7 ms·
You're not gonna make the news unless the media can spin up a headline that scares people People won't pay attention until they're scared People won't demand
by dsfyu404ed 11y ago
You're not gonna make the news unless the media can spin up a headline that scares people
People won't pay attention until they're scared
People won't demand action if they're not paying attention
Nothing will happened if people don't demand action.
If nothing happens the status quo (vulnerable systems) will remain. Until some bad actor (I'm sure several nations states would love that capability) gets into onStar and turns every connected vehicle (every GM made in the last 8yr or so) into a brick at an inconvenient time (rush hour on a monday).
>I've just phoned 'Troop C' of the Highway Patrol at their main number, +1-636-300-2800 and they seemed pretty keen to follow up. The fact that the vehicle was disabled where there was no shoulder, was impeding traffic, and the demo not cleared with them in advance has them concerned. I'm all for testing exploits and security research, but this isn't the right way to do it. And to film it and post it to a high traffic site is nuts.
I'm not sure if you're actually this dense or just trolling. What good can involving the police, after the fact, in a situation where nobody was harmed do?
To clarify: If a story involving events of questionable legality, no matter how small to were hit the news the police would be obligated to investigate on some level. Think about the kind of message that "we saw it on the news but we don't think it's worth investigating" would send. By informing them before it hits the general news, one enables the "swat teams and more" knee-jerk response that the police love (if I had cool toys I'd want to play with them too) but without any media scrutiny. For example, law enforcement was plenty eager to screw the guy that "hacked and airplane" (through similar means I might add) until the story became more widespread and they had to use their discretion to act in a manner that would not reflect poorly on them.
By alerting the State Police in advance they're
I don't expect this to hit the news. University of IIRC Michigan (something with an M) was doing similar things at closer range (bluetooth) on a test track back in 09(?) and nobody cared.
And for all the people saying they were "reckless and dangerous, etc, etc," sure, yeah, to a small extent. If they wanted to be reckless they'd have made the car go instead of stop, swapped left and right on the electronic power steering, disabled the brakes on one side or end of the car, etc, etc.
- leereeves 11y agoReckless endangerment/criminal negligence is a crime even if nobody is harmed. The hackers may have crossed the line if they disabled the engine on a narrow stretch of a busy highway. It should be investigated.
- ObviousScience 11y ago> I'm not sure if you're actually this dense or just trolling. What good can involving the police, after the fact, in a situation where nobody was harmed do? People who do one reckless thing such as this demo are likely to do others. Calling the police about this incident means that they'll have a record of the people doing this, and if it becomes a pattern, handle it considerably harsher than an isolated incident.
- nekopa 11y ago>I'm not sure if you're actually this dense or just trolling. What good can involving the police, after the fact, in a situation where nobody was harmed do? I don't know, maybe if they get in trouble the next researcher who wants to do a test by disabling a car doing 70mph on a public road will maybe just alert a few people and make sure that it would be impossible for someone innocent to die during their testing. I was with your comment until you called the GP dense or a troll. Because to follow your logic, to get action, they should've just actually killed a random person. Then you'd be right, we would get some changes, pretty quick. Who do you think should be the random person to get killed for change?
- yellowapple 11y ago> Who do you think should be the random person to get killed for change? If we decide now, then it wouldn't be a random person, now would it? :)
- genericuser 11y agoI agree they may not make news if they did this in a safe manner. However, the goal of people researching security, shouldn't be to make news. And these people while admittedly working with Chrysler to see it fixed, seem to be forgetting that. Especially since they plan to release their code, despite the fact that Chrysler has to get people to manually update their cars. "The two researchers say that even if their code makes it easier for malicious hackers to attack unpatched Jeeps, the release is nonetheless warranted because it allows their work to be proven through peer review." Their justification for releasing their code, as someone who works in peer reviewed industries is weak and they clearly are prioritizing attention over security at this point.
- shkkmo 11y agoThey could have made still made the news if they had taken a few extra precautions to reduce the risk of an accident. However, they do need to make the news. Them making the news makers it easier and more likely that politicians will prioritize the political capital of working to solve this over the lobbyist from the automotive industry. If Chrysler and other car manufacturers were taking this sufficiently seriously the releases might not be necessary. They gave Chrysler plenty of warning, Chrysler could have issued a recall (and still can), the consequences are on Chrysler, not on the security researchers.
- genericuser 11y agoYou do realize a recall doesn't make all the cars come back on their own to get fixed right? Hell many consumers don't even realize there was a recall till their product fails for the reason it was recalled. Chrysler seems to be taking this sufficiently seriously enough that releasing the code will do more harm than good. Could they take it more seriously? Well everything can always be taken more seriously, and someone will always claim it should. So I will say that's a matter of opinion. EDIT: If their plan to 'release their code' is nothing more than a bluff to raise awareness I would consider that a much more appropriate course of action.
- timtadh 11y agoI saw a presentation at a departmental colloquium 3 years ago which demonstrated similar capabilities. The point is, car companies are not responding well to this threat even though it is well known to them. In such situations it is in the public's best interest that information about the vulnerabilities be widely disseminated in order to keep the general public safe. Those with know how can already exploit these flaws and likely have been for years. The car companies need to act to secure their customer's systems.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wil421 11y agoThey didnt have to do this on a public highway. A large parking lot would have be sufficient. Why should other motorists be subject to harm because a couple hackers and a reporter want to make a story. They could've easily gone on one of the 24hr news channels to scare the masses.
- Someone1234 11y agoOr heck even a quiet public road. There are tons of inter-state roads that have single-digit numbers of cars an hour. Just drive out into the desert and play around. PS - Plus due to the flatness of these roads, with large de-facto shoulders you can pull off onto, they're much safer even ignoring traffic levels.
- stephengillie 11y agoYes, yes. We wouldn't be having this big thread about the safety of the experiment, and consideration for other motorists, if they hadn't done it this way. If they had done this in a parking lot at 25 MPH with a couple cops present, the way Mythbusters does things, they would have ONLY had a story about hacking a Jeep to shut it down. And if they played their cards right, they might even be able to start some LEO contracts for car-disabling equipment.
- sliverstorm 11y agoSo what you're saying is this was small potatoes and they should have caused a pile-up.
- asanagi 11y ago>People won't pay attention until they're scared You aren't allowed to scare people into social change, Citizen. Only the thugs in uniform are allowed to do that.