen what happens to communities when police withdraw? They become overrun by gangs and other less accountable organizations. Even favelas where cops act paramilitarily, say in Caracas, people still want cops because no cops is usually worse, unless you get a private version of cops, which is essentially cops by another name.
- hughw 11y agoHN is chock full of self-righteous hall monitors. They usually don't progress to the point of calling the cops.
- maxerickson 11y agoCan you expand a little on how calling the police about something is more or less self righteous than doing the (at least somewhat dangerous) experiment on a public highway?
- SG- 11y agoNever talk to the police. At least in places like St-Louis and other cities with historically bad police departments (most of the US).
- sfafdsdf 11y agoIt's interesting how you view this issue. If the researchers are more self-righteous than the person calling in, it justifies the latter?
- maxerickson 11y agoNo, it just makes directing that line of criticism at the caller pretty inane.
- invisible_dust 11y agoHall monitors are the best way I could imagine these people being described as. I completely agree.
- notNow 11y agoIt's definitely elementary school stuff to snitch and play the informant on your colleagues. The worst thing that this was coming from an old fart stuckup who thinks that they could police every thing and everyone around them and act more royal than the king himself. Old habits die hard.
- moistgorilla 11y agoThe fact of the matter is that this is Startup News not Hacker news. Hardly anybody on this website is a hacker. Most are people that code html and php in their day job and go home and do normal shit. These are people that complain about how the industry "pressures" them into coding in their free time.
- roflchoppa 11y agolook mom I'm a hacker too :^)
- Raphmedia 11y agoAs much as it seem over the top, those researcher could have hurt people. Calling the police will not have them go to jail or have their data deleted. It might (rightfully) get them a fine. It will however ensure that their next experiments are done in a safer, more legal way. Calling the police isn't all about emergency. You can call them to talk about issues that worry you such as this one. They will take care of bringing the issue the the right entities, it's their job.
- brandon272 11y ago> Calling the police will not have them go to jail or have their data deleted. It might (rightfully) get them a fine. It will however ensure that their next experiments are done in a safer, more legal way. Or not done at all. I may not fully agree with their methodology but I'm thankful this work is being done by people with good intentions instead of having these issues come to light when people with malicious intent find the vulnerability and kill or maim countless people.
- gknoy 11y ago> Calling the police will not have them go to jail or have their data deleted. Do we read the same Internet news? Having seen the way the law enforcement + prosecution machine works in cases like Aaron Schwartz, I would be surprised if these researchers did not spend time in jail, and didn't at least face charges of some Serious Nature. If there's a case to be made, the police will build it. If they build it, the DA will prosecute it, and there could be (is going to be?) things like charges under the CFAA, since they could certainly try the perspective that the access needed to be authorized by the auto manufacturer, rather than the owner of the car. I could totally see how invoking the power of the police on these researchers could, through the kind of progression we've seen many times before, destroy their lives. I really hope that's not the case -- I'd much rather they got some kind of warning like, "Don't you ever do this on a road with other people on it again". Even so, I agree with many others that their actions were pretty reckless, more so than I realized when I first read the article. This is the kind of thing that should have been done on a private test track, and doing it around others was reckless and negligent.
- EugeneOZ 11y agoI glad to see he did it. Not all "hackers" should be non-responsible kids who think about police as about enemies.
- afarrell 11y ago> Because you disagreed with their methods This isn't really engaging with his action. Specifically, because called the cops because he believed that their methods put people in danger of physical harm. This objection isn't coherent without an argument either that: 1) He was unreasonable in his belief that they'd put people in harm's way. or 2) It is not appropriate to contact law enforcement as a result of observing one person put another in harms way. I'm guessing you're arguing both, correct? aside: He contacted the state highway patrol, not the local St. Louis police. aside2: Hi Geofft! How are things going?
- geofft 11y agoHi! :) My argument is roughly that we don't know for sure that people were put in harm's way, and we have good reason, as hackers, not to trust the legal system to reliably figure these sorts of things out (and they generally fail in the direction of being worse for both individual researchers and society of a whole). If we did empirically find the legal system reliable and fair, I'd be more convinced that the threshold for objecting should be "unreasonable". The action is also over right now, and I see no indication that they intend to do so again. So this is either about punishment-as-retribution, or about dissuading future researchers from doing similar things. I don't think retribution is particularly justifiable, and I think there are better ways to dissuade future researchers, like having a conversation about it without the police involved. So I guess I'm arguing the specific sub-case of 2 that if they don't intend to put someone in harms' way again, law enforcement isn't necessarily right. (You're right about the highway patrol thing, btw. I think I had it confused in my head with some other recent public/police conflict where the highway patrol was worse than the local police, but it looks like the opposite was true of the Ferguson protests.)
- odbol 11y agoIf he was actually concerned, and not just outraged, he would have called the police and reported Chrysler for endangering thousands of people's lives.
- discardorama 11y ago"Hacking" is not what's portrayed in movies. The researchers could have achieved the exact same results (albeit with fewer clicks) by conducting this experiment in a remote parking lot or a private road. Heck, if the writer had contacted the cops, they could have given him an escort to make sure nothing bad happens. If you ask me, it is this kind of behavior that makes the work of real researchers harder, as the media is quick to paint all security researchers as clueless nerds who will put people at risk.
- yellowapple 11y ago> The researchers could have achieved the exact same results (albeit with fewer clicks) by conducting this experiment in a remote parking lot or a private road. According to the article, the researchers already did as early as 2013. Auto manufacturers ignored the reports while continuing to pretend that their vehicles are secure.
- jamespo 11y agoYou've said that a dozen times in this thread with no direct quotes or proof
- discardorama 11y agoAccording to the article, that experiment required physical access to the car; it was NOT a remote experiment like this one.
- yellowapple 11y agoIt still demonstrated the same root problem: that the computerized systems on cars today have very little in way of basic safeguards. And there was indeed quite a bit of cracking UConnect and wirelessly spying on Dodges and Chryslers throughout the country before the experiment. If I were an auto manufacturer, I wouldn't wait until someone finds a wireless exploit (at which point it's too late to do anything about it before people die or are maimed unless I'm lucky enough for the zero-day to be found by a white-hat or grey-hat). I'd see those earlier reports, say "holy shit if we have one wireless bug, the whole car could be pwned", and start working on a better isolation of critical systems from internet-connected systems immediately.
- mannykannot 11y ago> You called the cops on two security researchers and a journalist, because you disagreed with their methods... Calling it a disagreement over methods glosses over the real issue, which is that it was a dangerous exercise and its perpetrators apparently don't have sufficiently good judgement to be left to their own devices.