5 ms·
> You have a moment where you envision the future of virtualized storage and think about how great it will be when storage is nearly free and outsourceable and
by smacktoward 11y ago
> You have a moment where you envision the future of virtualized storage and think about how great it will be when storage is nearly free and outsourceable and you can stop buying disks from Amazon every few months
The future is now! Instead of you sending money to Amazon and them sending you disks, they keep the disks and you send them the money anyway.
Progress! :-D
- windsurfer 11y agoIf the disks only last so long, is it really so terrible that Amazon gets to keep the broken outdated junk?
- Sanddancer 11y agoYes. One can build a system that holds a petabyte of data, fits in less than one rack, has multiple redundancy, for about a hundred grand these days. Multiplied by three locations, that'll get you to $300000. Add in another $35000 for three years of hosting at three different datacenters, and you get to $335000. Sounds like a lot, right? Amazon's even more expensive. Storing one petabyte on Amazon, at the slowest, cheapest, glacier level, will cost you $10000/month, so at about 10 months, you've paid a hundred grand. At thirty six months, you've paid three hundred sixty grand. Plus, you have no hardware to show for it, while amazon sells that broken outdated junk to a reseller to regain some of their investment. Had you hosted it yourself, you could have sold all that equipment off to refurbishers and resellers and regained at least a portion of your investment back. So yeah, it is pretty terrible to choose Amazon.
- khuey 11y agoCommodity cloud services (and pricing) are meant for the 99%, not the outliers. If you have a petabyte of data to store you should either be doing enough other business with Amazon that you can negotiate rates down or you should be rolling your own.
- sneak 11y agoIt costs about a hundred and fifty grand annually (fully loaded, base salary 80-90k) to have the lowest end person who could conceivably keep one of these things running well for three years. n+1 means you need two of them in case one gets the flu. Tell me again about how Amazon's a ripoff, please.
- Sanddancer 11y agoYou're still going to need n+1 sysadmins to maintain the rest of your infrastructure. Maintaining a storage system like this really isn't much different for the day-to-day operations. So, yes, it's one more system, but you're already going to need those admins anyways.
- sneak 11y agoYou're also going to need connectivity, of course. We were doing an apples to apples comparison in a vacuum, I thought.
- Sanddancer 11y agoThat's covered in the cost estimates. A petabyte takes up about a half rack these days, and renting a half rack from a colo is about $350/mo.
- ObviousScience 11y agoI don't believe maintaining a high availability system with proper checking is less than 3 hours a day of work, or ~10% of someone's time on duty if we're talking around the clock. So we're talking about $75,000-90,000 a year in salary to maintaining the cluster if you want 24x365 coverage (which Amazon provides), as you'll need 2 people per shift, 3 shifts per day at a minimum to have people in house, even if they're only spending 10% of their time actually working on that particular issue. In reality, these are unrealistically small numbers. Each employee will have a cost to the corporation of $125,000-150,000 a year. Employees of that caliber spending 10% of their time on supervising a cluster for a year is $75,000-90,000. I'm amortizing the amount of work over your 3 datacenters by imagining you already have the staff and only counting out the number of hours needed for just this work. So the reality is that you left off something like $225,000-270,000 in actual cost of running your own cluster from your analysis, because while it's not "much different", it is a few hours a week from at least 6 employees if you're really talking about running managed, highly reliable storage.
- ThePhysicist 11y agoSadly, depending on what you want to accomplish with your storage the future is still not here. For example, if you want to share a virtual disk with multiple servers through NFS you will still need to manually create a NFS high-availability cluster using e.g. DRBD on most cloud providers (e.g. EC2 or Azure). To be fair, MS Azure offers fully managed SMB shares as a service, but the transfer speed is quite low (60 MB/s in the best case) so they are not very useful for most tasks.
- mrud 11y agoAWS has EFS [1] which should allow you to share one FS to multiple serves. It is still in preview but could help address these needs. [1] http://aws.amazon.com/efs/pricing/ http://aws.amazon.com/efs/pricing/
- ThePhysicist 11y agoThat looks interesting, thanks for the link!
- idunno246 11y agoEc2 has efs at least, no idea if it's any good
- nkozyra 11y agoI'm sure it's fine, at least as well as a manually-configured NFS, but it's only US-West (Oregon) now.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- objectivefs 11y agoFor sharing a filesystem between servers without managing your own high-availability cluster, you could try our ObjectiveFS [1]. [1] https://objectivefs.com https://objectivefs.com
- nadams 11y ago> you can stop buying disks from Amazon every few months This is something that has been puzzling me. Many years ago I purchased 4x 2TB 5900 RPM drives for a 4 bay ReadyNAS (cost about ~$300 for drives plus ReadyNAS). They have been spinning nonstop for ~4 years [1] and haven't had to replace a single one. Not even an increase in errors to signal that the drive is going. Yet - I've worked on a SAN that cost hundreds of thousands of dollars and would have to replace a disk about every month. Granted the disks in SANs probably spin faster (thus faster data access/lower MTBF) - but that high failure rate seems rather suspicious to me. [1] http://i.imgur.com/NRQCedj.png http://i.imgur.com/NRQCedj.png
- ChuckMcM 11y agoAFR buddy, AFR. AFR is the annual failure rate, its typically 2 - 5% of the population per year. 4 drives you don't have a large enough set to see this in action, just every day you're in danger of losing a drive by a small statistical amount. In the Blekko cluster we have just under 10,000 drives. We have a two 20 drive 'boxes' (40 drives) from Western Digital, as drives fail we pull replacements from the 'new/refurbished' box, and we put the dead one in the outgoing box. When we get up to 20 we RMA them in bulk, 20 go out, 20 more come in. That becomes the new 'new/refurbished' box. It really isn't SAN vs non-SAN it is all statistics. That said, if you're running your ReadyNAS with raid 10 (mirrored drives in a RAID 0 config) you may find some unpleasantness when a drive does fail. Statistically you have a 1/10 chance of not being able to re-silver the mirror for a 5900 RPM desktop SATA drive. That gets a bit painful.
- codezero 11y agoJust out of curiosity, has anyone done any research into determining whether a drive which fails after X days/years has some properties in the first Y days that could be a signal for future failure?
- Smerity 11y agoI'm certain there are more recent statistics but Google's "Failure Trends in a Large Disk Drive Population"[1] (2007) is a good start: "In addition to presenting failure statistics, we analyze the correlation between failures and several parameters generally believed to impact longevity." There is also a more recent open source dataset from Backblaze[2] that includes: "Every day, the software that runs the Backblaze data center takes a snapshot of the state of every drive in the data center, including the drive’s serial number, model number, and all of its SMART data" which forms the basis of an article correlating SMART data with drive failures at Backblaze[3]. [1]: http://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.com/en//archive/disk_failures.pdf http://static.googleusercontent.com/media/research.google.co... [2]: https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-data-feb2015/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-data-feb2015/ [3]: https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-smart-stats/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-smart-stats/