10 ms·
Chicago fires investigator who found cops at fault in shootings
- ClayM 11y agoThis is pretty much all you need to read: Davis’s termination came less than two weeks after top IPRA officials, evaluating Davis’s job performance, accused him of “a clear bias against the police” and called him “the only supervisor at IPRA who resists making requested changes as directed by management in order to reflect the correct finding with respect to OIS,” as officer-involved shootings are known in the agency. Since its 2007 creation, IPRA has investigated nearly 400 civilian shootings by police and found one to be unjustified.
- jMyles 11y agoCan you imagine if your build process worked that way? "Yeah, the integration tests failed 400 times, but in all but one of them, it was the test runner that was the problem."
- sp332 11y agoOur product killed 400 people, but we're pretty sure 399 of them deserved it.
- yebyen 11y agoTo be fair, that they were shot by an officer does not imply that they were killed. Of course I haven't read the statistics in detail, maybe we're only investigating these cases because they were cases where the person was killed. </cynical outlook>
- serge2k 11y agoOr it could reasonably be "Yeah, the integration tests failed 400 times, but, in all but one of them, the failure was indicative of an actual problem with the system". 1 out of 400 could easily mean the police use justified force almost all the time. Of course then they probably wouldn't be firing investigators, but there you go.
- jMyles 11y agoI guess it depends on what counts as a "pass." I think that the state mortally wounding someone is always a failure. There are different severity levels, to be sure, but there's a reason that they're all investigated. Even in the (in my estimation) relatively small fraction that are in fact truly, expressly legally justified, it's a failure on a different layer of the stack.
- jMyles 11y agoReading about the internal administrative process in large municipal governments is like learning about business in an alien culture. I can't imagine a healthy, successful organization of any kind making such an inane and chilling statement: > The spokesman said there would be no interview and sent this statement: “This is a personnel matter that would be inappropriate to address through the media, though the allegations are baseless and without merit. IPRA is committed to conducting fair, unbiased, objective, thorough and timely investigations of allegations of police misconduct and officer-involved shootings.” > The performance evaluation covered 19 months and concluded that Davis “displays a complete lack of objectivity combined with a clear bias against the police in spite of his own lengthy police career.”
- bitwize 11y ago> Reading about the internal administrative process in large municipal governments is like learning about business in an alien culture. Vogons?
- Zikes 11y agoI think it's time we recognized that we are essentially second class citizens, after police. They are consistently able to commit crimes without being prosecuted. They can use their position and influence to target and harass their personal enemies. When they are prosecuted for a crime, the sentencing is consistently far less than a non-LEO offender's. And there's no more recourse for us. When a police officer shows up, there's nothing you can do, and no way to predict what will happen. If they're in the mood, you can be beaten, pepper sprayed, tazed, bitten, or shot, for any offense no matter how minor or imagined.
- theseatoms 11y agoAgreed. Though I'm tempted to say that this problem isn't getting worse and that our awareness is only becoming more acute, the existence of digital information increases the potential for abuses of power. (No specific cases come to mind at the moment, but I'd wager that it happens more than occasionally.) So what can we do about it? Record the police. EDIT: Typo..
- Zikes 11y agoRecording is a step, however that only addresses a small part of the issue: proof of wrongdoing. Even in clear-cut cases with recordings, such as the Eric Garner incident, it does not seem to lead to real justice. Every other day I'm reading an article about cases where there are no doubts as to the events, but no charges are ever brought. I think the first thing that needs to be addressed is the lack of independent, third-party mediators, capable of policing the police and enforcing fair and balanced punishments. Second, we need to address the corruption, collusions, and abuses of power that come from being involved in the justice system. If you are a member of the court or a law enforcement officer and were, e.g. pulled over for a moving violation, there is a very good chance that revealing your profession will result in your release with no record or punishment. I have sat in a court while my father was being tried for a felony. Since my family are essentially nobodies, there was no one else in the court prior to proceedings beginning except us and the court staff. We listened as the prosecutor spoke in a familiar tone with the various staff in court, including the judge, about a recent vacation he had taken out of state. He mentioned that he was pulled over for speeding, but once he told the officer who he was he was let go, and he was very proud of it. About an hour later, he was calling my father a "monster with no regard for the law".
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoEven though liberals will deny this, the main issue here is that police unions are completely out of control and have this kind of power. The Independent Police Review Authority is full of union stooges, ex-cops, etc and is designed to protect cops. The real question is when will we start having the political will to question public sector unions? They seem to only make city services more expensive, more corrupt, and in the case of cops, lead to legalized murder. Decent piece on how this board and the union work to protect bad cops. You just can't expect the police to police themselves. http://www.wbez.org/news/who-polices-police-chicago-its-increasingly-ex-cops-111194 http://www.wbez.org/news/who-polices-police-chicago-its-incr... Now a WBEZ investigation raises questions about just how independent the agency is. City records obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request show that IPRA’s management now includes six former cops — officials who have spent most of their career in sworn law enforcement. Those include the agency’s top three leaders.
- mingus68040 11y ago>"Even though liberals will deny this..." This blanket assumption is probably why you're being down-voted. The easiest way to avoid this is by supporting your statements with as many facts as possible. A simple google search proved that this is not at all the case, for example, and that Republicans show much stronger support of police unions. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/12/12/the-gop-and-police-unions-a-love-story.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/12/12/the-gop-and... This selective support among Republicans suggests that you're addressing the wrong crowd.
- happyscrappy 11y agoIt will be very hard to pin the problems with Chicago on Republicans.
- digitalneal 11y agoAre you saying Governors have no power over the cities that reside in their state? From 1977 to 2003 Republicans were in control of Illinois executive office. 26 years in a row. From 1972 to 1991, Jon Burge running the show as Chicago police commander. Are you trying to say that Republican governors had no power to investigate/curtail the evil that was brewing under his leadership? hehe.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- justwannasing 11y agoGonna give you guys a few quick blurbs. First, a chief of police was interviewed on CBS News a while back. He said there are thousands upon thousands of police interactions with citizens every day but all anyone ever hears about is the one bad one that happened one time. Second, and this might sound off-topic but I hope you get my point. I was helping a guy move, a few months back, along with one of his friends who's a rookie cop. This took place over several days. Each day, we rode in a truck a coule of miles and, along the way, he would occasionally say, "Expired plates. Expired plates." cause we couldn't go a mile without him finding one. And not just by a month or so but, in one case it was almost a year. Which brought up racial profiling, as you could imagine. He said, "There is no race indicator on a radar gun." And "When I see something go wrong and I light it up, I can't tell who I'm pulling over, much less what race they are, until I get out of the car. And I don't care. You could look at my ticketing and arrests for the few months I've been on the job and say I do racial profiling cause most of them are [insert what you know it is] cause, from what I can tell, most of them do the things that get them tickets or arrested and put in jail." I think of that every time I see an article, here on HN, and the comments by people trying to blame the cops for everything as if they're against us. EDIT: As I pointed out, right away, the first two commenters entirely missed my point.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rosser 11y agoWe tend not to hear about the thousands of airline flights a day that don't crash, either. That doesn't mean for a second that we should just shrug and resign ourselves plane crashes. And even that analogy is flawed, because it's unambiguous that at least some of these "bad cop" interactions involve deliberate malfeasance on the part of the cop. When was the last time the pilot intentionally crashed their plane? It turns out, some cops are bad actors. They're the ones we should be hearing about. And we should also be hearing about it when their departments pull shit like TFA: firing the investigator who says their shoots were bad, for not altering his findings to suit their narrative.
- 11y ago
- imglorp 11y agoAnd this is why a democracy needs independent checks and balances at every level.
- vaadu 11y agoThis is why all officer involved shootings should be investigated and prosecuted(if necessary) by people with no skin in the game for any outcome.
- rquantz 11y agoSpecifically, investigation of police should the purview of the Federal Justice Department.
- late2part 11y agoI disagree. We need more state rights and autonomy, we don't need the Feds to come in and babysit a state. What Chicago needs to do is get managed by IL. And IL needs to realize that the corrupt people are getting voted in by IL citizens.
- rquantz 11y agoAnd yet the federal government is the only entity so far that seems to have any effect on police brutality. States have a history of ignoring or actively disparaging civil rights. Occasionally federalism is a harmless relic, but a lot of times the people crying about the federal government babysitting them are the ones who are trying to act unconstitutionally.
- shostack 11y agoI think I speak for all Chicagoans when I say "what were you expecting?" This is in a state where of our last seven governors, FOUR ended up in prison. That's a whopping 57%. There's a joke that our politicians have an "orange parachute" when they leave their jobs. When you add in all the other police issues over the years, you end up with not a single Chicagoan surprised at this outcome. The state and the city are corrupt beyond belief. Despite the cost to the tax payer, I'd love to see this guy sue the crap out of everyone involved. Of course, that's a risky move because you know, something could happen to him.
- digitalneal 11y agoLotta people here talking like they understand Chicago politics. The people who investigate these incidents were appointed to investigate them because City and State agree'd that CPD was unwilling to investigate the misdeeds of their department. So they setup an Independent review board. Which sounds nice and independent but...(Mayor and CPD friends filled it with former CPD brass or family of former CPD or former consultants to CPD) Now they are firing investigators because they don't give reports that appease the department. This is just another feather in the hat of police corruption rolling thru Chicago.
- backtoyoujim 11y agoto wit from the article: The performance evaluation covered 19 months and concluded that Davis “displays a complete lack of objectivity combined with a clear bias against the police in spite of his own lengthy police career.” That is a serpent choking down its own tail.
- sp332 11y agoMy favorite part: Through most of his IPRA tenure, Davis’s performance evaluations showered him with praise. They called him an “effective leader” and “excellent team player.” The final evaluation, issued June 26, said he “is clearly not a team player.”