3 ms·
"He just conjectures that there would be no efficient algorithm for encoding (e.g.) chess positions as states of a waterfall. This actually seems fairly unlikel
by jerf 11y ago
"He just conjectures that there would be no efficient algorithm for encoding (e.g.) chess positions as states of a waterfall. This actually seems fairly unlikely."
I think you're answering a different question than Scott. You seem to be answering "Can I construct a water-based computer that looks like a waterfall that could solve a chess problem, set up the initial parameters, and read the answer off the bottom?" This is conceivable. It is likely it would involve a highly implausible object of highly implausible accuracy and reliability, but if such an object existed it would still be a polynomial calculation to produce it. (Or, at least, a polynomial calculation could produce an object, if not the optimal one. The lack of solution to the Navier-Stokes equations might prevent you from finding an optimal one. And you might find yourself having some trouble with quantum effects. But such are the problems in the real world.) And our polynomial approximation is still not going to look like a waterfall as it will inevitably need looping constructs where state flows "back" uphill... if you want it to be one-way like a waterfall that is going to be exponentially large.
Scott's question is a different one. Given a real world waterfall that you have not constructed, but simply come across, can it be said to be computing the solution to a chess problem? Is a random rock that is sitting on the ground, jiggling away with atoms in constant motion that all the computers in the world could not possibly provide enough computational power to fully simulate, able to be said to be computing something with all that power? Could a boulder be sitting there simulating a human mind? I don't mean in the pan-psychic sense, I mean, literally, is it simulating a human mind? It has the computational capacity, when considered in the raw.
This is where Scott's argument kicks in, where the mapping is doing all the work.
Further evidence of this is that even if you want to sit here and argue that this boulder that is sitting in front of us (metaphorically) really and truly is calculating the state of your mind as well, well, with another equally sensible (and exponential and impossible) mapping, it's also calculating mine, it's also calculating Attila the Hun's, and it's also calculating the brain states of the final human being to ever live, and also deer's brains and the solutions to world hunger and pretty every other interesting thing ever, really. The contortions required to create the mapping of boulder state to human brain state are such that you can fit literally almost anything into it, and therefore, it is reasonable to point out that it is meaningless. It's an interesting argument that provides a surprisingly rigorous line that allows us to say that, no, that waterfall is not solving a chess problem or anything else... it really is, well, a waterfall.
- foldr 11y ago> Given a real world waterfall that you have not constructed, but simply come across, can it be said to be computing the solution to a chess problem? Yes, that's the question I was addressing. I'm really can't figure out why you thought otherwise. There's nothing in my original comment about constructing artificial water-based computers. >This is where Scott's argument kicks in, where the mapping is doing all the work. It is his conjecture that there is no computationally simple mapping, but I see no reason to believe that this conjecture is correct. He certainly doesn't give any reason to think so in the paper. And to echo jameshart's point, he gives no reason to think that the mapping from chess positions to brain states would be any simpler than the mapping from chess positions to waterfalls. If you find his conjecture plausible for some reason, that's fine, but you're quite wrong if you think that the paper presents any rigorous mathematical argument. The discussion is much less rigorous and sophisticated than the existing philosophical literature on the topic. (After all, Putnam's original paper contained a proof.) >Further evidence of this is that even if you want to sit here and argue that this boulder that is sitting in front of us (metaphorically) really and truly is calculating the state of your mind as well, well, with another equally sensible (and exponential and impossible) mapping, it's also calculating mine, it's also calculating Attila the Hun's, and it's also calculating the brain states of the final human being to ever live, and also deer's brains and the solutions to world hunger and pretty every other interesting thing ever, really. Yes, that's the problem. That's why the computational theory of mind seems to be a bit of a non-starter. Since pretty much every physical system computes pretty much every function, it's difficult to see how thought can arise merely as a consequence of the brain computing a particular function.