2 ms·
If the argument of this paper is correct, I think it would be evidence against materialism. If you find a position has an implausible consequence, that is evide
by skissane 11y ago
If the argument of this paper is correct, I think it would be evidence against materialism. If you find a position has an implausible consequence, that is evidence against that position, especially if its competitors (e.g. dualism, idealism) lack that consequence.
- pcwalton 11y agoPanpsychism is common in dualism as well.
- skissane 11y agoI don't think panpsychism is common in dualism - the vast majority of dualists are not panpsychists. The argument of the paper is that "the United States is conscious" is a probable consequence of materialism. For your point to succeed, we'd need an argument that panpsychism is a probable consequence of dualism (or idealism, or so on), as opposed to merely a possibility compatible with it. Since materialists need to ground mental concepts in physical ones, they run the risk that their attempts to do so may have a broader scope than they intend (as this paper argues). Dualists don't need to ground the mental in the physical, so they don't run that risk.