3 ms·
> If someone came to me and said "I did a self-selecting self-reporting survey of salaries, and it says I'm underpaid", I think I'd be more likely to fire them
by geofft 11y ago
> If someone came to me and said "I did a self-selecting self-reporting survey of salaries, and it says I'm underpaid", I think I'd be more likely to fire them for incompetence than to give them a raise.
OK, except that's not what's happening here. What seems to be happening here is someone saying "I did a self-reporting survey of salaries, and there's an existence proof that someone at my level is getting paid $X, can I get paid closer to $X than my current salary." Which is sound.
The statistics and pivot tables are very interesting, but I suspect they're not directly being used for negotiations. Nobody has any good information about how much money they should be asking for. The data this spreadsheet provides is that, if you ask for $X, it's within the range of reason, and not so high that you'll get laughed at.
If I apply for Google and try to negotiate a $200K salary, is that low? high? so high I'll get my offer revoked? (I've heard of that happening in tech!) I have no idea. Knowing even one person who works in my future role and makes $200K would be valuable information. So would knowing that I can't find anyone in that role making more than $110K. Knowing the mean and standard deviation of salaries at 95% confidence is not particularly more useful to me.
- cperciva 11y agoWhat seems to be happening here is someone saying "I did a self-reporting survey of salaries, and there's an existence proof that someone at my level is getting paid $X, can I get paid closer to $X than my current salary." Which is sound. It's sound modulo the assumption that everybody is being honest when they report their salaries, sure. Of course, in a company Google's size, there are always going to be outliers, so "someone at my level is getting paid $X" is a long way from "everybody at my level should be getting paid $X". If I apply for Google and try to negotiate a $200K salary, is that low? high? so high I'll get my offer revoked? (I've heard of that happening in tech!) I have no idea. Right, and that's the proper use of such anecdata -- to help you formulate your bargaining strategy, not as a bargaining chip itself. Ironically, if information like this had been available back in 2006, I might be working for Google: A few months after I rejected their offer, I was told that it was "pathetically low" and that I could have negotiated at least 50% more. If I had been offered that much more it might have factored into my decision; but I didn't know I could negotiate, so I ended up simply rejecting the offer.
- chetanahuja 11y ago"but I didn't know I could negotiate" This is shocking to me. Was it your first formal job offer?
- cperciva 11y agoYes.
- eitally 11y agoI have precisely the same fears. I have been relying on Glassdoor, which seems risky at best. A self-reported internal spreadsheet would be a lot more helpful.