4 ms·
This is what's known as "searching under the lamppost". Mathematicians would sometimes seek to prove only that which they suspect would be rather easy to prove,
by pron 11y ago
This is what's known as "searching under the lamppost". Mathematicians would sometimes seek to prove only that which they suspect would be rather easy to prove, so they construct the problem in such a way that the perceived difficulty is exactly that which is easily provable, thereby solving the problem. They then shove everything else (that is hard to prove) under their assumptions (which are sometimes very well-hidden), and say the problem is now mathematically solved!
Figuring out whether the research is applicable in practice then becomes a game not of validating the proof, but of uncovering all the assumptions.
I see it in the PL community, too, where, rather than starting by analyzing where software bugs actually lie and how expensive each kind of bug turns out to be, and then see how most expensive bugs can be prevented, they start with a programming model which is very easy to prove, construct programs that are easily expressed by the model, and then claim they've found a provably bug-free way to program.
The question of how many real-world programs can be easily transformed into the model, at what costs, and whether it is the expensive bugs that are actually prevented by the proof or rather the trivial ones is left as an exercise to the reader.
Of course, I don't blame them. If you don't start with what you strongly suspect you'll be able to prove, you might not get any publishable results at all.
- nullc 11y agoYour description sounds like intent, but it's important to keep in mind there is a selection force here. Ten earnest mathematicians try. 9 fail. The tenth structures the problem in such a way that the solution is meaningless but not obviously so-- his work gets published. But he doesn't know and certantly never intended to produce a meaningless proof. When useful proofs are harder to construct than difficult to detect as not useful trivial proofs, we should expect lots of the latter, even just by chance.
- pron 11y agoRight. It's not a conspiracy -- it's just what happens :) Also, I don't think that such work is meaningless in any way. Any discovery in math is meaningful in itself. It just isn't as applicable in real life as advertised (or the application is much more difficult than advertised).