4 ms·
This is actually an interesting hypothesis - has computing advanced enough to make central planning possible. I am not sure how you would test it though.
by danieltillett 11y ago
This is actually an interesting hypothesis - has computing advanced enough to make central planning possible. I am not sure how you would test it though.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoThe biggest problems with central planning were never quite as much about the lack of computing power, but more about the incentives that go with that power structure. Politically, the central planner gets to reward all his friends and punish his enemies and deprive them of resources and opportunities. Even aside from the obvious implications on political liberty, getting the opportunity to do business in that environment is a matter of political connection, not merit, leading to stagnation. I suppose, though, that you could at least use sufficiently advanced algorithms to monitor supply levels and inventories and sales to adjust prices so you can bring back some measure of the price-signaling mechanism that central planning has traditionally lacked... if the guy in charge isn't tempted to fiddle with prices for political reasons. Looking at some extant central-planning huggers like Tom Steyer (who wants to investigate/punish/tax oil firms because California regulations make gas more expensive than elsewhere in the nation) you can color me skeptical of the premise.
- sillygeese 11y agoThen there's the fact that no one can know what any given person wants to buy at a given time, and therefore central planning is doomed to failure because you can't centrally plan "the right" prices for everything, and then you'll end up vastly misallocating resources, and there will be widespread destitution ala Soviet Union. In conclusion, central planning ultimately just completely fucks up any economy. Check out Venezuela for a recent example. So if 100% central planning results in a total catastrophe, then there should be no central planning at all, because any extent of central planning is harmful compared to less (or ultimately none at all).
- panic 11y agoSo if 100% central planning results in a total catastrophe, then there should be no central planning at all, because any extent of central planning is harmful compared to less (or ultimately none at all). I don't think your argument works. If I drink a swimming pool full of water, I will die. Does that mean I should drink no water at all?
- sillygeese 11y agoMaybe it was poorly phrased. Here's another attempt. Any degree of central planning is harmful to us because: 1) it always represents an opportunity cost compared to people making choices themselves, and 2) the choices made by central planners are not made to benefit the masses (because otherwise they'd just let people make the choices themselves) What would be the point of being in a position to make decisions for other people, if you were just going to do your best to benefit others, instead of yourself?
- danieltillett 11y agoThis problem applies to a non-central planned economy too. Someone somewhere has to make a decision of what people want to buy and make it in advance of the item being purchased (hence inventory). This is why most business use central planning. If they get the planning wrong they lose money and potentially go out of business. The question is can this be scaled up now economy wide now that we have much more advanced computational tools to predict and react swiftly to demand changes. I don’t know :)
- sillygeese 11y agoHowever you might want to define "central planning", there's a massive difference. The business people are using their own money, but central planners use everyone else's.
- danieltillett 11y agoActually most large businesses are using someone else's money - the shareholders. The same sort of agency problems that exist in centrally planned economies also exist in large public companies.
- rwmj 11y agoThe reason central planning fails (in societies or in companies) is because the people doing the work at the "bottom" have a lot more knowledge about how things really work than the people making the decisions at the top. A lot of that knowledge isn't even easy to capture - it's tied up in skills, techniques, oral history and obscure trade secrets. In other words: the problem isn't likely to be speed/power of the planning computers, but how you get the information that needs to be fed into them. I think this could also explain why managers who worked their way up from the bottom tend to do well, whereas professional executives who are helicoptered in to companies fail.
- navait 11y ago> I think this could also explain why managers who worked their way up from the bottom tend to do well, whereas professional executives who are helicoptered in to companies fail. While intuitive, I have doubts about the truth of this statement. Citation needed.
- aetherson 11y agoI don't think it's principally processor bound. I think that the "intelligence" of a market is more in aggregating information than in running a complex algorithm. We probably have the computation resources to replace a market economy, but we have no way that I can see to get all the information needed into the computer.