4 ms·
I wish more common laptops would have replaceable firmware, like Lenovo and the like. Having all those blobs with who knows what is very annoying. Especially wh
by shmerl 11y ago
I wish more common laptops would have replaceable firmware, like Lenovo and the like. Having all those blobs with who knows what is very annoying. Especially when that firmware starts behaving as if it owns your computer, and refuses to boot because "WiFi card is not authorized" or some other such idiocy.
- brobinson 11y agoYes! I bought a Lenovo laptop in 2008 and tried to replace the wifi card with an Atheros-based one (better driver support on Linux at the time), and it refused to boot afterwards. Never buying a Lenovo laptop again.
- shmerl 11y agoI got one recently, and it came with 802.11n Intel card. I bought 802.11ac Intel one (it has a pretty good support on Linux). And who knew that some FRU part code wasn't from the "authorized" whitelist and that nasty firmware would refuse to boot with it. I had to return the card, and figure out what the compatible FRU part number is. The card is really exactly the same, just some internal code is different. This is beyond dumb and annoying.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yuhong 11y agoYea, I don't like Intel Boot Guard for that reason, and I think this is more important than being "100% FOSS" or the like. I once suggested allowing it to be disabled using a jumper or the like.
- na85 11y agoPhysical write jumpers would solve 99% of firmware security issues and significantly reduce the attack surface of modern computers. APTs can't really manifest unless they come pre-installed. Then again, NSA and other state actors wouldn't be able to implant malware into those areas without physical access. I wonder why we don't have physical jumpers.
- pgeorgi 11y agoFirmware these days requires more non-volatile memory in early init than is available outside flash. So with a write protect switch, RAM init couldn't store the actual memory configuration (~2kb of data), so wakeup from suspend to RAM doesn't work. In case of UEFI, its variables are also stored in flash, so that also doesn't work. Since everything optimizes for UEFI (as far as firmware matters are concerned), that jumper would be counter-productive.
- madez 11y agoI see here a _big_ security argument for libreboot. With free firmware and free kernel you can arrange suspend to RAM with write protected firmware memory.
- Sanddancer 11y agoA lot of systems use fairly off-the-shelf bioses, that have lots of tools available for them that were intended for OEMs to do the minor, annoying tweaks that you described. There are sites [1] that specialize in discussing and using these sorts of tools. I had a lenovo laptop that behaved a lot like that, and was going to use a modded bios to fix it, but discovered that an updated bios actually had a bug in the halt code, so it would claim to halt, but five seconds later would continue the boot process. [1] https://www.bios-mods.com/downloads/ https://www.bios-mods.com/downloads/
- shmerl 11y agoInteresting, thanks for the pointer. Nothing there on my laptop though, but I guess the firmware can be shared between many models.