5 ms·
A few comments (which aren't necessarily a complaint about your product) from a firefighter/paramedic: 1. Nursing home staff should be able to recognize typica
by FireBeyond 11y ago
A few comments (which aren't necessarily a complaint about your product) from a firefighter/paramedic:
1. Nursing home staff should be able to recognize typical and atypical signs of cardiac arrest ('should' being a key part of this).
2. My county's 911 service (serving 300,000 people) has the following response times: 6.0min for BLS (Basic Life Support) services, 6.1min for ALS (Advanced Life Support). 15 minute response times would be... a whole new world.
3. Impending cardiac arrest, I'd be curious as to what the 'difference made' would be. Administering ASA (aspirin)? Not emergently significant. Nitro? Typically self-administered, and again, I'd question the quality of a nursing facility that didn't feel comfortable administering such drugs based on vitals and symptoms alone, without needing the assistance of an ED physician (granted, several in our area as a policy/liability concern will immediately phone 911 as their 'treatment plan' for these situations - but similarly, these same facilities would be on the low end of the bell curve for utilizing a service like Call9).
4. Similarly, a nursing facility that wasn't vigorous in training and utilization of CPR/AED (because that's the number one hope for an arrest patient, high quality chest compressions - in the absence of tele-EKG for administering cardiac drugs for certain arrhythmias and dysrhythmia - again, if your 911 arrival time is 15+ minutes, perhaps...)
I can definitely see a use case for anything that moves from "proactive" (nor necessarily in a positive, often actually a negative sense) ED / 911 visit called by a skilled nursing facility. Indeed any increase in the use of a community outreach / service for high risk patients is a good thing.
I did read that you are indeed going to supply EKG and US to clients, and this helps - but I'd be curious about the value of some interventions. A presentation of impending cardiac arrest should be a first call to 911 (I realize your example presented with constipation and stomach pain). And in the context of having to talk a nurse through an EKG, what interventions do you really expect them to be able to reliably perform (start an IO/IV)? I am intrigued though, to see how this could grow, but it seems to me that your target might want to be 'urgent care' as much as emergency medicine.
Of course, where 911 response truly is that slow (and I know that it can be in several parts of the country), then anything that helps the patient's prognosis cannot be a bad thing.
- uber_for_cats 11y agoLook their own sales pitch in the article is the death knell for this startup. Protocol with 911: * Person has suspected heart attack symptoms. * 911 is called, short triage on the phone. * Ambulance is dispatched. Protocol with this new startup: * Person has suspected heart attack symptoms. * Skype with doctor, short triage on Skype. * Doctor quickly trains nurse (conveniently available on site) to take EKG (presumably while patient is grasping his chest). * Nurse takes first EKG in her life. * Doctor reads EKG, and calls 911. Who in their right mind would call a gatekeeper instead of 911 in an emergency?
- tpeck 11y agoIf I may clarify some of the misunderstandings of what happens in a typical emergency. If a patient is clutching their chest, we're calling our ambulance service, not doing an EKG. However, the great majority of heart attacks don't present with crushing chest pain. If they did, Emergency Care would be easy, and EM docs wouldn't have had to do 11 years of schooling to recognize and treat these subtleties. The patient that the TechCrunch article is referring too had a subtle tachypnea (slightly elevated respiratory rate because the dying heart muscle causes the blood to become acidic and so the body compensates by blowing off Co2) and a vague abdominal discomfort with a lot of confounding factors like constipation. This patient would not get an EKG in the overwhelming majority of nursing homes in the country, and it's not their fault! It's just because the system doesn't allow for the evaluation the patient may need. Also - an EKG is quite easy to do - this is a non-issue.
- Jessdonig 11y agoHi, this is Jessica from Call9. Just wanted to address a few points here: 1) When you call 911, you talk to a gatekeeper. That gatekeeper is a phone dispatcher, not a doctor. Talking to a doctor is not a delay in care--it's the reason people call 911 in the first place. 2) Since Call9 works with facilities such as nursing homes and has access to patient information, using Call9 actually saves time in the dispatch process. 3) As described in the article, it's not always that clear to the person calling 911 has "suspected heart attack symptoms". In the given example, he presented with abdominal pain. That is why having the doctor be the first point of contact is so important.
- tpeck 11y agoSo many good questions/points. Responding to each: 1. This would be an ideal world, but it just isn't the case. Nor do I think its a feasible solution to train nursing home nurses to be as knowledgeable about pathophysiology as physicians. Subtleties of acute cardiac syndrome (heart attacks, etc) are difficult to recognize, and it takes a few years of residency after medical school to be able to quickly recognize and act on them. There are many great nurses that can too, but that usually comes with lots of experience in critical situations (especially in the ICU, ER, and PACU). Nursing home nurses just don't have the same exposure to critically ill patients. 2. Which county? Those are great times. A word of caution when interpreting response times - they often start the clock at the time of dispatch, not the time of the patient calling 911. A lot of Call9's value is cutting out the inefficiencies between the 911 call and the dispatch. 3. Administering aspirin (ASA) is very significant. Anti-platelet therapy (e.g. aspirin) has been shown to decrease the mortality of heart attack patients significantly, and the earlier you give the aspirin, the sooner it works. As for nitroglycerin ('nitro'), the medication that dilates the blood vessels on the hearts surface and allows for better oxygen delivery to heart muscle as its dying in a heart attack, it is extremely dangerous to self administer nitro in certain situations that can only be interpreted if you have an EKG - in one of our patients, we in fact identified this issue and purposefully held the nurses giving off this medication which could have killed the patient. As for the nursing home, this situation happened in, the nurses are well trained and I've been happy with their level of care and concern for their patients. 4. I too think a proactive response makes sense. Good point about the utility of these diagnostics - we surely have cases where they are useful in facilitating the care of patient in an emergency. But they are extremely useful in preventing unnecessary hospitalizations - another key value of Call9. In this way, we do practice urgent care too. . Thanks for your comments - seems like you've been in the field and know your stuff.
- FireBeyond 11y agoThanks for the thoughtful reply! I agree, the ideal world and the real world are two very different things. Though still, given the length of your average RN course (or even LPN, since as we're talking real world, many nursing facilities are supervised by one RN over many LPNs) versus EMT... certainly it "should" be better. You do make a very good point about the nature of chronic versus acute patients. 2. Thurston (http://www.co.thurston.wa.us/medic1/stats.htm http://www.co.thurston.wa.us/medic1/stats.htm) - I'm not entirely sure about the measurement of response time, would have to clarify with a dispatchers. 3. Thank you for calling out this. Agreed, ASA is very significant, and should not be discounted. I meant that emergently it's not going to improve patient condition, but I should have acknowledged that's only one part of the treatment plan. NTG, too, at least here, is typically administered or assisted by BLS with numerous contra-indications (brady/tachycardia, hypotension, etc), but most patients I have seen are instructed by their physician to self-administer with symptoms "similar to previous cardiac event". I'm presuming right ventricular infarction on your example patient? As said elsewhere, I would like to see a service like this succeed, and apologize if I come off 'skeptical' in some of my comments!
- mattmireles 11y agoI worked 911 in NYC and LA. The incompetence of Nursing Home Staff is often quite astounding. It was common to arrive for a call of "general illness" only to find the patient in respiratory failure or cardiac arrest with no CPR in progress. I see this as providing a fast way for clueless staff to up-triage patients.
- FireBeyond 11y agoYeah. Anything that can be done to limit the damage of "ignorance and/or incompetence" is always a good thing. My pet hate is always "Do you have a history on the patient or what's been going on?" was almost invariably answered with: a) "No, this is my first day", or b) "No, I just got on shift" Oh. Good.
- civil2 11y agoTelemedicine can potentially add value in many settings, like here http://nyti.ms/1fyWXeK http://nyti.ms/1fyWXeK. What I disagree with is their misleading marketing as an alternative to 911. For regular people, this service is like a family doctor visit on Skype. Sometimes it can be handy, but it remains to be seen how this impacts outcomes statistically. (I wouldn't use this myself.) For healthcare facilities, like nursing homes, this is like providing a doctor on call via telemedicine. Many hospitals already do this with radiologists or neurologists for example. What is misleading is their marketing jump from these potentially useful scenarios to advertising as an alternative to 911 for the general public, and even claiming that they are faster than 911 when in fact they are a gatekeeper to 911.
- ams6110 11y agoWhile not wanting to paint with too broad a brush, many nursing/assisted living facilities have as a first priority the avoidance or at least dilution of liability. For example, in one facility, the management, the building owner, and the nursing provider will likely be three separate business entities. I can easily imagine that "call 911" is start and end of their approach to emergencies. If the patient dies, well there are probably 10 more people on the waitlist for that room.
- 11y ago
- semerda 11y agoDitto. 15 mins response times are old statistics. "Since the 1970s, arriving within eight minutes 90% of the time has been the gold standard for determining the quality of an EMS system." "NFPA 1710 states that first responders and BLS units must arrive on scene within a four-minute timeframe 90% of the time for all incidents. The ALS crew that must respond within eight minutes." Source: http://www.jems.com/articles/2012/02/great-ambulance-response-time-debate.html http://www.jems.com/articles/2012/02/great-ambulance-respons...