5 ms·
> SourceForge have taken a few missteps in recent months I'm curious as to why you put this in the past tense. SourceForge never backed down from their actions
by zamalek 11y ago
> SourceForge have taken a few missteps in recent months
I'm curious as to why you put this in the past tense. SourceForge never backed down from their actions and continue to use the wrapper.
> someday GH will also exhaust its natural growth and start more aggressive upselling
Acknowledging that GH can go the same way as SourceForge is a very healthy mindset, however, "will" is a strong word because GH has a monetization plan (is always has) - the lack of which is what ultimately caused SF to go down the path that they did.
What GH will or will not do does not deter from what SF is currently doing. Stop looking in your crystal ball and start looking at what is happening in the present.
> It seemed deeply unlikely at one stage to imagine Google would flush Code down the toilet
If you know Google you know this isn't the case. Google are ruthless with cutting ideas and products - just look at Reader. Google realized that Code wasn't making any money, saw that the platform was stagnating and saw that GH was doing a much better job at something that they had never really thought out. Exactly the same situation as SF. Two drastically different approaches to product death.
- kjak 11y ago>> It seemed deeply unlikely at one stage to imagine Google would flush Code down the toilet > If you know Google you know this isn't the case. Google are ruthless with cutting ideas and products - just look at Reader. Well, yes, it's obvious in hindsight... but Google started Code in 2005 and project hosting in 2006, while Reader was shut down in 2013. Github wasn't even launched until 2008.
- Laforet 11y agoGoogle Answers 2002-2006 Google Wave 2009-2010 Google Reader 2005-2013 The list goes on Google has been like this from very early on. I won't be surprised if I wake up to the news that gmail is getting the axe should google decide that the product is no longer commercially viable.
- ksherlock 11y agoSourceForge's monetization plan from 2001--2007 was SourceForge Enterprise Edition.
- xorcist 11y agoWhich, if you squint a bit, looks conspicuously like Github's current monetization plan.