2 ms·
Defined benefit pensions are a ridiculous idea to begin with. If that is true, then surely fixed annual salaries are also ridiculous, and everyone should be pa
by gaius 11y ago
Defined benefit pensions are a ridiculous idea to begin with.
If that is true, then surely fixed annual salaries are also ridiculous, and everyone should be paid on commission? Regardless of what you might think, in the real world, annual salaries are the norm and no-one bats an eyelid.
The truth of pensions is that they are not a "perk" they are deferred compensation and a part of the package of salary, benefits etc you negotiate when you take a job. Shifting the goalposts is not reasonable when it's one-sided like this.
- lotsofpulp 11y agoAnnual salaries are not legal contracts. You are paid periodically, biweekly, monthly, whatever, and should the business go under, so does your job and salary with it. I don't see how they are comparable at all. Predicting the future with 100% guarantees is impossible, obviously. Fortunately, humans have been able to develop models that are able to assist us in predicting the future with some reliability (the seasons for help with farming, weather forecasting for a few days, etc), but being able to say "over the next 30 years, we expect to earn an 8% average rate of return per year" is in a whole other league. It is true that defined benefit pensions are deferred compensation. Problem is push comes to shove, the world doesn't offer guarantees. How much infrastructure will be neglected? How many cuts to education will it take? We all know the military won't be touched, in any significant way. Defined benefit pensions are a nice dream, if you ignore the possibilities of corruption (it's still people controlling a huge pot of money, in an extremely opaque manner), not meeting expected rates of return, people living longer than expected, and finally....the tax base moving away or saying the hell with it, we'll just change the laws to tax pensions or not pay them.