4 ms·
The Cowardice of Nick Denton
- minimaxir 11y agoThe odd thing about this entire kerfuffle is that other Gawker network writers argue that the story should have stayed because of journalistic integrity. Natasha Vargas-Cooper of Jezebel posted "Stories don't need an upside. Not everyone has to feel good about the truth." (https://twitter.com/natashavc/status/621858660319297536 https://twitter.com/natashavc/status/621858660319297536) and Jason Schreier of Kotaku posted an interesting list of considerations (http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=172267922#post172267922 http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=172267922#post1...): 1) If a separate branch of your company did something that disgusted you, would you jump on Twitter to criticize it, or would you take the time to have conversations internally and see what was being done rather than getting angry on social media? Even if you were unhappy after that, do you believe raging publicly would help? Especially when you work for an entirely different entity and have nothing to do with decision-making at the branch in question? 2) Is it possible to simultaneously believe A) that the article was vile and should have never been published; and B) that the business department of a news organization should never, ever have the right to make editorial decisions in any way? 3) Is it also possible to believe that no matter how harmful or horrible an article may be, it should never be removed, because that's not how the internet works? Because you can't just make something go away? And because when a news organization makes mistakes, the best move is to update, apologize, correct, clarify, follow up... not to erase something and pretend it never happened? This seems to indicate that the issue is more about ignorance of journalistic ethics than malice.
- rubbingalcohol 11y agoAgree 100% with this post. Gawker's response to this controversy demonstrates that they are amoral. Yes, they fucked up by posting it in the first place, but the response--removing the post and having the CEO issue this mealy-mouthed non-apology reflects an unscrupulous mentality. A) you can't take something back on the Internet, you can only discuss and move on from it, and B) Denton isn't sorry for posting, and his tone amounts to "I would have gotten away with it too, if it weren't for you meddling kids." Ever since Gizmodo got kicked out of CES for drunken stupidity I have not respected Gawker. Every time they sink to a new low, they embrace it with enthusiasm and pride. This latest example really shows their true colors though. Gawker has no moral compass. Anyone who advertises on any of their properties should be ashamed. Someone should dox all their executives and see how they like that. Bonus points for taking it down the next day and saying "sorry, not sorry."
- hristov 11y agoI should point out that this post shaming the Conde Nast CFO followed about three raving angry posts against reddit that were submitted on the same day. Reddit of course is owned by Conde Nast. Considering that gawker usually has no more than 10-20 posts per day on the main site, it is extremely unusual for four of them to be aimed at the same company. Furthermore, in an interview in pando daily, an ex Gawker editor said that Nick Denton once complained to him that silicon valley companies "do not fear me anymore." For someone that has followed Gawker for many years now it is becoming increasingly likely that Nick Denton is using Gawker to scare/blackmail other companies to do his bidding. Gawker has always had periods of intense criticisms of some company (Google for example) that start and end suddenly without rhyme or reason. The fact that Nick Denton eventually took down this post of course does not matter at all. The damage has been done. My guess is that old Nick Denton wants something out of Conde Nast, and that is why he is applying full pressure.
- dang 11y agoGawker has been banned on HN for years. Spillover gawkery seems just as off-topic, not that the indignation isn't justified. We've penalized this post, but won't kill it, because the thread has some good comments.
- Simulacra 11y agoI respectfully disagree with this on the grounds of hypocrisy. When the media splashes on the front pages the sordid sex lives of heterosexual people, no one bats and eye. It's eagerly repeated, reported, and becomes fodder for news pundits and comedians. Yet when it's a gay person, everyone loses their fucking minds. Why? I think that's hypocrisy and a double standard. I am a gay man and I think the outing of ANYONES private life, gay or straight or anything else, is a gross injustice.