3 ms·
Except they haven't. At all. They may have said some stupid things, but that's a different thing entirely. There was no event of "destroying data in response to
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
Except they haven't. At all. They may have said some stupid things, but that's a different thing entirely. There was no event of "destroying data in response to an FOI request," - or if there was, there's no direct evidence of it in the leaked emails. And yes, I have read them.
You chose your words very carefully.
Emails (regarding AR4) were deleted. Phil Jones did say "I think I’ll delete the file rather than send to anyone". But yes, it's true no one admitted to deleting the files that later turned up missing.
It's not enough evidence to convict them in court, but it is enough evidence for the rest of us not to trust them.
No, the burden of proof is on those who want to show that the null hypothesis, that human-produced CO2 has the potential to cause direct harm through accelerated warming, is incorrect. The reason this is the null hypothesis isn't because the scientists say so, it's because it's the best physical model we have.
Your comment reflects a complete lack of knowledge of how the scientific process works.
a) Science can't tell you what the correct null hypothesis is. That's a completely subjective matter.
b) When engaging in hypothesis testing, the standard procedure is to take the opposite of what you want to prove as your null hypothesis. Trying to prove cigarettes cause cancer? Then you take "cigarettes don't cause cancer" as your null hypothesis.
If you are taking AGW as the null hypothesis, you are assuming that which you need to prove.