4 ms·
Some stuff to remember: - thinness does not matter that much. If you want your stuff to look cool, then it does, but for portability it doesn't. - thinness aff
by sz4kerto 11y ago
Some stuff to remember:
- thinness does not matter that much. If you want your stuff to look cool, then it does, but for portability it doesn't.
- thinness affects cooling. You don't want your battery get ruined, your CPU throttled and your lap burned.
- expandability matters on the long run
I just replaced my 2013 rMBP. I needed the following:
- expandable storage -- I can put 3 SSDs in this
- expandable memory - 4 DIMM slots, up to 64G RAM
- dockable
- trackpoint
- can drive UHD screens @ 60 Hz
- as Linux friendly as possible
- good keyboard
- good cooling
- IPS screen, min. fHD
I ended up buying the HP Zbook 15 G2. The only issue with that is UDH external screens and Linux-friendliness don't go together, because those displays require discrete GPU (Broadwells can drive UHD screens through MST, but most displays don't support that). The other alternative was the Thinkpad W550s, but I could get the G2 at half the price (and it's much more powerful).
I didn't buy:
- smaller devices because I'm working on this 10 hours a day sometimes, and portability itself wasn't enough to compensate for less power, less memory, worse cooling
- Thinkpad .40 series because of their clickpads
- Dell Precisions because they're extremely bulky and HPs have better keyboard
- Macbooks because OSX was not an option for me after using it for 2.5 years, also they don't have a trackpoint and their cooling is really abysmal
- anything from smaller vendors like System76, etc. because they all use OEM chassis and they're a far cry from top-end HP, Dell, Lenovo and Apple chassis
I personally don't understand how could anyone recommend a 11" MBA to someone who wants to do serious work on it. A 11" screen is extremely uncomfortable for all-day coding; if you keep it docked all day then might make sense though.
- Old_Thrashbarg 11y agoI have the Dell Precision M3800 with 15' screen. I haven't found it to be bulky. I got it with Ubuntu preinstalled and it's been my favorite laptop so far.
- sz4kerto 11y agoYep, the M3800 is not the usual precision, it's an XPS15 with Quadro.
- kaolinite 11y agoI'm surprised you say that thinness doesn't matter for portability. I couldn't imagine going back to my previous ThinkPad (currently using a 13" Macbook Air) - it would take up so much space in my bag. Remember that by thinning a laptop, you also make it lighter too.
- dottrap 11y agoI personally think weight matters, but not thinness. I used to use a 12" Powerbook. I now use a 11" Macbook Air. I still use the same bag to carry it around. Being thinner didn't win me anything. However, being lighter is a definite win. Hypothetically, if I could get the same laptop that is thicker, but cheaper, but is the same weight and has full sized ports for things like ethernet (or ports that were removed like SD cards, firewire, etc) instead of requiring dongles and attachments, I would get the thicker one. (A coworker bought a 15" Powerbook the same time I got my 12". We went to a conference and were lugging our laptops all day for a week. The weight difference took its toll on my coworker by the end of the week.)
- pmontra 11y agoI bought a Zbook 15 last year (the G2 is the 2015 model) and I'm pretty happy with it. I replaced Windows with Ubuntu, had some issues with shutdown/suspend and Usb 3 but I eventually fixed them. Nice to know it's got more Linux friendly this year.
- Daneel_ 11y agoTHIS. So much this.