3 ms·
I'd say that they're the same issue -- whether the state can honor expensive obligations that a lot of people are depending on -- and that distinguishing them i
by SilasX 11y ago
I'd say that they're the same issue -- whether the state can honor expensive obligations that a lot of people are depending on -- and that distinguishing them is pedantry. ("Oh, see, it wouldn't technically be reneging on a debt.")
When someone brings up the figure, the point is, "hey, there is a huge bill coming due, and not paying it would screw over a lot of people". When you dismiss that on the grounds that:
- We can just not pay it
- We can debase its real value
- It wouldn't be a default in the legal sense
then you are not addressing the core point. I don't see how someone can read your post and say, "oh, I guess I don't have to worry about this anymore", and if your post is not arguing to that effect, then I'm not sure what it adds to the discussion. At most, you're just saying, "you shouldn't totally freak out because the figure is just $60 trillion."
Let's assume for a minute that Illinois did have legal recourse -- say, but implementing a special tax on pensions. Would you feel any better? I wouldn't; someone is still getting screwed, the situation is still bad.
- rayiner 11y ago> whether the state can honor expensive obligations that a lot of people are depending on -- and that distinguishing them is pedantry. Distinguishing them isn't pedantic at all. First, there is a big difference between a defined benefit pension and say Medicare (which is the bulk of the unfunded liability). The former is a dollar amount people expect to receive. The latter is a general public service. It's like school funding or transportation. Nobody has an entitlement to receive a particular level of any of those services, even if they rely on them. Second, and perhaps more importantly, not being able to "honor expensive obligations" is not the end of the story. It certainly matters what happens when the ends don't meet. > "oh, I guess I don't have to worry about this anymore" I didn't say we don't have to worry about it anymore, I said it's a different problem. The pension crisis in many cities and states is an existential problem. They can't cut benefits, so they have no choice but to raise taxes and cut services, driving away their tax base. It'll lead to a vicious cycle that'll gut these local economies. At the federal level, cutting retiree benefits will hurt some people, but the government won't be forced into a position of fundamentally compromising its competitiveness vis-a-vis other countries. > Let's assume for a minute that Illinois did have legal recourse -- say, but implementing a special tax on pensions. Would you feel any better? I wouldn't; someone is still getting screwed, the situation is still bad. Yes! I'd rather see pensioners get less than they expected than see tax hikes and service cuts that accelerate the trend of people migrating from places like Illinois to places like Georgia.
- SilasX 11y agoSo you're saying Illinois pension liabilities are more problematic than those at the federal level, meaning that the former should be counted as worse for purposes of tabulating future promised benefits, and therefore the OP's figure understates the extent of the problem? Then why did you present the evidence as contradicting the OP's point when it actually supports it? It seems your post should have read: "That figure understates the severity of the problem because some of the liabilities are promised by states and localities that are far more constrained in their ability to get out of paying." Also, if governments are serious about honoring pensions, they should be accounted for on par with their bonds. If not, they should help future pensioners plan against the risk of non-payment. Framing it as "like tentative road construction" is trying to have it both ways: expect people to work as if the pension is guaranteed by the credit of the state, but really keeping it separate therefrom.
- rayiner 11y agoI think we parsed OP's original point differently. He said: "Its the same for the USA as it has 126 Trillion in unfunded liabilities. In the next 30 years, the US will face the same problems as cities are today." The term "US" here means "United States i.e. the federal government" not "United States as a whole country," since in the second sentence it is comparing the federal government's problems to those of cities. And the reason I think OP overstates the severity of the problem is because state finances aren't your problem if you don't live in that state, while federal finances are everyone's problem. Essentially, what OP is saying is: "even if you don't live in Illinois or California, you'll be facing the same problems in 30 years because the federal government has problems that are just as bad." But the federal government's problems are a lot less bad. Which is good, because you can move out of Illinois or California much easier than moving out of the U.S. > Also, if governments are serious about honoring pensions, they should be accounted for on par with their bonds The crucial distinction is that re-negging on bonds affects your finances going forward (increases borrowing costs), while re-negging on pensions does not. > Framing it as "like tentative road construction" is trying to have it both ways I think you misread my post here. I didn't say pensions are like just another public service, I said Medicare is, unlike pensions. Nobody bargained for a particular number of Medicare dollars in 30 years in return for doing a particular job. That's why the Federal government is in better shape--most of its obligations are things that aren't considered (legally and politically) guarantees in the same way as pensions.