3 ms·
>I don't know anything about the Thirty Years war, but I doubt that there's any major recent act of stupidity that was caused by excessive cleaving to (or knowl
by danieltillett 11y ago
>I don't know anything about the Thirty Years war, but I doubt that there's any major recent act of stupidity that was caused by excessive cleaving to (or knowledge of) historical experience.
Let me introduce you to Balkans war(s) of the 1990s. People who had been living side-by-side peacefully for decades decided to rehash hundreds of years of historical conflicts which to outsiders looked insane.
>I suspect we'll keep on looking back at the great depression until it ceases to seem salient.
The Great Depression is no longer relevant since we don't live in a world on the gold standard. The factors that drove the economy into the ground in the 1930s (massive deflation and bank failures) are not going to happen again. Deflation because countries can print as much cash as they like (Greece excepted), while in regards bank failures we now know banks (and bankers) are too big to fail.
>Oh, and the Crusades explain quite a bit about the state of the middle east.
Nothing about the middle east today is the result of the Crusades except some misguided people thinking the Crusades are relevant.
- foxhedgehog 11y agoNo, the OP is correct about the Crusades, particularly if you care about the POV of the political actors in the Middle East itself.
- danieltillett 11y agoSome actors in the middle east like to claim that any involvement of the west is another Crusade, but no western country is interested in “freeing the Holy Land” from non-christians.
- nl 11y agoYou are correct of course. Unfortunately some Western leaders have been a little unwise when speaking publicly: "this crusade, this war on terrorism, is going to take awhile." - GW Bush[1]. "President Bush said to all of us: 'I am driven with a mission from God'. God would tell me, 'George go and fight these terrorists in Afghanistan'. And I did. And then God would tell me 'George, go and end the tyranny in Iraq'. And I did."[2] It's pretty easy to paint a picture of attempted cultural (if not religious) domination by the West even without quotes like that. Add that stuff in and it is harder to explain how it isn't the same. [1] http://www.csmonitor.com/2001/0919/p12s2-woeu.html http://www.csmonitor.com/2001/0919/p12s2-woeu.html [2] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/oct/07/iraq.usa http://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/oct/07/iraq.usa
- danieltillett 11y agoYes there has been some lose language been used in this area by people how should have known better. The problem is the word “crusade” has a meaning in English different to its original historical origins.
- jganetsk 11y agoThe word "crusade" has the same meaning it always had. It has a positive connotation, just as it always had. And the same goes for the word "jihad" in the Islamic world.
- cubancigar11 11y agoI am of the thought that it is very much a crusade, because there is no reason to believe the actual crusades were anything beyond riling up the peasants for the benefit of the rich.
- danieltillett 11y agoThis is an interesting hypothesis, but I think we should consider that the nobles actually believed in the religious aspects of the Crusades. While I am sure some were in it for the money or prestige at least the first couple of crusades appeared to have been motivated by religious zeal.
- dsr_ 11y agoDon't mistake excuses for motivations. The law of primogeniture (inheritance to eldest son) along with large family size played a big role in the causes of the crusades. Let's suppose you've managed, as a family, to hack and slash your way to the top of the nobility. Grandfather was a friend of the guy who became king, father inherited lands and got them productive, and now five brothers have all survived. The eldest gets the land. The next four have learned to ride horses, swing swords, and wear armor. One of them decides that the Church isn't so bad, and thus effectively goes into politics. There are still 3 armed badasses who won't be getting the power and wealth they are used to... unless they go and take it from someone else. Their brothers in the Church have an idea: maybe you can go be violent somewhere else?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Tloewald 11y agoThere's a difference between knowing history and bearing grudges. Generally folks who bear grudges have a very poor (and one-sided) view of history. The Great Depression was not solely caused by the gold standard, although getting rid of it certainly seems to have aided recovery (worth noting since some argue for returning to it). Iraq wasn't going to be like Vietnam either because the people loved us, and our weapons were so much awesomer. Incidentally, Bremer was reading about the occupation of Germany and Japan after WWII on his way to Baghdad. History can be instructive, but you need to use it wisely, not cherry pick the instances that support your existing view. There's plenty of Roman history (for example) that maps beautifully onto modern America, even though we are very different from the Romans.
- danieltillett 11y agoHistory can be a guide, but an untrustworthy guide. Use history, but always be aware that today is not a repeat of yesterday. In regards the Great Depression the gold standard seems to be mostly responsible. The countries that left the gold standard first were the first to recover and those that delayed suffered longer. The USA is an interesting exception since Roosevelt revalued gold by fiat in 1933 which had the effect of getting the USA effectively off the gold standard and introducing inflation into a deflationary spiral.
- Tloewald 11y agoReplace "history" with any body of knowledge and you get an equally valid truism.