3 ms·
> It was a deliberate exaggeration in order to highlight the absurdity of the actual arguments MOST geeks do make. And that's the unnecessary bit - by caricatu
by potatolicious 17y ago
> It was a deliberate exaggeration in order to highlight the absurdity of the actual arguments MOST geeks do make.
And that's the unnecessary bit - by caricaturing whatever real perceived problem there is you've both lost credibility and created a strawman where none needed to have been created.
If geeks make these absurd arguments, then repeat them, let your readers be the judge of it. As it is all you have are farcically exaggerated fake quotes, which does little to convince the reader that any problem even exists.
> I've heard various forms on those actually used
I've also heard new programmer hires exclaim "what's SQL?!". This doesn't mean it's a common (or even uncommon) occurrence. I too have met people (from all walks of life, mind you) who are vehemently against product placement and advertisement in any form... doesn't mean they are common, and certainly I do not get the impression this attitude is more prevalent in the geek community than elsewhere.
> "I'm bad with names" or "I'm not an artist" -- and then turning around and denigrating those skills that other people have taken the time & effort to develop.
I agree with you here, but again, this is not a problem unique to the geek community. It's a problem that seems to span all of humanity... e.g., "I'm no computer whiz / What a nerd!" Calling out the geek community on this is unnecessary and distracts from the fact that it's a far more fundamental human issue.
- ahoyhere 17y agoIf deliberate, humorous exaggeration in argument is wrong, I'm in some great company! e.g. Mark Twain, Oscar Wilde, yaddayadda. I'm not saying I'm half as good as they are, but your assertion that it shouldn't be used comes across as rather strident. And by adding your new programmer/what's SQL? argument, you fell into the same trap yourself. We're not going to agree, might as well not bother.
- anamax 17y ago> If deliberate, humorous exaggeration in argument is wrong, I'm in some great company! e.g. Mark Twain, Oscar Wilde, yaddayadda. Are you trying to do what they did? If not....