2 ms·
The odd thing about this entire kerfuffle is that other Gawker network writers argue that the story should have stayed because of journalistic integrity. Natash
by minimaxir 11y ago
The odd thing about this entire kerfuffle is that other Gawker network writers argue that the story should have stayed because of journalistic integrity. Natasha Vargas-Cooper of Jezebel posted "Stories don't need an upside. Not everyone has to feel good about the truth." (https://twitter.com/natashavc/status/621858660319297536 https://twitter.com/natashavc/status/621858660319297536) and Jason Schreier of Kotaku posted an interesting list of considerations (http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=172267922#post172267922 http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=172267922#post1...):
1) If a separate branch of your company did something that disgusted you, would you jump on Twitter to criticize it, or would you take the time to have conversations internally and see what was being done rather than getting angry on social media? Even if you were unhappy after that, do you believe raging publicly would help? Especially when you work for an entirely different entity and have nothing to do with decision-making at the branch in question?
2) Is it possible to simultaneously believe A) that the article was vile and should have never been published; and B) that the business department of a news organization should never, ever have the right to make editorial decisions in any way?
3) Is it also possible to believe that no matter how harmful or horrible an article may be, it should never be removed, because that's not how the internet works? Because you can't just make something go away? And because when a news organization makes mistakes, the best move is to update, apologize, correct, clarify, follow up... not to erase something and pretend it never happened?
This seems to indicate that the issue is more about ignorance of journalistic ethics than malice.