4 ms·
I recommend that everyone donate a few dollars via PayPal to Peter's legal defense fund: donate@rifters.com
by grandalf 17y ago
I recommend that everyone donate a few dollars via PayPal to Peter's legal defense fund:
donate@rifters.com
- mattmaroon 17y agoI'd like to donate to the border guards. I figure there's a 50/50 chance there's a lot more to this story than Cory Doctorow's (his friend) has told, but nobody else will blindly take their side.
- noarchy 17y agoHaven't had to cross the border much, aye?
- mattmaroon 17y agoI've crossed the Canadian border maybe 50 times with never a problem (and often a couple boxes of Cuban cigars in my wheel well).
- grandalf 17y agoSo have I incidentally, but that didn't stop the Canadian guards from mistreating me on one unfortunate occasion. There are a variety of issues here, but I think the core issue is that people should be very concerned when law-abiding, harmless citizens are exposed to unnecessary coercion based on the whims of border clerks.
- mattmaroon 17y agoI'm curious, what happened? I was once caught with Cubans. They broke them and sent me on my way.
- grandalf 17y agoI was in college (U of M) and going to windsor with a friend the night before spring break to visit the casino (a bit of a novelty at the time and more fun than Ann Arbor when most of the campus was vacant). He had loaded his car (he had his video game system and guitar in the back, ready to drive home to Ohio the next day)... Just as we were pulling up to the checkpoint, I got a call from someone I hadn't heard from in a long time. In about 5-10 seconds I said, "Great to hear from you let me call you back in a few minutes". That overlapped by about 3 seconds with the guard's question "What's your citizenship". I said "US Citizen". The guard said, "Why are you on teh phone when I'm talking to you?" I said, "I'm sorry about being on the phone, I just got a call from someone I hadn't heard from in a long time and wanted to answer and say I'd call back". The guard reached over and stuck something under the wiper and directed us to drive into the search bay. Then, two surly men in uniform walked up and started hyper-aggressively asking questions. I explained that I thought I'd offended the previous guard b/c I'd been on the phone, and that we were just going for a routine visit to the casino. The guards then ordered us to get out of the car and began searching the car. They found my friend's video game system and guitar and acted as if this was highly suspicious. We explained that it was the night before spring break and that he had those things ready to bring home with him the next day and that they would be coming back to the US with us later. The guards proceeded to ask a lot more questions with voices raised, etc. Then they informed us that were were going to have to go back to the US. I said, "That's bullshit" in a firm voice. One of the guards came quickly toward me, so I jumped back into the car and locked the door. He roiled for a few seconds and then said, "I'm not going to hit you". I then waited for a moment until he backed away and got back out of the car and said, "Ok, you are making a mistake, we are harmless" etc. We then returned to the US and looped back around to re-attempt crossing, but the license plate had been flagged and we were ordered to leave again without being searched. The next day I called the Canadian border control office and explained to the supervisor what had happened. He said something along the lines of "How do I know you're telling the truth?" and hung up. He obviously didn't care. The next time I went to Canada I asked a few people who worked in tourism related shops just inside the Canadian border if my experience was typical. They told me that the job of border guard appeals to the sort of people who enjoy getting into fights, etc. and that they take the job to "blow off steam". If the supervisor had expressed the slightest concern, etc., I'd attribute it to a random bit of bad luck or misunderstanding, but I think the reality is that excesses/abuses happen all the time. I was ultimately only verbally abused, harassed, and turned away... fortunately the guard who came at me was prevented from acting on his impulse to get physical by my retreat into the car.
- tsally 17y agoYou already do donate to the border guard; it's your tax money paying his/her salary. More importantly, I don't think blindly taking the government's side on any issue is a good thing. I'd much rather have everyone default to believing the private citizen and be wrong some of the time. Blind faith in the citizenry probably at worst has a net zero effect. Blind faith in the government is most certainly negative. That being said, I'm completely open to the possibility that the border guards followed procedure. I definitely need more information to form an opinion.
- CamperBob 17y agoI'd rather people defaulted to not "believing" anything or anyone without specific reasons to, myself, but then I'm weird that way.
- mattmaroon 17y agoThat was actually my point.
- cgranade 17y agoIf following procedure means beating someone senseless and trying to get them to waive their legal rights, then procedure is fucked. Yes, I am taking Watts' story at face value, and I could be wrong in that, but given my experiences, it seems much more likely that border crossing guards acted out of line than the alternative.
- grandalf 17y agoI have had incidents with the Canadian guards at the Windsor border... Not as extreme as Watts' case, but I did nothing more than take a call on my cell phone for 5 seconds (to tell the person I'd call back later), and then say "This is bullshit" when the car was turned away from Canada b/c of the phone usage. This was before 9/11 and I am an utterly harmless, good natured person who is about the most obviously non-criminal one could possibly imagine. It is absurd any border guard anywhere would feel the need to ramp up the testosterone in response to me.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- baguasquirrel 17y agoI know someone who often has to get tour groups through customs. He could tell you all about what great fun it is.
- cgranade 17y agoIt's not just Cory Doctrow vouching for him, but also Charlie Stross and Neil Gaiman. Is it possible that there is more to the story that exonerates the guards? Of course it's possible, but given the US border crossing guards, it's not bloody likely. Even if he did something tremendously ill-advised, which doesn't sound like the case here, that does not justify a brutal beating and an assault charge, nor does it justify attempting to get Watts to waive his Miranda rights. Hell, we can even take the extreme case that Watts did somehow commit a felony (no evidence of this); the guards still should have respected his rights and his human dignity.
- pyre 17y ago> It's not just Cory Doctrow vouching for him, but also Charlie Stross and Neil Gaiman. No offense, but "I know the guy and he's a stand-up guy," doesn't mean that he's incapable of lying.
- dhume 17y agoIt doesn't have to be. It just has to mean it's more likely that he was telling the truth than that the border guards were, and the border patrol doesn't exactly have an upstanding reputation.