4 ms·
No, the problem here is that elected officials are given access to the pension fund to begin with. If the pension were set up independently and the government s
by chongli 11y ago
No, the problem here is that elected officials are given access to the pension fund to begin with. If the pension were set up independently and the government simply handed over their bargained-for monthly contribution to the independent fund then we wouldn't have the issue of politicians running populist "loot the pension fund" campaigns.
- lotsofpulp 11y agoCorrect, but that is the only way taxpayer funded pensions can be sold. The reason that non government pensions are so expensive and are basically extinct is that there are strict laws setup to guarantee pension funds are adequately funded and the pensioners aren't left to fend for themselves. These laws don't exist for taxpayer funded pensions, so politicians and union leaders can do what they see fit, and the best answer I've gotten for why there are no rules for government funded pensions is that governments have the power to tax. If defined benefit pensions, aka life annuities, were handed off to an entity that didn't have the power to tax, I'd be interested to know at what cost it would have. I suspect most companies wouldn't even offer the kind of guarantees offered by government funded pensions.
- rayiner 11y agoThat's more or less how, e.g., Chicago funds its pensions: http://www.wbez.org/news/experts-say-chicago-has-public-pension-system-set-fail-109329 http://www.wbez.org/news/experts-say-chicago-has-public-pens.... Every year, they put in a fixed multiple of what employees paid in two years' prior. The city skipped a number of payments in the 1990's because the funds were projected be overfunded, but I've never seen an account of these "loot the pension fund" measures you're talking about.
- twic 11y agoLooting has happened, but as far as i know, mostly in the private sector. Robert Maxwell was the last great example, and the rules in the UK were tightened up considerably after him: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/1251019.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/1251019.stm