4 ms·
Now You Can Buy Solar Power from Your Neighbor
- nathan_long 11y agoDo they actually transfer power between "host" and "partner", or just money?
- athenot 11y agoThis looks more like a transfer of credits, not of the actual power.
- danielweber 11y agoIn a grid, electricity is largely fungible. By transferring money to people doing the "right things" you encourage more of those "right things."
- edent 11y agoThis is just... odd! In the UK, the Government pay me (via my energy company) for every kWh I generate. I also get paid for every unit I export. Once a quarter (or automatically if I have a smart-meter) I take meter readings and email them to the Energy Company. A few days later they transfer the cash to my account. Why bother with this middleman? What's the use of an inefficient 3rd party? Energy is fungible. Unless you've actually got a direct wire between your panels and your neighbour's property, this is just nonsense.
- wjnc 11y agoInternational perspective from a different country: In the Netherlands there is quite a large tax on kWh. When producing for your own consumption you don't have to pay that tax. As soon as you are 'distributing' (or, sharing in this context) you have to pay the energy tax. This led to the situation that where a block of houses installed a common system, they all had to pay taxes, more or less destroying any chance of a decent return on investment. I own a windmill in a shared context, but the return is about 1%, so more of a 'green' than financial argument. (The legal decision stems from this month, so after the link in story above.)
- jonwachob91 11y agoNot every region of the world is as green energy progressive as the UK. In the US, states make their own regulations on energy - and it is reflected in the state of Florida. FL only has 5 utility companies, but Duke (the largest utility in the country) and FPL (the 3rd largest in the county) control most of the state (the other 3 utility companies purchase power from Duke and FPL, essentially making them the only 2 providers in the state). FPL's parent company NextEra is the largest supplier of Solar Energy in North America. Duke is a top 5 provider of solar energy in North America. Yet it is illegal for me to power my home on solar panels that I buy. If I do buy the panels, I still have to pay my utility for every kWh I use even if I didn't get it from the utility (negating any financial benefits). Two of the top providers of solar energy on the continent control the utilities in FL and their lobbying is what keeps us from getting any solar benefits. OUR NICKNAME IS THE SUNSHINE STATE!!! Hopefully, companies such as Yeloha can show our legislators and their constituents the power of home owner solar and it's sharing capacity. They could provide a lot of data to empower change.
- jonwachob91 11y agoAn article came out a few days ago about the fight for rooftop solar in FL - http://grist.org/news/enviros-tea-partiers-and-the-christian-coalition-all-agree-florida-needs-more-rooftop-solar http://grist.org/news/enviros-tea-partiers-and-the-christian... It'll give you some insight into the legal landscape for rooftop solar in FL (and a few other states).
- outworlder 11y agoWhat if you have no contracts with any utility companies whatsoever? Are you still required to pick one and pay them?
- jonwachob91 11y agoWe don't get to pick, we have one that services our house and we are required to use them. If we don't connect the panels to the grid - they send out inspectors to homes that are drawing below the norm power and look for panels. If they find panels or any renewable energy source they call the cops and start a lawsuit.
- grecy 11y agoBecause the power companies in the US are enormous, entrenched multibillion dollar enterprises, and doing as you suggest would be bad for profits. I honestly believe in the next 10-20 years one of the biggest challenges we have to overcome is dealing with these companies and the many layers of government protection they have. Off the top of my head I'm thinking about power, oil, heathcare, automotive, maybe transport.
- antaviana 11y agoIn Spain the Goverment is issuing a law where you have to pay about a 60% of the power you generate for your own compsumption if you are connected to the grid. Clearly, our Governtment truly believes that we do not need renewable energy.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoHasn't this been covered through the Utilities, already? Most utilities here allow you to buy different plans, normal electricity, or electricity generated from renewable sources. At the end of the day it's just a 'accounting trick', as it's not like the green energy is being routed specifically to you, you get the same energy, most of it from a coal burning plant, but your payments are earmarked (in the accounting) to pay for existing or new green energy projects, and you hope they're audited such that this is actually true (as opposed to selling 15% of their electricity as 'green' when their green sources are only 5% and growing slowly). And this isn't even any different from having your own solar, unless you're in a remote location unconnected to the grid and uninterested in interconnecting to the grid. Most people who have solar simply get two energy meters. One of your power being generated and going to the grid (not to your own home), and one of power from the grid going into your home. It's pretty rare that you actually use the energy that the panels on your roof generate. Which means that whether those panels are on your own roof, or on the other side of the planet, doesn't really make any difference as long as they cost the same and have the same sun conditions. Except of course for the fact your home rises in value with panels on them because panels are essentially a small currency printer that takes sunlight as its ink, which has value. Which brings me to the weirdness of this project. People with roofs get free panels and some free electricity. And people without roofs have to pay for that, which is obviously going to be quite expensive. Residential solar is already 2x, almost 3x as expensive as industrial solar projects, plus solar is still more expensive than your utility in the first place, and then you have to pay for extra panels for someone else's energy bill, plus the panels you do pay for aren't owned by you and don't add value to your home, and of course the energy of the panels doesn't even go directly to you, or hell even directly to the person whose house's panels you're paying for. I don't see why this would be a better idea than buying solar credits, shares in an industrial solar farm or green energy from your utility. It sounds like a waste of money to me, magnifying the very concern that is keeping solar from taking over the energy market. For example that's what vandebron.nl does here in the Netherlands. They essentially sell green energy credits (I call them credits not because it's not green energy, but because it's delivered to the grid in general, and not to them specifically) to consumers by facilitating the financial link between independent producers (e.g. a farmer who has a wind turbine and who can sell to 600 households) and the consumer.
- shiggerino 11y agoThere is nothing new about the technology or the business model. Maybe it's an unusual one for Americans, but for everyone else, it's not.
- chrisBob 11y agoAs a Massachusetts resident with solar panels I can tell you that this is a useful service. In this state you do not get paid for the over production and instead it just accumulates in your account. I currently have a $500 credit with the electric company and no good way to cash out. There is a mechanism in place to give someone else your extra credit but then you need to figure out how to charge them by looking at your bill every month. There is also a requirement that the person you transfer to must be in the same "ISO-NE load zone" and I haven't figure out what that means yet. It probably means that my neighbors are ok, but my co-workers might not be an option. I don't know know how they set their rates, but I would be happy to sell people electricity at 75% of what they pay the power company since I am not doing anything with my extra as it is. To answer the power or money question: This is just a money transfer. It is similar to the way anyone can purchase renewable energy for a 10% premium. They don't send you different electrons, it just gets paid differently.
- ChrisGranger 11y agoYou could run BOINC or mine Bitcoin or something similar with your excess electricity assuming you also have idle computer hardware, at least until there's a better option for you.
- fiveoak 11y agoNot a bad idea, but I thought ASICs basically killed the profitability of mining on standard computer hardware? Still, if the electricity is free then at least it's something.
- theseatoms 11y agoWhy not buy ASICs then?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alricb 11y agoThe ISO New England load zones are: Connecticut, Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Vermont, Northeastern Massachusetts and Boston (NEMA), Southeastern Massachusetts (SEMA) and Western/Central Massachusetts (WCMA).