3 ms·
Yes, certainly. But not American companies; not companies that purport to have American values. The principle of free speech was incorporated into our constitut
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Yes, certainly. But not American companies; not companies that purport to have American values. The principle of free speech was incorporated into our constitution, not because the idea started and ended there, but to push an American ideal into Government unequivocally. The ideal exists outside the constitution.
A private company can suppress free speech; it can perform searches and seizures on its grounds; it can profile and discriminate and have pay inequality. But it cannot claim any moral high ground. To say "at least we don't violate the letter of the constitution" is a shamefully low bar.
- incepted 11y ago> A private company can suppress free speech; it can perform searches and seizures on its grounds; it can profile and discriminate and have pay inequality. But it cannot claim any moral high ground. I don't think any company has ever tried to make such a silly claim. If they fire someone, it will usually be because that employee broke the terms of their employment contract which nobody forced them to sign in the first place.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoRight. Employee agreements that suppress free speech are kind of the subject of this thread.
- incepted 11y agoThat's the whole point: employee agreements do not suppress free speech. It's legal nonsense to claim that they do.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIf you define free speech as 'that part of the American value that is embodied in a Constitutional amendment' and take it no further. Be fair.